EVANGEL94's Final Slugfest Tournament Discussion Thread: Questions, Comments, & Talk

Started by Papa Smurph76 pages

Nope, it's classic Kent. Given Strange has access to his old stuff

why's this up for discussion?

Unless we're buying into that stalemating Spectre foolishness.

Can someone highlight a feat that Fate's done that dwarfs Surfer/Warlock/GL/Superman/Hulk/Gladiator's top feats?

And no, getting your ass kicked by Spectre and saying you're no match for him is not IMO a good example.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
Can someone highlight a feat that Fate's done that dwarfs Surfer/Warlock/GL/Superman/Hulk/Gladiator's top feats?
Curiously enough, the same thing (far less, in fact) was asked about Mogo. I'm still waiting on even base reasoning for his potential ban.

Just to point that out.

Dr. Fate's Marvel analog/= is Dr. Strange
Mogo's Marvel analog/= is Ego the Living Planet.

Though I guess Ego would be acceptable with his piss poor on panel feats that include losses to the Thor bros and Silver Surfer.

And the Sentry level feat of Stalemating Galactus

Not to mention Kent Nelson isn't a planet with the Helmet of Nabu

Hasn't Quasar beaten Ego too while I'm at it?

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
Dr. Fate's Marvel analog/= is Dr. Strange
Mogo's Marvel analog/= is Ego the Living Planet.
It's hard to respond to this without saying something insulting...

According to their respective companies...

Wolverine's analog is Lobo
Quicksilver's analog is Flash

If you had any proof or reasoning to back up the statement "Mogo = Ego", I suggest you post so. This drivel about a Planet > Herald for pages without even an explanation to back up the statement is characteristic of the worst trolls.

You're running out of time, and still haven't given anything resembling an actual solid argument.

No evidence is needed. It's simple logic.

Sentient Planet>Human, so Sentient Planet GL>Human GL.

Originally posted by King Kandy
No evidence is needed. It's simple logic.

Sentient Planet>Human, so Sentient Planet GL>Human GL.

That's not at all logical.

Bear > Human

Bear with machine gun in paws> Human with machine gun in hands?

Originally posted by SmurphSmash!
That's not at all logical.

Bear > Human

Bear with machine gun in paws> Human with machine gun in hands?

Because a bear understands what a machine gun is........

pick hal jordan and be done with it. mogo gets either materialized primarily outside the battle field or dies materializing into it. do us and yourself a favor by picking another gl that doesn't jeopardize this great tournament. if this tournament gets canned cause of bickering, the guilty parties are just reinforcing stereotypes of comicbook fans. for the sake of fun end it already.

Originally posted by SmurphSmash!
That's not at all logical.

Bear > Human

Bear with machine gun in paws> Human with machine gun in hands?


Assuming they both have equal capacity to use the machine gun, yes.

Mogo and other Gls have equal capability to use the ring.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
pick hal jordan and be done with it. mogo gets either materialized primarily outside the battle field or dies materializing into it. do us and yourself a favor by picking another gl that doesn't jeopardize this great tournament. if this tournament gets canned cause of bickering, the guilty parties are just reinforcing stereotypes of comicbook fans. for the sake of fun end it already.

He's not, he's just going to continue to ask everybody to drop common sense and prove a negative.

be a bigger man then, it's not that hard.

Originally posted by King Kandy
Assuming they both have equal capacity to use the machine gun, yes.

Mogo and other Gls have equal capability to use the ring.

And yet Hal and Kyle's use of the ring dwarf most GL's, despite equal capability.

You've said nothing about skill, willpower, creativity or feats.

You haven't even stated what being a sentient planet gives him.

Only that it means he's big. Whoop-de-doo.

think about this. your or your opposition are going to get carpal tunnel syndrome debating if one character is legit, if thats not lame i dont know what is. I think its best if we skip the annoying arguing and get to the arguing that can get you the bragging rights that you are trying to get in this current argument, and the bragging rights here are pre mature

Originally posted by psycho gundam
pick hal jordan and be done with it. mogo gets either materialized primarily outside the battle field or dies materializing into it. do us and yourself a favor by picking another gl that doesn't jeopardize this great tournament. if this tournament gets canned cause of bickering, the guilty parties are just reinforcing stereotypes of comicbook fans. for the sake of fun end it already.
Seeing as my pick is being questioned, and I am simply asking the bitching parties to put up or shut up, I don't see why I am being warned about bickering.

Furthermore, Evangel and I have each personally addressed the battlefield issue, and that it is no longer a problem.

then just ask for the circumference of mogo be reduced then, or is his size your motivation to argue?

Originally posted by SmurphSmash!
And yet Hal and Kyle's use of the ring dwarf most GL's, despite equal capability.

Note that none of these GL's are living planets.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
then just ask for the circumference of mogo be reduced then, or is his size your motivation to argue?
The battlefield size is being increased.

And, looking at my picks, it shouldn't be hard to deduce I can simply do it myself.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
be a bigger man then, it's not that hard.

IDRC anymore, but my son's insistence on starting stuff after being warned has peaked my interest.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
Note that none of these GL's are living planets.
So, now to the core of why you have no argument.

I was saying that Hal/Kyle's use of the ring dwarfs that of most other humans.

So, feel free to explain how Mogo can use the ring more adequately than either of them.