Thor vs Superman

Started by carver9453 pages

Originally posted by cdtm
That part doesn't negate the part that comes before it, though. It adds to it, perhaps, but the part in bold is the main crux of the argument.

There's no civilians in danger here, and they won't fight like idiots, and there's nothing being suggested that they haven't performed in comics, so what's the problem?

So again I ask. Does Surfer beats Supes 10/10? Yes or No?

Originally posted by carver9
So again I ask. Does Surfer beats Supes 10/10? Yes or No?

I didn't see you ask that the first time.

Yes.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Not a low showing but an embarrassing one Hulk fans will lord over you for years. This is just worthy Hulk and even you yourself would have to admit wb I ain't holding back no more Hulk would cripple Thor in two panels.

😆 💃

Originally posted by cdtm
That part doesn't negate the part that comes before it, though. It adds to it, perhaps, but the part in bold is the main crux of the argument.

There's no civilians in danger here, and they won't fight like idiots, and there's nothing being suggested that they haven't performed in comics, so what's the problem?

The problem is what's in character and likely for them to do.

Thor's God Blasted and Anti-Forced and summoned multi-planetary scale storms before. Considering he, currently - ugh - is more than willing to kill a foe if he thinks they deserve it - why shouldn't we just assume that in every thread he's in with a bad guy or someone whom Thor wouldn't mind killing he just does that? He's done it on panel, and numerous times. And since Thor can gauge his own attack and use just enough force short of killing, anyway, why doesn't he do this more often?

Originally posted by cdtm
I didn't see you ask that the first time.

Yes.

So you admit that as soon as the fight starts it is basically done for Supes via K-nite, red solar energy, drainage, create black hole in the skull, etc, etc?

Is this what you are telling me?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Not a low showing but an embarrassing one Hulk fans will lord over you for years. This is just worthy Hulk and even you yourself would have to admit wb I ain't holding back no more Hulk would cripple Thor in two panels. A longer fight has always favored the Hulk anyways due to his powerset recent issues aside so Thor admitting he can't beat the Hulk in a fight to the last man standing is something that shouldn't be news to you.

Embarrassing, in what way? He ran out of gas after going through a large serious of ordeals. Would I have preferred if he stayed on his feet? Sure, but it's nothing to complain about. Not at all.

And this is coming from someone who defended Thanos' showings after he was reborn. I wonder, do you actually believe anything you post?

Thor vs. Hulk will almost always be a stalemate due to how Thor approaches the battle.

Rune King Thor would crush World Breaker Hulk.

Originally posted by carver9
😆 💃
Enjoy your moment in the sun, carver.

Whoah!Are people acting like Thor saying he could never beat Hulk as a big thing?If anything, it seems that scene to me was like sarcasm by Thor.Because when the Hulk responded "I knew" he started charging at Thor.And Thor responded "Did you now" and then he powered up and hit Hulk with a powerful move that sent Hulk into space.If anything, that sarcasm part by Thor was just to sucker in Hulk(Nul) for a power move.And this was against an amped Hulk.Thing(Angrir) took down Red Hulk and that speaks volume on how much he was amped.Because there is no way regular Thing can beat Red Hulk.So Thor going toe to toe with Hulk(Nul) and Thing(Angrir) is a big deal in his part.

Yah, honestly anyone faulting Thor for collapsing after just taking out 2 uber characters is kinda silly. This is not Odin Thor after all. And he defeated both of them without busting out anything super powerful. Sure that was one hell of a lightning blast to BFR Hulk, but still. He didn't use a god blast, or anti-force, or life drain; or anything of that nature.

Originally posted by igniz
If anything, it seems that scene to me was like sarcasm by Thor.Because when the Hulk responded "I knew" he started charging at Thor.And Thor responded "Did you now" and then he powered up and hit Hulk with a powerful move that sent Hulk into space.If anything, that sarcasm part by Thor was just to sucker in Hulk(Nul) for a power move.

Also, Thor was laughing when he said he could never beat Hulk. Honestly that's one way to interpret it. That's actually the vibe I got when I first read it. Because otherwise, him saying "Did you now.." makes no sense whatsoever. Of course, this is Fraction...

Current Thor vs Superman 5/10. Wait till the relaunch of DC and then it might be very well a 10/10 for thor 😐.

Originally posted by Igniz
Whoah!Are people acting like Thor saying he could never beat Hulk as a big thing?If anything, it seems that scene to me was like sarcasm by Thor.Because when the Hulk responded "I knew" he started charging at Thor.And Thor responded "Did you now" and then he powered up and hit Hulk with a powerful move that sent Hulk into space.If anything, that sarcasm part by Thor was just to sucker in Hulk(Nul) for a power move.And this was against an amped Hulk.Thing(Angrir) took down Red Hulk and that speaks volume on how much he was amped.Because there is no way regular Thing can beat Red Hulk.So Thor going toe to toe with Hulk(Nul) and Thing(Angrir) is a big deal in his part.

I dunno about sarcasm, but what I got from that was more on Thor telling Hulk indirectly that He always held back. And Hulk replying with "I...knew" to me was the Hulk admitting that somehow, he always knew that Thor never went all out against him. Hence Thor's final replay of "did you know" which was aching to showing Hulk what he really is capable of.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Current Thor vs Superman 5/10. Wait till the relaunch of DC and then it might be very well a 10/10 for thor 😐.

I wouldn't bet on that seeing as to how everyone seems to be getting powered down or something. Which is IMO, the right direction to go. I mean, busting mountains in half is damn impressive. Busting and moving moons and planets is just down right ridiculous.

Been done. And that's all we have for now. Supes won. Deal with it.

Originally posted by gogogadgetgo
I wouldn't bet on that seeing as to how everyone seems to be getting powered down or something. Which is IMO, the right direction to go. I mean, busting mountains in half is damn impressive. Busting and moving moons and planets is just down right ridiculous.

Yeah I also think that it's better to power them down so the stories are more entertaining and challenging.

Originally posted by DickBlazer
Been done. And that's all we have for now. Supes won. Deal with it.
One fight doesn't make it ironclad it goes down in the manner every time. LOL.

Originally posted by DickBlazer
Been done. And that's all we have for now. Supes won. Deal with it.

Originally posted by quanchi112
One fight doesn't make it ironclad it goes down in the manner every time. LOL.
Exactly. Beside the fact that crossovers don't count in the forums. And we're talking about current Thor, not "Stock is lower that shit at the moment early 2000's Thor". Current Thor will use powers, be more aggressive, he won't just sit there and brick Superman the whole time.

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
Exactly. Beside the fact that crossovers don't count in the forums. And we're talking about current Thor, not "Stock is lower that shit at the moment early 2000's Thor". Current Thor will use powers, be more aggressive, he won't just sit there and brick Superman the whole time.
The only time I'd say one fight could be a good indicator of this if it was a one sided stomp with neither holding back.

If Superman is as fast as Flash, not sure how Thor has a chance in a forum fight.

Good thing Superman's not as fast as the Flash, huh?

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Good thing Superman's not as fast as the Flash, huh?
do you agree that he's still much much faster than thor though?