Blade vs. Wolverine

Started by Creshosk57 pages

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
1. It doesn't matter if you think it's impossible since we're talking about a comic book character who happens to be a mutant with an already odd bone structure. It happened on-panel and was a knockout and per forum customs, a win. Deal with it. So point against you.

2. It was the bullet to the brain that knocked him out. Same as the above instance. Everything else leading up to that point was to make Wolverine mad. And considering that you're trying to convince people that Wolverine's healing factor is uber, I find it disingenuous that you're arguing Wolverine's healing factor was so taxed by that point, that was why he was unconscious for so long. It's one or the other. You can't have it both ways. Either his healing factor can be taxed and overcome, or a single bullet to the brain through either his eye or throat takes him out. Considering that he's been taken out before by a single bullet to the brain, on-panel evidence dictates the latter.

And considering his encounter with Deadpool. You really think his boneclaw healing factor is on par with his current one? Wolverine got hit by a duck bomb, two shuriken grenades, a waitress punch, a piano and was rolled over by a delivery truck that exploded. That knocked him out of the game for twenty minutes, ON-PANEL. I've seen bone-claw Wolverine rolled over by a truck before and he healed in seconds, post-Fatal Attractions. No way that the extra explosions (which didn't even engulf him in flames) account for the difference between those two instances. For you to argue that current HF is equal to his boneclaw HF is ludicrous.

3. Desert environment obstructs his healing factor? Says you. Even I don't make this claim. And you only assume it was hundreds of bullets. Considering he appears to have a hundred bullet holes in him on-panel, please don't try to inflate the feat.

Yes downgraded. As suggested by Azrael, as admitted by Wolverine and even mocked by X-23. ALL ON-PANEL. His healing factor is downgraded to such a degree that bullets take him out. Especially bullets to the brain. ON-PANEL.

Appearently you don't understand the rules of the forum very well One time feats that happen on panel? Yeah those do to get discarded.

The "No PIS" Rule

PIS = Plot Induced Stupidity

At times, for the sake of the plot, characters that are immensely more powerful than their opponent will "job" to carry on the plot of the story, even though the characters powers and history would clearly show that they are more than capable of destroying their opponent. For this reason we have a No PIS Rule. This rule prohibits the use of such instances of PIS from being used as evidence in debates.

Spiderman vs. Firelord
Spiderman vs. Firelord, or SvFL, is a shorthand that refers to any time when a character performs a feat that their powers and skills should be blatantly insufficient for, and is not repeated or is rarely repeated again relative to the character's overall established career, as well as the character's opponents' established showings. In statistical terms, it is an outlier, something that is radically beyond the character's established capabilities. For example, Spiderman defeating a herald of Galactus is a case of the SvFL exemption; however, Batman being able to sneak up on Superman is not because he has done so frequently under different writers.

It happened once? Sorry, but Spiderman beat Firelord once. but guess what? Despite it happeneing ON PANEL it is not creidble to use it.

Originally posted by DestinyGuy678
that was definently longer than 5 minutes

for nitro to fall unconcsious wake up and talk to his boss is deifnently more than 5 minutes

It was a short conversation. Logan was a skeleton when it started and completely healed before it was finished.. it wasn't hours.

Originally posted by jinzin
It was a short conversation. Logan was a skeleton when it started and completely healed before it was finished.. it wasn't hours.
and it took him a while to get started healing and his nervous system took even longer

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
1. It doesn't matter if you think it's impossible since we're talking about a comic book character who happens to be a mutant with an already odd bone structure. It happened on-panel and was a knockout and per forum customs, a win. Deal with it. So point against you.
Wolverine wasn't even out, he was mummbling shit talk and trying to get to his feat. He didn't go down until Scrambler touched him. So you're delusional.
And again, it's a feat contradicted by on panel proof. 😬
Looks like you're the one having problems "dealing with it" since you start this shit up again in another thread.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
2. It was the bullet to the brain that knocked him out. Same as the above instance. Everything else leading up to that point was to make Wolverine mad. And considering that you're trying to convince people that Wolverine's healing factor is uber, I find it disingenuous that you're arguing Wolverine's healing factor was so taxed by that point, that was why he was unconscious for so long. It's one or the other. You can't have it both ways. Either his healing factor can be taxed and overcome, or a single bullet to the brain through either his eye or throat takes him out. Considering that he's been taken out before by a single bullet to the brain, on-panel evidence dictates the latter.

