Galactus Vs. The Spectre · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Air Legend
An author doesn't have to blatantly say everything to get his point through.

👆

Especially when they smother us with related evidence that puts the puzzle together.

But anyways ... 🙂

Mr. Slippyfist Dead

Originally posted by Air Legend
🙄 That's not bashing. nvr would have been banned a long time ago if that was the case.

Ah... the old, "he did it, i want do it, i can do it!!!" approach.

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Galan007
Meant 'some' of your claims'.

I thought it was one.

"Some" indicates more than one, what other claim are you referring too?

Originally posted by Galan007
We have evidence to answer that question..

Right.
That evidence illustrates how Conceptual beings that guard their own realities,
create said realities that they guard.

Why are the Brothers different?

Especially when we take into account that they are exact replicas of the original Brothers,
who create realities with their own bodies (embodiment)

Originally posted by Galan007
Evidence is what we seem to be lacking concerning the Brothers...

I disagree friend.

A direct statement may be lacking,
but the evidence leans towards the idea
that the Brothers are the embodiments of their realities.

Mostly because they are exact replicas/duplicates of what the original Brothers were,
and what were the original Brothers?

Why embodiments of their realities of course. 🙂

Originally posted by Galan007
I'm not saying you're wrong,
just that I haven't seen enough to support your claim
that the Brothers were the actual embodiments of their respective Megaverses, yet.

Cool, that's your opinion and it's respected, but I disagree wtih it.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Mr Master
Mostly because they are exact replicas/duplicates of what the original Brothers were

Proof?

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Galan007
Proof?

You seriously want proof
that the Marvel Brothers are an exact rip-off of the original Brothers?

Tell me your messing with me brother G, cause now your scaring me. 😛

Air Legend Moderat0r

Originally posted by Galan007
Proof?

Cuz they looked exactly the same 😐

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted

Originally posted by Air Legend
Cuz they looked exactly the same 😐

That is proof? How many times has mystich looked exactly like someone else but wasn't?

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Mr Master
You seriously want proof
that the Marvel Brothers are an exact rip-off of the original Brothers?
Tell me your messing with me brother G, cause now your scaring me. 😛

You said they were the 'exact' same.

Yet the only solid on panel proof you have, is what they looked like? srsly

Using the same theory,
I guess Darkseid momentarily held the 'embodiment' of Mxy's power in the palm of his hand as well, eh?

Air Legend Moderat0r

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
That is proof? How many times has mystich looked exactly like someone else but wasn't?

Why don't you try reading a book or go back to school. Did Shakespeare blatanly say what the themes of his works were? Did Weird Al blatantly say in his song Eat It that the song was a parody of beat it? Did Mark Twain blatantly say in his book Huckleberry Finn that it was a satire.

Try using your brain for once.

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Galan007
You said they were the 'exact' same.
Yet the only solid on panel proof you have, is what they looked like?

Let's see,

The Name (Brothers)

The Look (exact replicas)

They're Architects (sharing the same job)

They're Guardians (serving the same purpose)

In the personal story of the Brothers is the same (They battle)
.......................................................................................

Because of this, I still think your messing with me. 😠

Originally posted by Galan007
Using the same theory,
I guess Darkseid momentarily held the 'embodiment' of Mxy's power in the palm of his hand as well, eh?

Using DC scans to prove something in Marvel comics.

You should know better. 🙂

The Great Galen Restricted

So wait just so were all clear, Spectre takes this.....oh and Spectre and LT are equal in power.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Mr Master
Let's see,
The Name (Brothers)
The Look (exact replicas)
They're Architects (sharing the same job)
They're Guardians (serving the same purpose)
In the personal story of the Brothers is the same (They battle)

Must have missed the part where it says what they embody? 😕

Originally posted by Mr Master
Using DC scans to prove something in Marvel comics.
You should know better. 🙂

No difference really.... as neither were stated on panel to be the actual embodiment of said power. 🙂

On a sidenote,
Is Roma the embodiment of the Omniverse? She does guard it, afterall. 🙂

Air Legend Moderat0r

Originally posted by Galan007
Must have missed the part where it says what they embody? 😕

Logic dictates that. Do you have logic?

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Air Legend
Logic dictates that. Do you have logic?

Enough logic to know that when I'm debating, I'd like to see solid evidence before I take what people are saying to heart?

Yep. 🙂

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Galan007
Must have missed the part where it says what they embody? 😕

This oughta help your confusion:

Originally posted by Galan007
No difference really....
as neither were stated on panel to be the actual embodiment of said power.

Actually infinitely huge difference, diffrent comic book companies.

Just don't try an make a point for Marvel by using DC scans please. 🙂

Originally posted by Galan007
On a sidenote,
Is Roma the embodiment of the Omniverse? She does guard it, afterall.

Silly question, that can only lead to a degrading debate. 🙁

When has Roma ever been stated to be the embodiment of the Omniverse?

Never.

When have the Brothers ever been stated to be embodiments?

3 Months before they became Marvel property.
...............................................................................

