Darkseid Vs Superman:Validation of Superman's victories

Started by quanchi11233 pages

Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan
What's you point? He's not considered one of the definitive New Gods writers. I fail to see how a comment in his story overrules what actually went down elsewhere.

I didn't say that Starlin is the only writer who has portrayed Darkseid as a physical top tier. Although so far Starlin himself has not portrayed such a thing. In fact in Cosmic Odyssey Darkseid easily knocked away a charging Superman and barely unfolded his arms to do so. He could think that Superman's speed makes up for a strength advantage on Darkseid's part. Or he could have just meant that Superman is in Darkseid's ballpark, similar to the comments of Wonder Woman rivalling Superman. We don't even know how Starlin sees them matching up until he has a drawn out fight between them.

The point is that you can't claim one feat doesn't count because you like another story better.

Superman has beaten Darkseid once without help. He's been owned by Darkseid a number of times. Judging by their direct encounters, Darkseid would beat Superman about 70% of the time. If we look at how they match up against common opponents, it becomes much different because almost all comparisons point to Darkseid dwarfing Superman (like in Hunter/Prey).

But again, Superman was matched by Orion and stated to be rivalled by him in the exact comic you're referencing. You're constradicting yourself. How can DOTNG#2 support your idea of Superman > Darkseid > Orion when Superman is both stated and shown to be virtually equalled by Orion in the same comic?

I dont just count one feat but currently it looks as if Superman has physically caught up with Darkseid. Makes sense to me as Darkseid really rarely gets physical and usually relies on his powers alone. You are taking into consideration all of Darkseids appearances against superman But as I have tried to tell you things have obviously changed. Back in their first encounter all it took was a bitchslap but now you have we seen Darkseid rely on his omega effect to try and beat him. Its nowhere near as easy as it used to be.

You want to bring up hunter and prey fine. Another showing that Darkseid failed miserably in when meeting a much more physically intimidating opponent who Darkseid really didnt want to face. I can definitely see why.

Again how am i contradicting myself. Superman had an incomplete fight against orion. It wasnt like they fought for hours but was stopped prematurely. Darkseid recently owned orion in firestorm 35 right with his powers. Not physically. Darkseid is more than superman when his overall powers are concerned but as i have always maintained when they fail darkseid can fail. Fine me a recent thrashing of Orion by Darkseid by him manhandling Orion physically.

So what if superman had an inconclusive fight against orion that doesnt prove like you want it to that darkseid is above superman which he isnt as stated in the comic.

Just becuz you love Darkseid dont build him up into something that hes not. Times have changed and Superman isnt being defeated by a bitchslap anymore.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I dont just count one feat but currently it looks as if Superman has physically caught up with Darkseid. Makes sense to me as Darkseid really rarely gets physical and usually relies on his powers alone. You are taking into consideration all of Darkseids appearances against superman But as I have tried to tell you things have obviously changed. Back in their first encounter all it took was a bitchslap but now you have we seen Darkseid rely on his omega effect to try and beat him. Its nowhere near as easy as it used to be.

I really don't see much difference between the way Darkseid treated Superman in S/B#13 prior to the interference and how he treated him in Confidential#8. In both stories, DS appears to be putting the same amount of effort into his counter-attack. The only real difference is that he has a closed fist in S/B#13.

Anyway, what are you arguing? Are you saying that Superman was a normal top tier when he started, and now he's at a team basher level of strength? Or are you saying that Darkseid has always had top tier strength but Superman was like class 60 when he first started?

We have to put this in the context of the larger DCU.

Do you consider current Superman way above J'onn, Orion, CM, Supergirl, Powergirl, Lobo, WW, Captain Atom, etc. in strength? Do you consider Darkseid as merely on par with all of these people or way above them? Do you think Superman was on par with these beings in strength when he started out or was he significantly below them in your view?


You want to bring up hunter and prey fine. Another showing that Darkseid failed miserably in when meeting a much more physically intimidating opponent who Darkseid really didnt want to face. I can definitely see why.

There was no face to face encounter between Darkseid and Doomsday, although yes Doomsday did show he could take Darkseid out if he can get close enough and get an opening. And when Superman saw Darkseid afterward, he stated that he never thought it was possible to hurt DS.

