Originally posted by Lord S
Uhh, tossing a guy around with the physique, strength, and durability of the Hulk, and more, is not going going to do a damn thing...unless there's [b]real heavy-duty power behind it, (ala Odin). [/B]
He doesn't have to toss him anywhere just hold him in place.
Failing that, you still have to address the mind control issue.
Failing that it's a stalemate.
Originally posted by Aster PhoenixWhy don't you disprove it?
Prove it. Prove that it can shield against Psionic Energy.
It's well known that Thanos is highly resistant to telepathic assaults.
If Magneto's shield can protect him from a blast of psionic energy from Galactus, then Thanos' shield can easily do the same from a less powerful entity.
Unless you want to debate the merits of whose forcefield is stronger...and we all know the answer to that.
Originally posted by Lord S
[B]Why don't you disprove it?It's well known that Thanos is highly resistant to telepathic assaults.
Really? do you have scans to back that up?
If Magneto's shield can protect him from a blast of psionic energy from Galactus, then Thanos' shield can easily do the same from a less powerful entity.
Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
If your saying Moondragon is more powerful then Prof X and Nate Grey Combined then you had better have scans to prove that and don't use ones when she had the mind gem.
Prove it.
No. that's not what I'm saying. I'm saying he totally DISMISSED her attack. It meant not a thing. If anything, he'll struggle against Nate and Xavier's power under Onslaught, but um...why don't you prove that Onslaught can beat Thanos using Xavier and Nate's telepathy.
Both are extremely powerful telepaths but that doesn't it can beat Thanos. You've got to prove that. 😄 Now yeah see where we're coming from.
Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
No. that's not what I'm saying. I'm saying he totally DISMISSED her attack. It meant not a thing. If anything, he'll struggle against Nate and Xavier's power under Onslaught, but um...why don't you prove that Onslaught can beat Thanos using Xavier and Nate's telepathy.Both are extremely powerful telepaths but that doesn't it can beat Thanos. You've got to prove that. 😄 Now yeah see where we're coming from.
Once again the burden of proof is on you. You the one defending that he cannot be attacked by this method, therefore you have to prove it. Ask the mod if you not sure.
Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
Once again the burden of proof is on you. You the one defending that he cannot be attacked by this method, therefore you have to prove it. Ask the mod if you not sure.
He can't be attacked by this method because people have tried and FAILED. Everyone knows this, except you. Who's success beaten him this way? No one that I know of.
Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
He can't be attacked by this method because people have tried and FAILED. Everyone knows this, except you.
That's why you provide scans to prove it. Because the scans also show the circumstances under which the attacks happen so you can put them in proper context.
Originally posted by Aster PhoenixCommon knowledge from watching his character evolve over the years. Don't have scans now, but I'm sure with a little research, you can find them.
Really? do you have scans to back that up?
When did that happen? And how do you know they are the same type of force field tech? Not every force field necessarily guards against the same thing.Secret Wars.
Originally posted by Lord S
[B]Common knowledge from watching his character evolve over the years. Don't have scans now, but I'm sure with a little research, you can find them.
And in secret Wars did Thanos force field allow him to guard against a psionic being and absorb it?
Originally posted by Aster PhoenixHearsay only to an ignorant newbie who doesn't bother to research anything and expects everyone to run around for him. You're still new and haven't earned that right yet, I'm afraid.
Your claim, your job to provide them. Until then, it's hearsay.
And in secret Wars did Thanos force field allow him to guard against a psionic being and absorb it?Thanos did not appear in Secret Wars.
Originally posted by Lord S
Hearsay only to an ignorant newbie who doesn't bother to research anything and expects everyone to run around for him. You're still new and haven't earned that right yet, I'm afraid.
Thanos did not appear in Secret Wars.
Originally posted by Aster PhoenixThen by your logic we shouldn't believe that the Living Tribunal is more powerful then Onslaught, either...because we don't have the scans of him standing up to psionic energy.
Well if your not willing to prove your claims, don't expect me to take them seriously.
Then the example is irrelevant.As is everything that's come off your keyboard.