A bullet to the brain after multiple explosions, bullets and plot devices otherwise. And as I've said before a bullet in his brain SHOULD put him down..... Anyways, you're missing the point again.... It doesn't matter what EVENTUALLY put him down what matters is that it wasn't JUST a few bullets and it's HARDLY evidence that shows Wolverine's HF as depowered.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
And considering his encounter with Deadpool. You really think his boneclaw healing factor is on par with his current one?

Bone claw Wolverine said that Sabretooth healed faster than he did. A hole in Sabretooth's head put him down for the duration of an evening twice.... it's put Wolverine down for 10 seconds.... so no it's not "on par", it's superior.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Wolverine got hit by a duck bomb, two shuriken grenades, a waitress punch, a piano and was rolled over by a delivery truck that exploded. That knocked him out of the game for twenty minutes, ON-PANEL.
Well for one you have no idea if Wolverine was even knocked out or stuck under the debris, you don't know how long he was dragged behind the truck before it blew either... So again.. delusional.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
I've seen bone-claw Wolverine rolled over by a truck before and he healed in seconds, post-Fatal Attractions. No way that the extra explosions (which didn't even engulf him in flames) account for the difference between those two instances. For you to argue that current HF is equal to his boneclaw HF is ludicrous.

Well it's ludicrous if you think Wolverine can be put down by a few bullets nowadays.. and you do.. sooooo....

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
3. Desert environment obstructs his healing factor? Says you. Even I don't make this claim. And you only assume it was hundreds of bullets. Considering he appears to have a hundred bullet holes in him on-panel, please don't try to inflate the feat.
5 guys full auto, long enough for Wolverine to realize he needs to count the bullets and extract his revenge on Mystique.... and uhh says me? No... Says ON PANEL evidence.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Yes downgraded. As suggested by Azrael, as admitted by Wolverine and even mocked by X-23. ALL ON-PANEL. His healing factor is downgraded to such a degree that bullets take him out. Especially bullets to the brain. ON-PANEL.
Azreal "I can't guarantee that it won't"

Wolverine- before he had a fight.

X-23- after Scrambler got ahold of Logan...

Yeah.. all irrelivent as PROOF which is what you need but sorely lack.

Originally posted by DestinyGuy678
and it took him a while to get started healing and his nervous system took even longer
AZ RE AL... 😐

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
3. Desert environment obstructs his healing factor? Says you.
No...

http://img382.imageshack.us/img382/3410/howhfworksed0.jpg

It's

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
ON-PANEL.

Originally posted by DestinyGuy678
and it took him a while to get started healing and his nervous system took even longer

Originally posted by jinzin
AZ RE AL... 😐
No, I think Destinyguy678 is right. He starts healing when Nitro is still unconscious. That's when Wolverine regained consciousness anyway. So it was definitely past any encounter with Azrael at that point in time. The muscle and skin and hair was what took the few minutes that you're referring to jinzin. The nervous system was another thing entirely:

http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p105/Manjaro_/Wolverine48-008.jpg
http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p105/Manjaro_/Wolverine48-009-010.jpg
http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p105/Manjaro_/Wolverine48-011.jpg
http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p105/Manjaro_/Wolverine48-012.jpg

looks to me like Wolverine is concious only shortly before Nitro is... So again it wasn't hours worth of healing.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
[B The muscle and skin and hair was what took the few minutes that you're referring to jinzin. The nervous system was another thing entirely:
[/B]

yep...the skin and hair prob took minutes, but the nervous system and the other complex stuff prob took a few hours at least.

Originally posted by Master-Borg
yep...the skin and hair prob took minutes, but the nervous system and the other complex stuff prob took a few hours at least.

Like it did when he fell into molten Lava.
Or when "the suit" plasma blasted him to the bone?
Or when he regenerated from a drop of blood... yeah... 🙄

That sure looked like minutes.