Doomsday was wading through Superman's blasts, but was incoherent after one blast from Darkseid. Then Superman went all out for two pages and couldn't put a single dent in some Apokolips missiles, then a weakened Darkseid instantly vaporized them. Superman was also at a disadvantage against an upgraded Cyborg when Darkseid stepped in and vaporized the guy with one blast.

Darkseid was portrayed as incompetant in H/P but he was also shown to dwarf Superman in power. The scans are in the respect thread if you need to see what I'm talking about.

Again how am i contradicting myself. Superman had an incomplete fight against orion. It wasnt like they fought for hours but was stopped prematurely. Darkseid recently owned orion in firestorm 35 right with his powers. Not physically. Darkseid is more than superman when his overall powers are concerned but as i have always maintained when they fail darkseid can fail. Fine me a recent thrashing of Orion by Darkseid by him manhandling Orion physically.

Here's Darkseid manhandling Orion in Legion Foundations which came out in 2004:

http://img383.imageshack.us/my.php?image=legion29184gm.jpg

http://img383.imageshack.us/my.php?image=legion29198rc.jpg

http://img383.imageshack.us/my.php?image=legion29203ji.jpg

Orion was under the control of the older stone-form Darkseid at the time, but he didn't appear to have any problems from the mind control. As you can see the controlled Barda is standing toe to toe with Ultra Boy.

Darkseid also smacked Orion aside at the start of their fight in Orion #5. I always interpretted that fight as Darkseid being stronger but Orion's skills and speed winning out. Whatever though.


So what if superman had an inconclusive fight against orion that doesnt prove like you want it to that darkseid is above superman which he isnt as stated in the comic.

Let's get something clear -- saying that Superman rivals him does not mean that Superman equals him. Superman has been stated to be rivalled by Wonder Woman before, even though he has a noticable strength advantage. Darkseid's statement means only that Superman's physical stats are in the same ballpark as his, not that they are exact equals. Superman's speed is also a part of his physical stats. Starlin could very well hold the view that Darkseid is stronger but Superman's speed makes it competitive. Starlin could see Darkseid and Superman the way he wrote Pre-Crisis Mongul and Superman, where normally Mongul thrashed him but going all out Superman was close enough that he acheived a double KO on one occasion. We really don't know because the comment isn't specific. All it tells us is that Superman's physical stats are in the same ballpark as Darkseid's.

In the same comic, Orion islugs it out with Superman evenly for several pages. Darkseid also states that Superman and Orion could have "slaughtered each other." In fact, the Astro-Force appears to overpower Superman's heat vision. What the comic says about Orion and Superman is much clearer than what it says about Superman and Darkseid.

BTW, this fight was longer and more drawn out than the OWAW fight between Superman and Darkseid that you consider a stalemate.


Just becuz you love Darkseid dont build him up into something that hes not. Times have changed and Superman isnt being defeated by a bitchslap anymore. [/B]

Actually Superman pretty much was at Darkseid's mercy after a *****-slap in S/B.

And please don't bring up my love of Darkseid, especially considering your obvious love of Thanos. I can have some fun debating facts, but I'm really tired of getting into the "you're biased!" game. It's just not fun anymore. If you disagree with me, attack my points. Implying that someone is biased is not a legitimate debate tactic.

Originally posted by Jimmy-Chan
I really don't see much difference between the way Darkseid treated Superman in S/B#13 prior to the interference and how he treated him in Confidential#8. In both stories, DS appears to be putting the same amount of effort into his counter-attack. The only real difference is that he has a closed fist in S/B#13.

Anyway, what are you arguing? Are you saying that Superman was a normal top tier when he started, and now he's at a team basher level of strength? Or are you saying that Darkseid has always had top tier strength but Superman was like class 60 when he first started?

We have to put this in the context of the larger DCU.

Do you consider current Superman way above J'onn, Orion, CM, Supergirl, Powergirl, Lobo, WW, Captain Atom, etc. in strength? Do you consider Darkseid as merely on par with all of these people or way above them? Do you think Superman was on par with these beings in strength when he started out or was he significantly below them in your view?

There was no face to face encounter between Darkseid and Doomsday, although yes Doomsday did show he could take Darkseid out if he can get close enough and get an opening. And when Superman saw Darkseid afterward, he stated that he never thought it was possible to hurt DS.

Doomsday was wading through Superman's blasts, but was incoherent after one blast from Darkseid. Then Superman went all out for two pages and couldn't put a single dent in some Apokolips missiles, then a weakened Darkseid instantly vaporized them. Superman was also at a disadvantage against an upgraded Cyborg when Darkseid stepped in and vaporized the guy with one blast.

