Captain Marvel vs Silver Surfer

Started by ultimatethor9 pages

Originally posted by lawest9
Other characters such as thor, the hulk for example have punched the surfer out before so it's not a strecth to believe that a magically charged CM can do the same.

Also the THING has kayoed him with a single punch on his first trip to earth while trying to signal galactus.

Completely false. Regular thor has never ever koed silver surfer. Neither has the hulk. Also thing didnt even ko him as he was completely unhurt.

Originally posted by darthgoober
When has Hulk KO'd Surfer without Surfer being cut off from the Power Cosmic?

That was actually rectoned out in Marvel Saga(most likely due to the ridiculousness of it). Surfer was staggered, not KO'd...

Original...
[img=http://img212.imageshack.us/img212/8476/fantasticfour4906ih8.th.jpg]

Recton...
[img=http://img116.imageshack.us/img116/3734/themarvelsaga25bookxxv1ej7.th.jpg]

Many of you make ss out to be hulk level in strenght alone but hulk did koed him in planet hulk, and if it makes you feel any better we'll say the fall on top of alicia masters roof knocked him out when he was hit by ben grimm but never the less he was out, and BTW, your scans didn't come through and marvel is good at rectonning in favor of SS, THEY ARE SO FULL OF SHIT.

Originally posted by lawest9
Other characters such as thor, the hulk for example have punched the surfer out before so it's not a strecth to believe that a magically charged CM can do the same.

Also the THING has kayoed him with a single punch on his first trip to earth while trying to signal galactus.

i'd never say surfer can't be put down, its not as if its never happened before...

Originally posted by ultimatethor
Completely false. Regular thor has never ever koed silver surfer. Neither has the hulk. Also thing didnt even ko him as he was completely unhurt.
NOsir it is not false particurily the fight involving the thing, read my post above for what happened.

Also thor koed him with mjolnir in the warrior madness series and the hulk did it in the planet hulk saga.

Oh BTW, even spider-man knocked him on his ass in the original surfer series of the sixties.

Originally posted by lawest9
NOsir it is not false particurily the fight involving the thing, read my post above for what happened.

Also thor koed him with mjolnir in the warrior madness series and the hulk did it in the planet hulk saga.

Thor hammer, wwh strength>>>>anything captain marvel has to offer or put to the table.

Originally posted by carver9
Thor hammer, wwh strength>>>>anything captain marvel has to offer or put to the table.

facepalm

Originally posted by Raoul
facepalm
Agreed

Originally posted by lawest9
NOsir it is not false particurily the fight involving the thing, read my post above for what happened.

Also thor koed him with mjolnir in the warrior madness series and the hulk did it in the planet hulk saga.

Thor in that series was heavily amped and was tearing thru multiple top tiers. In planet hulk ss was disconnected from the power cosmic and greatly weakened.

Things punch itself is not what took surfer out. It was the fall. Further, that is a very low feat for surfer early in his history. Heck its his first appearance. Since then he has been protrayed far more powerful going unscathed from far worse impact than that.

Originally posted by lawest9
Oh BTW, even spider-man knocked him on his ass in the original surfer series of the sixties.

Spiderman didnt even come close to knocking him out. He did no harm to SS whatsoever. He was just a pest to surfer. Surfer didnt even use his power cosmic for most of that fight.

Originally posted by lawest9
Many of you make ss out to be hulk level in strenght alone but hulk did koed him in planet hulk,

Proof that Surfer was KO'd(didn't Surfer lead the slaves out of the Arena)? Also, Surfer was completely cut off from the Power Cosmic at the time(which means he couldn't amp his strength/durability) and was still kicking the Hulk's ass in Melee until Hulk's friends jumped in to distract Surfer.

Originally posted by lawest9
and if it makes you feel any better we'll say the fall on top of alicia masters roof knocked him out when he was hit by ben grimm but never the less he was out,

No we'll say he wasn't KO'd at all, just staggered. That was the whole reason I posted the recton...

Originally posted by lawest9
and BTW, your scans didn't come through and marvel is good at rectonning in favor of SS, THEY ARE SO FULL OF SHIT.

Try again because they're working for me. And I can't think of any recton but this one that Surfer's benefited from in any way...

Originally posted by ultimatethor
Spiderman didnt even come close to knocking him out. He did no harm to SS whatsoever. He was just a pest to surfer. Surfer didnt even use his power cosmic for most of that fight.
I didn't say he knocked him out, he did put him on his backside, point is he was knocked down by someone who is supposed to be so far below his level in strenght, go back and read the original issue and not some rectonn.

Leaning towards CM.

Originally posted by Raoul
i'd never say surfer can't be put down, its not as if its never happened before...
that is the most reasonable and fairly sensable statement yet, thank you.

Too many of these ss threads tend to be an "kiss surfer ass fest situation"

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Leaning towards CM.
Why?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Why?

CM stats rival Supes, with no exploitating I don't see SS taking the majority. There about even in speed, to be hoenst I don't remember CM ever useing superspeed in battle much like with SS. In SS defense he can at least initiate blast fairly quick, but I don't think he will output enough power to KO CM. On the other hand, I think magical charged bolts or strikes will do some considerable damage to SS.

Originally posted by lawest9
I didn't say he knocked him out, he did put him on his backside, point is he was knocked down by someone who is supposed to be so far below his level in strenght, go back and read the original issue and not some rectonn.

Are you talking about Spidey or the Thing in this post? Just asking because you're talking about the recon but UT was talking about Spidey...

Originally posted by The Great Galen
CM stats rival Supes, with no exploitating I don't see SS taking the majority. There about even in speed, to be hoenst I don't remember CM ever useing superspeed in battle much like with SS. In SS defense he can at least initiate blast fairly quick, but I don't think he will output enough power to KO CM. On the other hand, I think magical charged bolts or strikes will do some considerable damage to SS.
Surfer is so friggin versatile. I dont know how anyone could give billy the majority here. Surfer is more powerful and more versatile. He wins.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Surfer is so friggin versatile. I dont know how anyone could give billy the majority here. Surfer is more powerful and more versatile. He wins.

Didn't Billy become the new Shazam or whatever?? If so he is easily Sky-Father Level.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
Didn't Billy become the new Shazam or whatever?? If so he is easily Sky-Father Level.
I think this is classic Captain Marvel.