Originally posted by fangirl101Considering that forum rules state that you should always assume current incarnations unless stated otherwise... I would again respectfully disagree. And considering I've never seen classic Thor faint from getting shot with a bullet... again... I respectfully disagree.
One would assume that the thread started meant Classic Thor. One would also assume one would assume that Thor would get shot with a green bullet and faint.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Considering that forum rules state that you should always assume current incarnations unless stated otherwise... I would again respectfully disagree. And considering I've never seen classic Thor faint from getting shot with a bullet... again... I respectfully disagree.
You've never seen Thor faint from a bullet? Um yes, he has fainted from a bullet before.
classic thor was awful when it came to machine gun fire, iirc, the modern one on the other hand, is superman-like when it comes to standing there looking bored as the bullets bounce off of him...
i'd say current hal beats classic thor (and not just using machine gun fire), but if this current thor is as powerful as is claimed, then he should take it...
that said, if i was writing the comic, i couldn't write hal beating any version of thor... something about him being a god, i dunno...
Originally posted by Raoul classic thor was awful when it came to machine gun fire, iirc, the modern one on the other hand, is superman-like when it comes to standing there looking bored as the bullets bounce off of him...i'd say current hal beats classic thor (and not just using machine gun fire), but if this current thor is as powerful as is claimed, then he should take it...that said, if i was writing the comic, i couldn't write hal beating any version of thor... something about him being a god, i dunno...A god who runs around with Superheroes? And let's the Hulk whoop on his ass? There have always been major Gods and lessor ones. If One were to look at the length of comics history, Silver Surfer would seem more Godlike than Thor.
Originally posted by fangirl101
A god who runs around with Superheroes? And let's the Hulk whoop on his ass? There have always been major Gods and lessor ones. If One were to look at the length of comics history, Silver Surfer would seem more Godlike than Thor.
i'd have hal beat norrin (though not all the time), but not thor...
Originally posted by fangirl101
See, I would have SS kicking Thor's ass and probably at least half on Hal. Especially with those new suck ass rings.
i'd have ss take thor for a majority...
i'd hal take an even split against norrin...
i'd have thor take a majority against hal...
yeah, it doesn't make sense... 😛
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
I respectfully disagree with the above assessment. ^_^Classic Thor. Not easily.
Current Odinforce Thor who can recreate an entire pantheon of Gods and their entire kingdom and keep it floating over Oklahoma? Very easily.
He woke them up, he didn't recreate them. And Asgard floating is impressive, but fairly worthless for battle purposes. I agree Thor wins, but the Current Thor wankfest in the forum as opposed to Classic annoys me a bit.
Originally posted by Raoul
i'd have ss take thor for a majority...i'd hal take an even split against norrin...
i'd have thor take a majority against hal...
yeah, it doesn't make sense... 😛
No, it does. Strengths and weaknesses rarely match up in an A>B>C manner with similarly-powered characters. And this matches fairly well with forum consensus as well, though quite a few would give Surfer a slight majority on Hal.
Originally posted by fangirl101
I can agree.
Originally posted by draxx_tOfU
👆
glad i'm not the only one...
Originally posted by DigiMark007
No, it does. Strengths and weaknesses rarely match up in an A>B>C manner with similarly-powered characters. And this matches fairly well with forum consensus as well, though quite a few would give Surfer a slight majority on Hal.
if i had to choose one over the other, i'd pick norrin over hal... though thats probably because ss was the first comic i've ever read...
Originally posted by Raoul
if i had to choose one over the other, i'd pick norrin over hal... though thats probably because ss was the first comic i've ever read...
I was originally a Thor-backer vs. Norrin. But was swayed the other direction by the forum (though I still think Thor takes some). Surfer really is the class of his power level, despite almost equally as impressive feats from the likes of Thor and Hal. They're really the A-list talent at herald, so there's not really a wrong answer.
Originally posted by DigiMark007
I was originally a Thor-backer vs. Norrin. But was swayed the other direction by the forum (though I still think Thor takes some). Surfer really is the class of his power level, despite almost equally as impressive feats from the likes of Thor and Hal. They're really the A-list talent at herald, so there's not really a wrong answer.
yeah, i know what you mean... i'd generally give norrin the nod over anyone in his field, even clark... and god knows i've looked for ways for clark to take him...
Originally posted by Raoul
yeah, i know what you mean... i'd generally give norrin the nod over anyone in his field, even clark... and god knows i've looked for ways for clark to take him...
😂
Originally posted by Newjak
Did anyone read the recent Nova.Silver Surfer took Nova's best unfazed. He appeared to be on a whole new level in that comic.
He is the basically the be all end all of that power level.
No argument. Though I'd caution against wanking him too hard. He's still the class of top tier herald, nothing more. Soon we'll be hearing teh Sub-Skyfather chants, which I think would be a mistake.
Originally posted by DigiMark007I yeah I definitely wouldn't put him that far.
😂No argument. Though I'd caution against wanking him too hard. He's still the class of top tier herald, nothing more. Soon we'll be hearing teh Sub-Skyfather chants, which I think would be a mistake.
Originally posted by RaoulYou need to. If for nothing else then the absolute sweet feat Silver Surfer pulls off in it. It is just sweet. 😛
i keep meaning to read that nova... dammit...