Darkseid was portrayed as incompetant in H/P but he was also shown to dwarf Superman in power. The scans are in the respect thread if you need to see what I'm talking about.

Here's Darkseid manhandling Orion in Legion Foundations which came out in 2004:

http://img383.imageshack.us/my.php?image=legion29184gm.jpg

http://img383.imageshack.us/my.php?image=legion29198rc.jpg

http://img383.imageshack.us/my.php?image=legion29203ji.jpg

Orion was under the control of the older stone-form Darkseid at the time, but he didn't appear to have any problems from the mind control. As you can see the controlled Barda is standing toe to toe with Ultra Boy.

Darkseid also smacked Orion aside at the start of their fight in Orion #5. I always interpretted that fight as Darkseid being stronger but Orion's skills and speed winning out. Whatever though.

Let's get something clear -- saying that Superman rivals him does not mean that Superman equals him. Superman has been stated to be rivalled by Wonder Woman before, even though he has a noticable strength advantage. Darkseid's statement means only that Superman's physical is in the same ballpark as his, not that they are exact equals.

Superman's speed is also a part of his physical stats. Starlin could very well hold the view that Darkseid is stronger but Superman's speed makes it competitive. Starlin could see Darkseid and Superman the way he wrote Pre-Crisis Mongul and Superman, where normally Mongul thrashed him but going all out Superman was close enough that he acheived a double KO on one occasion. We really don't know because the comment isn't specific. All it tells us is that Superman's physical stats are in the same ballpark as Darkseid's.

In the same comic, Orion is stated to be Superman's rival AND slugs it out with him evenly for several pages. Darkseid also states that Superman and Orion could have "slaughtered each other." In fact, the Astro-Force appears to overpower Superman's heat vision. What the comic says about Orion and Superman is much clearer than what it says about Superman and Darkseid.

BTW, this fight was longer and more drawn out than the OWAW fight between Superman and Darkseid that you consider a stalemate.

Actually Superman pretty much was at Darkseid's mercy after a *****-slap in S/B.

And please don't bring up my love of Darkseid, especially considering your obvious love of Thanos. I can have some fun debating facts, but I'm really tired of getting into the "you're biased!" game. It's just not fun anymore. If you disagree with me, attack my points. Implying that someone is biased is not a legitimate debate tactic.

Let the fun begin. How is Ds not putting more into his counterattack. I cannot believe you would have say this. All he did was backhand him in confidential whereas in the batman story he used his omega effect. That is his most powerful attack and why resort to it if he didnt have to. The counter punch failed whereas in the past its all it took. Can you see the difference? I mean can you?

Im saying over the years that Superman has become gradually more powerful when it comes to how he is perceived by writers. Darkseid has obviously gotten weaker than wha he used to be. I mean back in the day he rarely lost but then you have two losses to superman,the asspounding from doomsday, and the embarrassing shovel incident with raker where Darkseid didnt land one hit in.

I dont consider superman that much above jonn and friends there. Orion with what we have seen can hang with superman in a brawl becuz he tends to love that kind of a fight whereas Darkseid just wants to end it as soon as possible. He doesnt like fights that drag on and doesnt like to get his uniform dirty so to speak. That is the reason imo that superman can hang in there with orion whereas Darkseid doesnt fare as well later in the fights for two reasons.

1. Superman and orion really havent fought long enough for a winer to be decided so its kinda inconclusive.
2. Darkseid relies on his men and his powers to do the talking for him and doesnt have the experience the dog of war has in drawn out brawls. Darkseid does have an army watching his ass so one on one confrontations are hard to come by.

Doomsdayshowed he could take Darkseids most powerful attack after he crushed his planets defenses. Darkseid met him once before in a scan goober threw up and I believe Darkseid left and told steppenwulf not to tell anyone about this as he had nothing to gain but it stilled looked bad. Doomsday showed Darkseid is like a child to him and tha Ds couldnt mount one counterattack.

Oh yeah the comic I believe that you are tlaking about is Darkseid talking so he considers Superman a rival whereas before all he needed was a bitchslap.

Oh how times have changed.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Let the fun begin. How is Ds not putting more into his counterattack. I cannot believe you would have say this. All he did was backhand him in confidential whereas in the batman story he used his omega effect. That is his most powerful attack and why resort to it if he didnt have to. The counter punch failed whereas in the past its all it took. Can you see the difference? I mean can you?

