Daredevil v.s. Batman

Started by Eon Blue11 pages
Originally posted by Battlehammer
no it does not.

Why do you say that?

Originally posted by brainchild81
Nope NW's my fave character from DC & I don't like Slade all that much.
I already know that. That's how the discussion of PIS started 🙄 Jeez, Where's Long Pig when you need him?

Judging by the fact that you said that Batman and NW shouldn't be able to defeat Slade, you certainly had me fooled 😕.

Originally posted by Eon Blue
Why do you say that?

becuases he was wrong over and over again.

He also a hypocrit.

Could go either way, really.

Daredevil has radar sense and slightly better agility. Batman has the advantage in durability thanks to his armor which not even an Omac could cut (everybody seems to overlook this little facet) and better striking power. I also think he's the better fighter of the two, not to mention the better tactician.

Meh, Batman 5-5.5/10.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Ok do me a favour. Read what I said and process the information...ok?

I did read it but I would need to see scans. People on KMC have a habit of interpretting scans in an odd way that is unrealistic and often biased. Face facts DD is an ordinary guy with training he can't lift a ton, no one on our earth can so why should he be able to

Originally posted by severance
I did read it but I would need to see scans. People on KMC have a habit of interpretting scans in an odd way that is unrealistic and often biased. Face facts DD is an ordinary guy with training he can't lift a ton, no one on our earth can so why should he be able to

Because DD doesn't routinely do things an ordinary guy in our world can't, amirite?

No I think what he means is that he is "normal" in strength, in which I agree batman has him outmatched in power, plus bats is a far better allround fighter, he basically knows 127 different Martial Arts and I probably am mistaken but isn't he a master in a few of them?

Although both characters are listed as normal stat wise, they both have done things that say enhanced or peak human.

Originally posted by severance
I did read it but I would need to see scans. People on KMC have a habit of interpretting scans in an odd way that is unrealistic and often biased. Face facts DD is an ordinary guy with training he can't lift a ton, no one on our earth can so why should he be able to

You can't apply our world's rules and boundaries with comics. Just like in cartoons, a man or a duck could get crushed by a huge rock and not get killed.

Personally i think Daredevil is stronger and more agile but Batman is the smarter and better fighter thats why he wins a slight majority to me.

Originally posted by ScarletSpeed
No I think what he means is that he is "normal" in strength, in which I agree batman has him outmatched in power, plus bats is a far better allround fighter, he basically knows 127 different Martial Arts and I probably am mistaken but isn't he a master in a few of them?

He is using an ordinary persons strength in our world to say someone who is "normal" in a fictional world can't do something more impressive.

Do you realize how ridiculous that is?

Originally posted by batdude123
Could go either way, really.

Daredevil has radar sense and slightly better agility. Batman has the advantage in durability thanks to his armor which not even an Omac could cut (everybody seems to overlook this little facet) and better striking power. I also think he's the better fighter of the two, not to mention the better tactician.

Meh, Batman 5-5.5/10.

co-signed

Originally posted by Phantom Ghost
Judging by the fact that you said that Batman and NW shouldn't be able to defeat Slade, you certainly had me fooled 😕.
Well you're easily fooled. I try not to let who I like more sway my opinion of who'd win in a scrap. Bats or NW are great, but they are humans. 'Stroke ain't. Bats or NW should be able to do just enough to piss DS off & make him do this.

They beat him for storyteling purposes, not 'cuz they should. Batman has a huge jobber aura. If DS was human they'd beat him, or if he was an incompetant meta. DS is a meta & he's got the skills to pay the bills. Go to the DS respect thread & then tell me that it makes any real sense for him to have such problems w/Bats or NW. I think there's even a scrap when Slade asks Batman "Why am I fighting you like we're equals?". DS should own ANY human in a fistfight. He'd even hand Cap his @ss.

Originally posted by brainchild81
Well you're easily fooled. I try not to let who I like more sway my opinion of who'd win in a scrap. Bats or NW are great, but they are humans. 'Stroke ain't. Bats or NW should be able to do just enough to piss DS off & make him do this.

They beat him for storyteling purposes, not 'cuz they should. Batman has a huge jobber aura. If DS was human they'd beat him, or if he was an incompetant meta. DS is a meta & he's got the skills to pay the bills. Go to the DS respect thread & then tell me that it makes any real sense for him to have such problems w/Bats or NW. I think there's even a scrap when Slade asks Batman "Why am I fighting you like we're equals?". DS should own ANY human in a fistfight. He'd even hand Cap his @ss.

You forgetting the first part of that fight. Batman got some very good blows in. And even after the fight, Slade was hurt himself. Take away Slade's enhancements and he wouldn't be on batman's level, seeing as how Batman was still able to hurt him with his enhancements.

Ditto. I already said

Originally posted by brainchild81
If DS was human they'd beat him
Slade ain't human though. This reminds me of when people say "Take away the SSS & Bats will kick Cap's @SS" Nobody cares because the SSS is part of Cap just as the enhancements are part of DS

i'm still undecided.

Originally posted by batdude123
which not even an Omac could cut (everybody seems to overlook this little facet)

Wait one minute, you're assuming thats standard armour? Isnt that prep? Werent these OMACS fighting really powerful metas?

Let me help you decide.

A city environment, no weaponry or equipment, pretty much just H2H except Batman probably has his protective costume.

Daredevil is more honed to the city environment and more acrobatic because of this, giving him more balance and skill. Batman is probably stronger by a very small margin, but I fail to see how it will help if Daredevil is all over him with nerve strikes, drop kicks. Sure, Bats is acrobatic too, but to be honest I only really see him being very acrobatic with use of grappling lines etc, which he doesn't have. He can work out that DD has heightened senses, but without sonic bombs or anything, there isn't much he can do about that. DD can just keep hitting him in all the weak points that he senses, for the win. DD can also sense when Batman is about to hit due to heartbeat patterns.

DD 6/10

Originally posted by Etrigan

DD 6/10

Well thought analysis again. 👆

Originally posted by Etrigan
Let me help you decide.

A city environment, no weaponry or equipment, pretty much just H2H except Batman probably has his protective costume.

Daredevil is more honed to the city environment and more acrobatic because of this, giving him more balance and skill. Batman is probably stronger by a very small margin, but I fail to see how it will help if Daredevil is all over him with nerve strikes, drop kicks. Sure, Bats is acrobatic too, but to be honest I only really see him being very acrobatic with use of grappling lines etc, which he doesn't have. He can work out that DD has heightened senses, but without sonic bombs or anything, there isn't much he can do about that. DD can just keep hitting him in all the weak points that he senses, for the win. DD can also sense when Batman is about to hit due to heartbeat patterns.

DD 6/10

dd is more honed to the city enviroment riiiiiiiiiiight 😆