Yoda versus Dumbledore (the Force versus Hogwarts magic)

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Perspective is how YOU PERSONALLY see things and everyone can see it differently. Now they sure are not slow as once cast it hit snape almost instantly.
Whether Yoda can dodge it is irrelevant as it would follow him and with his small stature he would be knocked over and dumbledore could just go on a barrage of that spell as well. So now dumbledore can turn Yoda into a ferret or take him out using those fire spells or any other transfiguration spell.

Are you kidding me? Took close to a second to travel from Mcgonagol to Snape per shot. That is NOT instant by any stretch of the imagination. And FYI, all the shots from that specific fight were forward moving.

You need to prove that they were tracking cuz I don't see where they were tracking him here.

Proof:

http://youtu.be/H1U1tjdg2K8

It took from 2:40-2:41 to shoot and connect. And it fired forward, not in a tracking fashion.

Heck, she couldn't even shoot him down when he was trying to get away.

Yoda slams him with a force push before his first shot even lands for the KO.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Eh? TCW is canon and TV "feats" are allowed here as long as it is canon to the character.

Yeah, the rules he obviously didn't read clearly state the following:

8) Characters from televised movies are allowed for versus matches, but characters from an actual TV series are not allowed, since, obviously, the tv series is not a movie. Characters who have appeared on both television and on film (Star Trek, 24, etc) are allowed for versus matches. Star Trek, for example, has numerous tv shows of different franchises as well as motion pictures and it seems only fair to allow feats from both in versus matches. Remember, though: Characters who have appeared on television ONLY cannot be used in the Movie Versus Forum.

The Clone Wars is canon to the Star Wars movie universe. As in the characters as they are portrayed in the films are the same characters as they are portrayed in the series. So any Clone Wars feats are also relevant to this match.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
I was waiting on you to do that yes TCW is cannon but not the movies. So therefore doesn't count in this forum.

From the rules:

Characters who have appeared on both television and on film (Star Trek, 24, etc) are allowed for versus matches. Star Trek, for example, has numerous tv shows of different franchises as well as motion pictures and it seems only fair to allow feats from both in versus matches.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
From the rules:

Characters who have appeared on both television and on film (Star Trek, 24, etc) are allowed for versus matches. Star Trek, for example, has numerous tv shows of different franchises as well as motion pictures and it seems only fair to allow feats from both in versus matches.

Beat you to it. 😛

You win this time VD! :-p

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
I was waiting on you to do that yes TCW is cannon but not the movies. So therefore doesn't count in this forum.

Actually Imp(this forums mod) has stated that TV shows can be used as long as it's canon.

Looks like two people beat me to pointing that out. good job Nib and TVD.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Eh? TCW is canon and TV "feats" are allowed here as long as it is canon to the character.

Movies sir TCW is not movies but still gods can't TK something 500 meters away. And still dumbledore can just turn yoda into a ferret case closed.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Looks like two people beat me to pointing that out. good job Nib and TVD.

Why does that matter if dumbledore can just turn yoda into a ferret before yoda even gets close enough

If Dumbledore is close enough to have a chance of hitting Yoda with a spell, then he's close enough to have his wand tk'd.

Thus Yoda wins via tk and speedblitz.

Originally posted by Silent Master
If Dumbledore is close enough to have a chance of hitting Yoda with a spell, then he's close enough to have his wand tk'd.

Thus Yoda wins via tk and speedblitz.

500 meters dumbledore doesn't even have to use it right then he can wait for about 2 seconds then use it. Also dumbledore would have that accuracy to which is proven by the deul between snape vs mcgonagall when the spells are extremely precise.

So dumbledore wins via turning yoda into a ferret

The duel your referring to was at very short range, so it doesn't even come close to proving that Dumbledore could hit Yoda from .5 kilometers.

Thus Yoda wins via tk and speedblitz.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
So dumbledore wins via turning yoda into a ferret

Originally posted by Silent Master
The duel your referring to was at very short range, so it doesn't even come close to proving that Dumbledore could hit Yoda from .5 kilometers.

Thus Yoda wins via tk and speedblitz.

You can still look at how the spells were shot and then how they hit meaning that dumbledore could use that precision to hit yoda spot on. And if you read my last post he can wait for as long or short as needed to where yoda is not to close but close enough to get shot.

Dumbledore wins due to turning yoda into a ferret

Originally posted by Robtard
Prove Transfiguration works on aliens. Your claim. Prove it.

Transfiguration works on everything aliens included. Yoda's said species is not even known so therefore his species is not immune to transfiguration. As we don't know what his species is. With that he can be transfigured.

Dumbledore wins via transfiguration

Spells being accurate over short distances hardly proves that they would be accurate over long distances, that would be like saying that hitting a bullseye from 50 feet means that you can do the same from 1,625 feet.

So once again, Yoda wins via tk and speed.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Transfiguration works on everything aliens included. Yoda's said species is not even known so therefore his species is not immune to transfiguration. As we don't know what his species is. With that he can be transfigured.

Dumbledore wins via transfiguration

"It worked on a crow, so it can work on anything!", That's a No Limit Fallacy, kid.

You haven't proven Transfiguration would work on a Yoda and you haven't proven that Transfiguration can be used on targets 500 meters away, considering (iirc) all the Transfiguration we see is done up close.

Two things you need to prove. So prove them.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Spells being accurate over short distances hardly proves that they would be accurate over long distances, that would be like saying that hitting a bullseye from 50 feet means that you can do the same from 1,625 feet.

So once again, Yoda wins via tk and speed.

Once again dumbledore wins via transfiguration. And based off of what you are saying all dumbledore has to do is hold a steady protege charm and when yoda runs into it, he will be repelled back and then dumbledore will transfigure him into a ferret.

Originally posted by Robtard
"It worked on a crow, so it can work on anything!", That's a No Limit Fallacy, kid.

You haven't proven Transfiguration would work on a Yoda and you haven't proven that Transfiguration can be used on targets 500 meters away, considering (iirc) all the Transfiguration we see is done up close.

Two things you need to prove. So prove them.

You'll have to forgive him, as he seems to think that hitting something from 5 feet is proof that you can do the same at 5,000 feet.

On a side note, that means he likely believes that movie Cap lifting around 1,000 lbs over his head means that he can lift 100 tons.

Originally posted by Robtard
"It worked on a crow, so it can work on anything!", That's a No Limit Fallacy, kid.

You haven't proven Transfiguration would work on a Yoda and you haven't proven that Transfiguration can be used on targets 500 meters away, considering (iirc) all the Transfiguration we see is done up close.

Two things you need to prove. So prove them.

Yodas species is not stated to be immune to anything all he has is extreme longevity. So how wouldn't transfiguration work.

If you go by that than we are back to square one. Yoda just stands there for the first move and then dumbledore could just use any spell of that the case bit still dumbledore wins via transfiguration.