1. I meant that the backhand in S/B#13 looked to be just as casual as the pimp-slap in Confidential.

2. In S/B#13 his goal was to kill Superman which is why he was about to use the beams after the backhand. In Confidential he was just getting Superman out of his hair.

The Omega Beam aspect really doesn't have anything to do with the topic. What I'm saying is that Darkseid physically responded to a flying charge from Superman with a nonchalant backhand, just as he did in Confidential.


Im saying over the years that Superman has become gradually more powerful when it comes to how he is perceived by writers. Darkseid has obviously gotten weaker than wha he used to be. I mean back in the day he rarely lost but then you have two losses to superman,the asspounding from doomsday, and the embarrassing shovel incident with raker where Darkseid didnt land one hit in.

1. What shovel incident? Raker was lifting a shovel and Darkseid was charging his Omegas when the Guardians stepped in. Two pages earlier, Raker hit Darkseid with an actual weapon and did no damage. There's no reason to assume a shovel would've hurt him, much less beaten the OE, when he took a shot from Raker with a real weapon without damage a couple pages earlier. And when the Omegas had just bursted one of Raker's constructs. As for landing no hits, the only hit Raker landed was with that weapon that launched himself and Darkseid into the air. Aside from that, they traded blows for one panel and that was pretty much it.

Also in the same comic Darkseid harmlessly held Raker's energy-charged ring in his hand with no damage and crushed it effortlessly.

2. There's no shame in being dropped by a sneak attack from Doomsday. Superman and Captain Marvel have each destroyed each other with sucker punches before. I can't think of a single portrayal where Darkseid was that far above Doomsday in terms of strength and durability. It's completely plausible that Doomsday's attacks could hurt even a high portrayal DS like that if he landed some clean shots. And this isn't even a recent comic.

3. Yes, he's jobbed to Superman. He's also owned Superman, the Legion, Firestorm, Orion, Etrigan, Eclipso, and Secret all fairly recently. And he ignored an attacking Supergirl like she wasn't there. So there are several recent showings where Darkseid looked as good as ever.

I dont consider superman that much above jonn and friends there. Orion with what we have seen can hang with superman in a brawl becuz he tends to love that kind of a fight whereas Darkseid just wants to end it as soon as possible. He doesnt like fights that drag on and doesnt like to get his uniform dirty so to speak. That is the reason imo that superman can hang in there with orion whereas Darkseid doesnt fare as well later in the fights for two reasons.

1. Superman and orion really havent fought long enough for a winer to be decided so its kinda inconclusive.
2. Darkseid relies on his men and his powers to do the talking for him and doesnt have the experience the dog of war has in drawn out brawls. Darkseid does have an army watching his ass so one on one confrontations are hard to come by.

This really doesn't jive with continuity.

1. Superman when he started out, like he was in Confidential, was repeatedly shown to be on par with J'onn, Etrigan, Orion, Lobo, M'onel, etc. physically. Wonder Woman admitted him to be stronger than her. He wrecked Maxima, who's given him trouble even since his death powerup. All of these people he was on par with back then still appear to be his rivals today.

2. Darkseid has plenty of showings of physical might above top tiers.

Doomsdayshowed he could take Darkseids most powerful attack after he crushed his planets defenses. Darkseid met him once before in a scan goober threw up and I believe Darkseid left and told steppenwulf not to tell anyone about this as he had nothing to gain but it stilled looked bad. Doomsday showed Darkseid is like a child to him and tha Ds couldnt mount one counterattack.

I've already covered H/P. As for DD Year One, the narration plainly stated that a HTH battle between the two would be a war, and DS refused to use the OE out of honor. He left when Steppenwolf informed him that the reason he came there in the first place (the chemicals) was destroyed.


Oh yeah the comic I believe that you are tlaking about is Darkseid talking so he considers Superman a rival whereas before all he needed was a bitchslap.

He stunned Superman in S/B with a casual backhand just like he did in Confidential. Incidentally, Superman has pimp-handed both Maxima and WW before, both of whom have been stated to rival him.


Oh how times have changed.

