Silver Surfer vs Beta Ray Bill

Originally posted by DarkOdin
4.You do know it was a clear win for surfer but it did nothing to show he out powered Bill he had to use a sneak attack to gainthe upper hand. As to one of the two BRB or Surfer from that fight niether one showned to be more powerfull.

The board hitting BRB was NOT a sneak attack. It was a smart use of abilities, not a sneak attack as BRB WAS actually fighting back at the time. Would you call it a sneak attack if Surfer got hit in the back with a lightning bolt?

Now Skuttlebutt, THAT was a sneak attack as SS was both lowering his guard (arguable but the scan seems to point out to it) and was unaware of Skuttle's approach and attack.

DDude...do you realize that comic was inaccurate

cuz according to that comic, surfer couldn't even reach ithan prime before scuttlebutt did

I say SS wins.

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
The board hitting BRB was NOT a sneak attack. It was a smart use of abilities, not a sneak attack as BRB WAS actually fighting back at the time. Would you call it a sneak attack if Surfer got hit in the back with a lightning bolt?

Now Skuttlebutt, THAT was a sneak attack as SS was both lowering his guard (arguable but the scan seems to point out to it) and was unaware of Skuttle's approach and attack.

Both were sneak attack but isee you have double standards. Skuttbutt is a warship of Bill's that counts a sneak attack but surfers board doesn't

😆

It's logical for the Surfer to win, he is slightly stronger in my opinion.

What isn't right however, is idiots ignoring the fact that Surfer attacked first, attacked from behind and that BRB was trying to convince Norrin just as much as Norrin was trying to convince him.

Originally posted by Starscream M
DDude...do you realize that comic was inaccurate

cuz according to that comic, surfer couldn't even reach ithan prime before scuttlebutt did

And if it was a thread about how fast the Surfer can travel then maybe you can chalk that up as a low feat.

As it is, how fast Surfer traveled has no credence on the owning he gave BRB's face.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
Both were sneak attack but isee you have double standards. Skuttbutt is a warship of Bill's that counts a sneak attack but surfers board doesn't

😆

Because Bill knew that Surfer has a board coming into the fight while the Surfer wasn't aware that Skuttlebutt would turn around and assist in the fight?

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
It's logical for the Surfer to win, he is slightly stronger in my opinion.

Ok then... so what the hell are we debating about??? >_< We seem to agree here.

BTW, I don't think any1 is saying that SS >>>>> BRB but SS > BRB. Enough to take good ol' horseface down decisively in a scrap.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
What isn't right however, is idiots ignoring the fact that Surfer attacked first, attacked from behind and that BRB was trying to convince Norrin just as much as Norrin was trying to convince him.

I don't think people said that BRB attacked first, I think people are saying that BRB landed the first few decisive hits and it failed to do any significant damage while Surfer 1-2-3 attack put down BRB pretty convincingly.

Lol at all this denial and wankage.

BRB countered Surfer's blast. Surfer moved in close, then got owned and knocked into a ship.

Done. The fight "ends" here.

Now comes plot device.

Surfer and BRB start talking while, BRB blocks Surfer's blast again. Surfer's board then hits him from behind while Surfer hits him twice while he is stunned. BRB might have moved maybe a foot at most after receiving his punches.

Wow.

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
BTW, I don't think any1 is saying that SS >>>>> BRB but SS > BRB. Enough to take good ol' horseface down decisively in a scrap.

Based on...?

Originally posted by Spire
Lol at all this denial and wankage.

BRB countered Surfer's blast. Surfer moved in close, then got owned and knocked into a ship.

Done. The fight "ends" here.

Now comes plot device.

Surfer and BRB start talking while, BRB blocks Surfer's blast again. Surfer's board then hits him from behind while Surfer hits him twice while he is stunned. BRB might have moved maybe a foot at most after receiving his punches.

Wow.

Whatever you're smoking, can I have some?

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Whatever you're smoking, can I have some?

'May'.

Originally posted by Spire
'May'.

Ahem. Sorry, my english sux. 🙁

Whatever, you're smoking, MAY I have some?

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Ahem. Sorry, my english sux. 🙁

Whatever, you're smoking, MAY I have some?

I don't know, can you?

Originally posted by Spire
I don't know, can you?

YOU tell me. O_o

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
YOU tell me. O_o

Never. Maybe.

Surfer OWNED BRB.
seriously, the way Surfer was telling Bill to stay down (AND the way Bill DID STAY DOWN, in a non-threatening fetal position) just about communicated total ownage.

people are free to disagree, but damn that was good to see 😄

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Because Bill knew that Surfer has a board coming into the fight while the Surfer wasn't aware that Skuttlebutt would turn around and assist in the fight?

Ummm. The scans clearly shows the board in front of Bill Then flying of to the side to fly of panel and coming around from behind.

Losing track of surfer's board "which moving pretty danm fast "bill should of been aware while he was blocking surfers attack. Bill should beaware of it.

But a gaint ship that surfer just crashed into turning around while surfer was attacking Bill surfer was unaware of it come on.

Come on once again the same thing happen to both guys but you say there was no way for surfer to known but bill should of known of the board???

And you say spire is 😮‍💨

Originally posted by Starscream M
how do you think Thor stacks up to Surfer then?

Either Bill is no longer Thor's equal or Surfer could do likewise to Thor...or: there's going to be another fight where Bill comes out on top or breaks even. As I posted earlier, I'm suspending judgment til I see the whole story.

Originally posted by Mindship
or: there's going to be another fight where Bill comes out on top or breaks even. As I posted earlier, I'm suspending judgment til I see the whole story.

yeah, i agree. they'll likely meet again and i wouldn't be surprised to see things go differently. at the same time, i've only ever viewed bill as thor's approximate PHYSICAL equal anyway. thor>>>bill with his hammer, and it's only ever the hammer and how it is used that would determine any thor/ss battle. i don't think that showing vs bill has any relevence at all in relation to how thor vs ss would go.