Revan vs Anakin

Just for getting out of a long and boring arguement sakes, I will say this.

THey are very similar. both are mechanically adept, both won important pod races, both turned to the darkside, and both are amaizing duelists with amaizing power and are set to an amaizing storyline. why anakin was in a movie instead of revan escapes me.

Maybe Revan was even modeled after anakin because anakin was such a great storyline.

I will say that I defenitely think that Revan is Smarter, More adept to the force, and more experienced then anakin. I think they might actually tie with lightsabers.... maybe. all out, revan would win. just sabers, I do not know the outcome.

Maybe they even have the same ammount of skill? this is one that only george lucas could answer.

Well, that's some progress coming from you... you're still wrong, though.

Originally posted by 0°Mandalore°0
definitely on the 'top 10', but I will say it again: Revan is not a better duelist than Anakin. You just can't see admit that.

Honestly I'm not sure if Revan is in the top 10 overall anymore

I would put Exar Kun,Sidious,Mace,Yoda,Anakin,Luke skylwaker,Kyle Katarn,Bane, Dooku,Kasim over him.

Then there are others that an argument could be made for such as Anoon Bondara,Maul is a good saber duelist,not sure where Kyp Durron ranks in this,Ulic has a shot,Cin might have a chance.

Than we have the Tulak Hord and the ridiculous opinion from Kreia. But I'll till more details is known before I'll make a decision for that.

I'd says he falls somewhere from 10th (at the highest but i doubt it) to the 15 range. We need more details on his known duels as to where to truly rank him. But based on what we know this is where he is for me.

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Honestly I'm not sure if Revan is in the top 10 overall anymore

I would put Exar Kun,Sidious,Mace,Yoda,Anakin,Luke skylwaker,Kyle Katarn,Bane, Dooku,Kasim over him.

Then there are others that an argument could be made for such as Anoon Bondara,Maul is a good saber duelist,not sure where Kyp Durron ranks in this,Ulic has a shot,Cin might have a chance.

Than we have the Tulak Hord and the ridiculous opinion from Kreia. But I'll till more details is known before I'll make a decision for that.

I doubt Drallig, Bondara, Kas'im, or even Bane are over him.

Although, I'll say Revan is definitely not in the 'top 5', by any means.

Originally posted by 0°Mandalore°0
On second thought, you're probably right. Although, I would say Revan is in the 'top 15'.

I don't think Bondara, Drallig, or Kas'im are over him, though.

Drallig I only put because he was the battle master but i doubt it as well.

Boondara was said to be the best duelist in the entire order in Shadow Hunter (right before TPM) So he has good chance at the least and the same would go for Maul since Anoon couldn't best him in saber combat and Kas'im is a master of all the forms and is weapon master of the sith academy. Nebaris can make a good argument for him since i don't remember all the details about him.

Although, I'll say Revan is definitely not in the 'top 5', by any means.

I agree even if there were details known about him I'd still rank Kun,Sidious,Mace,Yoda,Luke,Kyle and Jacen above him.

or even Bane are over him.

Bane with orbalisks takes him down.

what are orbalisks?

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Drallig I only put because he was the battle master but i doubt it as well.

Boondara was said to be the best duelist in the entire order in Shadow Hunter (right before TPM) So he has good chance at the least and the same would go for Maul since Anoon couldn't best him in saber combat and Kas'im is a master of all the forms and is weapon master of the sith academy. Nebaris can make a good argument for him since i don't remember all the details about him.

Hmm... yes, I had forgotten he had defeated PoD Bane in a saber combat, after all.

Although, I doubt Maul or Bondara could take him down.

Bane with orbalisks takes him down.

Yes, he does, but without them, I don't think he does... he gives Revan a hell of a fight, though.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=477142&pagenumber=4

well at least I won one

although Im not admitting any of you have won this one. I am just tired of arguing the same arguement to the same arguement over and over again.

Revan would still beat anakin all out just by using his force

and I think revan would be in the top 5 or six force wise... sideous, yoda, Nadd, kun, revan, nihilus....

but what are the orbalisks?

Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=477142&pagenumber=4

well at least I won one

although Im not admitting any of you have won this one. I am just tired of arguing the same arguement to the same arguement over and over again.

Revan would still beat anakin all out just by using his force

and I think revan would be in the top 5 or six force wise... sideous, yoda, Nadd, kun, revan, nihilus....

Yes, forcewise, maybe he is.

There you go. http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Orbalisk

Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=477142&pagenumber=4

well at least I won one

although Im not admitting any of you have won this one. I am just tired of arguing the same arguement to the same arguement over and over again.

Um I was never debating you or any1 in that thread considering i was just mentioning a few points and i said i agreed with alot of what you said. Though no offense if we ask any member here they would think I won this debate.

Revan would still beat anakin all out just by using his force

and I think revan would be in the top 5 or six force wise... sideous, yoda, Nadd, kun, revan, nihilus....

you probably won because there is not alot of "canon" material about revan's lightsaber skills.

Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
you probably won because there is not alot of "canon" material about revan's lightsaber skills.

true... I dont know much about the thought bomb. I thought it was a device.

....

You still don't know?

its a force ceremony?

Here, acknowledge yourself.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Thought_bomb

I'd like you to name ONE Jedi or Sith in the KOTOR era who compares with Yoda, Mace, Kenobi, or Sidious.

Sion- invincible
Nihilus- unbelievably powerful, able to hold a ship together and has the skill to use the Force on Billions of individuals at the same time
Kriea- Also powerful, and can fight with out hands
Revan- Nuff said
Exile- Unlimited, a wound in the Force unbeatable, war hardened
Malak- able to use star forge and compare with Revan
Exar Kun- Nuff said
Ulric Qel'Droma- Stood up to Kun and beat That Nadd guy and that Zombie
Nomi Sunrider- able to separate people from the Force and is a powerful jedi in her own right

DO NOT say that the KOTOR lot can't compare. You're just wrong

saber wise? Revan would go down though it will not be pwnage on either side.

I disagree.

Again clear minded anakin would TOOL revan in a saber combat.

Theres no such thing.