Yes times are changing, but not in the direction you imply:

http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=129373

NRAMA: So it’s going back to that early scene in the series, Darkseid playing the “chessboard” of the DC Universe – but still, even then, he came across as part observer, part puppet master…

DD: Darkseid at the chessboard is a theme that runs throughout the series, and moving the pieces around is something that Darkseid is very good at. Whether he does it on his own, or uses others to do it for him is something that will be revealed as the series moves on.

NRAMA: And Darkseid’s inclusion touches back on what you’d said building up to this all – that part of all of this was to get Darkseid back into fighting shape, back to being the threat that everyone fears, back to being the guy that even Superman (at least part of him) wants to run away from…

DD: Absolutely. That’s something that I feel very strongly about. What we’re doing right now is reestablishing Darkseid as the premiere villain or one of the premiere forces in the DCU. We’ve shown him in the past going toe to toe with so many other characters, so in some ways he was overexposed and undervalued in regards to his relationship. With this, we want to make very clear Darkseid’s reach, and the depths that he would go to to achieve his ultimate goals.

Superman shitstomps Darky.... Again. 😊

Originally posted by Galan007
Superman shitstomps Darky.... Again. 😊

scans?...131

Originally posted by Priest
scans?...131
*see damn near every encounter they've had* 😄

Originally posted by Galan007
*see damn near every encounter they've had* 😄

But those are invalid you see because of [insert one of a thousand sad excuses]

Originally posted by Val
But those are invalid you see because of [insert one of a thousand sad excuses]
It was an avatar!! durcry

Originally posted by Galan007
*see damn near every encounter they've had* 😄

Fail. 🙄

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Fail. 🙄

damn u responded faster than i thought. 😂

Originally posted by Priest
damn u responded faster than i thought. 😂

As long as DS currently is beating the shit out of Orion who is Superman's "equal" and making eclipso look a fool, Who is yet and still superior to the above the top tier, black mary, then DS is in fact beyond what people wish him to be.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Fail. 🙄

😊

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
As long as DS currently is beating the shit out of Orion who is Superman's "equal" and making eclipso look a fool, Who is yet and still superior to the above the top tier, black mary, then DS is in fact beyond what people wish him to be.

EDIT - NVM

Don't feel like getting involved in a Nvr debate right now.

Originally posted by Val
EDIT - NVM

Don't feel like getting involved in a Nvr debate right now.


You don't have to get into a debate with me. It's simply. When Thanos gets an upgrade, people talk about him in that Era. When DS gets repowered and an upgrade, all of a sudden it's a problem. I think that I might be motivated to make a Respect the beings DS has defeated or owned Thread. To put everything in perspective.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
You don't have to get into a debate with me. It's simply. When Thanos gets an upgrade, people talk about him in that Era. When DS gets repowered and an upgrade, all of a sudden it's a problem. I think that I might be motivated to make a Respect the beings DS has defeated or owned Thread. To put everything in perspective.

............

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
As long as DS currently is beating the shit out of Orion who is Superman's "equal" and making eclipso look a fool, Who is yet and still superior to the above the top tier, black mary, then DS is in fact beyond what people wish him to be.
Did Orion beat Superman in their recent fight. Nope didnt think. It was over before a winner could be decided. Ds may be able to may Orion look like a fool which he most certainly is but he cant really make Superman look like a fool.

Supes beats on ds from time to time while orion has yet to do so.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
You don't have to get into a debate with me. It's simply. When Thanos gets an upgrade, people talk about him in that Era. When DS gets repowered and an upgrade, all of a sudden it's a problem. I think that I might be motivated to make a Respect the beings DS has defeated or owned Thread. To put everything in perspective.
The ale isnt an upgrade and wont be used in the future becuz Darkseid will survive his death, it isnt the same thing although you desperately want it to be.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Did Orion beat Superman in their recent fight. Nope didnt think. It was over before a winner could be decided. Ds may be able to may Orion look like a fool which he most certainly is but he cant really make Superman look like a fool.

Supes beats on ds from time to time while orion has yet to do so.

IN the same book where you love to talk about what's stated about superman being the rival of DS physically, it says that Superman and Orion are so evenly matched that the fight wouldn't end. DS even says he would love to see them kill each other. You fail.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
IN the same book where you love to talk about what's stated about superman being the rival of DS physically, it says that Superman and Orion are so evenly matched that the fight wouldn't end. DS even says he would love to see them kill each other. You fail.
Orion tends to favor a physical battle and has more expereince than Darkseid in that regard. Supes can hang with orion while handing ds his ass. Different matchups and different results.