And you ignored the relevance of my post:

Commonalities betweeen the Original Brothers .... and the Retcon Brothers.

They have the same Name ... (Brothers)

The have the same Look (exact replicas)

They have the same job (Architects)

They serve the same purpose (Guardians)

They have the same personal story (The Brothers battle)

They even use the same weapons (Swords)

....................................................................................

But you believe this isn't proof enough they were the same Brothers (embodiments)

....................................................................................

Nothing more to say. As you wish. 🙂

Air Legend Moderat0r

Originally posted by Galan007
Enough logic to know that when I'm debating, I'd like to see solid evidence before I take what people are saying to heart?
Yep. 🙂

They have the same Name ... (Brothers)

The have the same Look (exact replicas)

They have the same job (Architects)

They serve the same purpose (Guardians)

They have the same personal story (The Brothers battle)

They even use the same weapons (Swords)

That's enough solid evidence (source Mr Master). Now you just have to use your brain and connect the peices because an author is not going to blatantly write everything out.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Mr Master
When has Roma ever been stated to be the embodiment of the Omniverse?

About as many times as the post-retcon Brothers have been stated as the embodiments of Megaverses. 🙂

Originally posted by Mr Master
When have the Brothers ever been stated to be embodiments?
3 Months before they became Marvel property.

You mean 3 months before their retcon?

Meh,
I guess nothing about a character changes when they're retconned, huh?

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Galan007
About as many times
as the post-retcon Brothers have been stated as the embodiments of Megaverses.

It seems you don't get it, or dont want to. Fine.

Originally posted by Galan007
You mean 3 months before their retcon?
Meh,
I guess nothing about a character changes when they're retconned, huh?

Something did change, they went from being the embodiment of Marvel & DC,
to just being the embodiments of Two Marvel Megaverses.

So yea, I guess things DO change. 🙂

This sarcasm you're trying to pull will contiue to backfire.
..............................................................................................

On a side note,

If you want a scan that relates to this,

LT holding the embodiments of the Brothers in his hand:

This is more appropriate ... and it's from Marvel ... not DC.

THOTI/Thanos holds the embodiment of Eternity in his hand:

And I could care less about Mxy/Joker & Darkseid,

but yea, that is the embodiment of Eternity's power in Thanos' hand.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Mr Master
It seems you don't get it, or dont want to. Fine.

lol.

Roma = the Omniversal Guardian (stated on panel).
The Brother's = Megaversal Guardians (stated on panel).

You say the Brothers, (who once again were only stated as Megaversal Guardians), embody these Megaverses -- So why wouldn't Roma (stated as the Omniversal Guardian), embody the Omniverse?

I'm only using the same theories your giving me, other ways. 🙂

Originally posted by Mr Master
Something did change, they went from being the embodiment of Marvel & DC,
to just being the embodiments of Two Marvel Megaverses.
So yea, I guess things DO change. 🙂

Once again,
You have no other proof than your personal opinion on what they embody, as such a question hasn't been positively answered, on panel... Yet. 🙂

Originally posted by Mr Master
This sarcasm you're trying to pull will contiue to backfire.

Sarcasm? No. 🙂

Mr Master Junior Member

Originally posted by Galan007
Roma = the Omniversal Guardian (stated on panel).
The Brother's = Megaversal Guardians (stated on panel).
You say the Brothers, (who once again were only stated as Megaversal Guardians), embody these Megaverses -- So why wouldn't Roma (stated as the Omniversal Guardian), embody the Omniverse?

Believe this was addressed right here:

Originally posted by Mr Master
When has Roma ever been stated to be the embodiment of the Omniverse?
Never.
When have the Brothers ever been stated to be embodiments?
3 Months before they became Marvel property.
...............................................................................
And you ignored the relevance of my post:
Commonalities betweeen the Original Brothers .... and the Retcon Brothers.
They have the same Name ... (Brothers)
The have the same Look (exact replicas)
They have the same job (Architects)
They serve the same purpose (Guardians)
They have the same personal story (The Brothers battle)
They even use the same weapons (Swords)
....................................................................................
But you believe this isn't proof enough they were the same Brothers (embodiments)
....................................................................................
🙂

Originally posted by Galan007
I'm only using the same theories your giving me, other ways.

No you're not.

As Roma being confused with being a "Concept" is impossible, since she NEVER was one.

On the other hand,

the Brothers WERE Concepts in DC vs Marvel ... so at least there's a debate there.

My whole argument isn't based on the "Guardians" title, that's your whole argument.

I have plenty of indirect evidence that intimately relates to details concerning the Brothers.
(As re-posted above in this post)

Originally posted by Galan007
Once again,
You have no other proof than your personal opinion on what they embody, as such a question hasn't been positively answered, on panel... Yet.

Except the fact that not only were Brothers Conceptual embodiments,
but they share every single other trait with the current Brothers
including their historical relationship. (they Battle with Swords) 😂

But yea, Marvel probably left that part out.

Anyway dogs, I'm done on this one, let's agree to disagree I guess. 🙂