Wolvie gets blasted, short conversation later he's alive again.

"Kinda hard not to my eyelids haven't grown back yet."

But the eyes and brain have.

By the way Jinzin. OneDumbG0 put me on ignore cause he couldn't answer one of my questions.

Originally posted by Creshosk
By the way Jinzin. OneDumbG0 put me on ignore cause he couldn't answer one of my questions.

😂

Originally posted by jinzin
Like it did when he fell into molten Lava.
Or when "the suit" plasma blasted him to the bone?
Or when he regenerated from a drop of blood... yeah... 🙄

"feeling my nervous system regrow itself ONE cell at a time"

it would take AT LEAST hours for his nervous system to regrow back

Originally posted by Master-Borg
"feeling my nervous system regrow itself ONE cell at a time"

it would take AT LEAST hours for his nervous system to regrow back

Right, because it took hours for Nitro to get up to his feat even through he woke up 2 seconds after Logan regained consciousness.

Originally posted by Master-Borg
"feeling my nervous system regrow itself ONE cell at a time"

it would take AT LEAST hours for his nervous system to regrow back

Depends on how long it takes to grow a single cell.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Depends on how long it takes to grow a single cell.
well he can feel it grow one at a time, it suggests that it was growing at a speed that he could feel

however, even assuming it one cell takes .01 seconds to grow (unlikely since he wouldn't feel them individually in that case), it would take hours

Originally posted by jinzin
Right, because it took hours for Nitro to get up to his feat even through he woke up 2 seconds after Logan regained consciousness.
so are you saying Logan is bullshitting lol?

and thats artistic depiction, we dont know the exact lapse of time

madness.

Originally posted by jinzin
Wolverine wasn't even out, he was mummbling shit talk and trying to get to his feat. He didn't go down until Scrambler touched him. So you're delusional.
And again, it's a feat contradicted by on panel proof. 😬
Looks like you're the one having problems "dealing with it" since you start this shit up again in another thread.
On-panel proof of what? The ambiguous torture pit scene where he may or may not have had his brain penetrated again? We already went through this, as you yourself recall. The bullet may have penetrated his brain in the torture pit and pushed the bullet out through his eye. This is much more plausible since the New X-Men issue was published AFTER the torture pit. More recent and clearly on-panel. I just responded to this thread with my opinion. You don't like my opinions that's fine. But by your accounting, an ambiguous and older scan trumps a clear and newer scan. Your cup of tea.
Originally posted by jinzin
A bullet to the brain after multiple explosions, bullets and plot devices otherwise. And as I've said before a bullet in his brain SHOULD put him down..... Anyways, you're missing the point again.... It doesn't matter what EVENTUALLY put him down what matters is that it wasn't JUST a few bullets and it's HARDLY evidence that shows Wolverine's HF as depowered.

Bone claw Wolverine said that Sabretooth healed faster than he did. A hole in Sabretooth's head put him down for the duration of an evening twice.... it's put Wolverine down for 10 seconds.... so no it's not "on par", it's superior.

Well for one you have no idea if Wolverine was even knocked out or stuck under the debris, you don't know how long he was dragged behind the truck before it blew either... So again.. delusional.

You're trying to connect Sabretooth's HF performance with boneclaw Wolverine's comments... and then use boneclaw Wolverine's healing factor at it's peak as the backdrop for this current fight... What the schmuck? Do you know what's easier? Just measuring his current healing factor with his current performance post-Azrael.

And what's happened since then? Wolverine's been put down by a single bullet, twice and put down by a hail of bullets. No equivocation, all on-panel and all recent. Although it's interesting that you think current Wolverine HF > boneclaw Wolverine HF, it doesn't really matter. I care about his current healing factor, post-downgrade. And as it is, current Wolverine can be put down by single shots to the brain and a hail of bullets.

Originally posted by jinzin
Well it's ludicrous if you think Wolverine can be put down by a few bullets nowadays.. and you do.. sooooo....
I don't think it's ludicrous considering that's actually what's been happening on-panel post-Azrael: