Jesus christ..........you guys are arguing for something so out of left field, so screwball and against established canon&fact, that it looks like it was written by Mcduffie. 👇
I call bullshit on this thread and the extreme bias towards Thor. He may get the majority, I can live with that, though I don't agree. But saying he curbstomps Hal Jordan? Horseshit. nono
Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Jesus christ..........you guys are arguing for something so out of left field, so screwball and against established canon&fact, that it looks like it was written by Mcduffie. 👇I call bullshit on this thread and the extreme bias towards Thor. He may get the majority, I can live with that, though I don't agree. But saying he curbstomps Hal Jordan? Horseshit. nono
what are you, some kind of neutral? shock
Originally posted by TricksterPriestI actually agree. I think he would get the majority over Hal, but DEFINATELY not curb.
Jesus christ..........you guys are arguing for something so out of left field, so screwball and against established canon&fact, that it looks like it was written by Mcduffie. 👇I call bullshit on this thread and the extreme bias towards Thor. He may get the majority, I can live with that, though I don't agree. But saying he curbstomps Hal Jordan? Horseshit. nono
Originally posted by Raoul
just because it hasn't been done (bar john) doesn't mean it can't, though, does it?
Uh, sorry. I'm not willing to discard years of continuity based on a single ridiculous page. Geoff Johns be damned... 😬
Originally posted by Raoul
i meant limitless in terms of what you can do with sufficient charge...
That's the first time I've seen a ring straight up quit on a task that had nothing to do with its charging. So...
Originally posted by Raoul
in fairness though, how many gl's do we know that have tried to recreate a solar system? its a huge task... the guardians've lied before, and considering it takes a truly exceptional gl to reach the level of hal or john, it could have easily been maintained that a gl was only limited by his own imagination or willpower...
The Guardians have lied before? So are you trying to tell me that you'd go along with a single page dumped on us even though the history of the Green Lanterns tell us otherwise? This whole idea is ridiculous.
And it's not as if creating a solar system is the best feat a Green Lantern has ever done before. People can throw all the Geoff Johns wanking they want at me, but I'll still consider that crap writing.
Originally posted by batdude123
Uh, sorry. I'm not willing to discard years of continuity based on a single ridiculous page. Geoff Johns be damned... 😬
i'm not saying anyone should, just that isn't at least within the realm of possibility that the ring, charge permitting, has limits?
That's the first time I've seen a ring straight up quit on a task that had nothing to do with its charging. So...
i googled and googled, but can't seem to find an interview where johns explains what he means...
The Guardians have lied before? So are you trying to tell me that you'd go along with a single page dumped on us even though the history of the Green Lanterns tell us otherwise? This whole idea is ridiculous.
No, i'm not...
And it's not as if creating a solar system is the best feat a Green Lantern has ever done before. People can throw all the Geoff Johns wanking they want at me, but I'll still consider that crap writing.
we're talking about creating a solar system in its entirety... planets full of people with their own lives and buildings and everything...
i mean, for all we know, john was trying to literally recreate the entire thing, not just constructs, but create life out of nothingness...
Originally posted by batdude123
Uh, sorry. I'm not willing to discard years of continuity based on a single ridiculous page. Geoff Johns be damned... 😬That's the first time I've seen a ring straight up quit on a task that had nothing to do with its charging. So...
The Guardians have lied before? So are you trying to tell me that you'd go along with a single page dumped on us even though the history of the Green Lanterns tell us otherwise? This whole idea is ridiculous.
And it's not as if creating a solar system is the best feat a Green Lantern has ever done before. People can throw all the Geoff Johns wanking they want at me, but I'll still consider that crap writing.
Originally posted by batdude123
I know mentioning something like that is taboo around here, especially since they\'re close to evenly matched in the power department, and because Thor is "teh gawd of thunda!!!" However, tell me something; what makes Thor immune to having his blood transmuted? Has he ever resisted something of this manner?Now, this isn\'t me saying Hal will do this in a fight against Thor. I\'m just questioning the reasons as to why people might not think it\'s valid.
A valid question. Here's why:
One: Thor can transmute matter himself. Anyone with a similar power is most likely immune to it, or could reverse its affects.
Two: Gods, much like Eternals, won't be killed by anything except things at the molecular dispersion level. Such god-like durability (excuse the pun) is bound to hinder transmutation attempts.
Three: Mjolnir's magical nature, ability to absorb all manner of attacks (psychic, energy, magical, etc.) means that such an attack would probably have a hard time working at all since he could negate it.
Four: It's never been done, except by the Infinity Gauntlet
Does that means he's 100% for sure immune? No. But it's a pretty strong case against it.
Originally posted by Dark-Jaxx
I actually agree. I think he would get the majority over Hal, but DEFINATELY not curb.
A reasonable stance.
Originally posted by DigiMark007
A valid question. Here's why:One: Thor can transmute matter himself. Anyone with a similar power is most likely immune to it, or could reverse its affects.
Two: Gods, much like Eternals, won't be killed by anything except things at the molecular dispersion level. Such god-like durability (excuse the pun) is bound to hinder transmutation attempts.
Three: Mjolnir's magical nature, ability to absorb all manner of attacks (psychic, energy, magical, etc.) means that such an attack would probably have a hard time working at all since he could negate it.
Four: It's never been done, except by the Infinity GauntletDoes that means he's 100% for sure immune? No. But it's a pretty strong case against it.
Originally posted by darthgoober
Its not direct evidence of Thor resisting molecular transmutation, but here's an instance of Thor resisting having his molecules "frozen"...
http://img397.imageshack.us/img397/7105/avengersv101410ma2.jpg
http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/2133/avengersv101411vw7.jpg
http://img396.imageshack.us/img396/5940/avengersv101412bc0.jpg
👆
Silver age comics are the best! Kallusian minion, "I have frozen your molecules... but have left you the ability to hear my leader's bad-guy speech! Do not question the science behind our molecule-freezing ray gun! You Earthlings would never understand our superior Kallusian technology! 'Klaatu barada niktu,' our lightly shaded purple a$$es!"
😂
Originally posted by OneDumbG0 I respectfully disagree with the above assessment._ ^_^Classic Thor._ Not easily.Current Odinforce Thor who can recreate an entire pantheon of Gods and their entire kingdom and keep it floating over Oklahoma?_ Very easily.One would assume that the thread started meant Classic Thor. One would also assume one would assume that Thor would get shot with a green bullet and faint.
