Wizards vs Mutants

Started by Robtard40 pages

Originally posted by omgchos
Obviously not. Now you're just being stupid. Looks like this argument is over.

U guys have nothing left.

Yeah, I forgot that scene in the HP movies where they do an autopsy and they specifically state "did not give heart attack."

Say that again, I think one more time should give you that win you need.

Immune to magic????? Wtf?????

Originally posted by Robtard
I think only a few wizards in the films know it.
All the death eaters know it. Harry knows it. Any wizard worth a shit knows it.

Originally posted by Robtard
Yeah, I forgot that scene in the HP movies where they do an autopsy and they specifically state "did not give heart attack."

Na, it was over when people started pulling non-movie feats.


U know a heart attack takes more that a second to kill you right?

Such as is a relative term, he could mean every villain in every X-Movie, he used Brotherhood because they were what came to mind when you thought of villains in the X-Men movies. Who were really villains in HP besides the Death Eaters?

I;ve got to work later, but when I get back, I will continue to ask questions that get ignored, and put up proof that will be ignored as well, But alas, that's what you get when you debate fanboys.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
He said "Villians such as the brotherhood and the death eaters." It is quite clear. And since Deadpool was neither, he is not in this fight.

"Such as" doesn't mean 'only these two'. He's saying villains; Deadpool was a villain.

EDIT: someone beat me to it.

Originally posted by KingD19
Such as is a relative term, he could mean every villain in every X-Movie, he used Brotherhood because they were what came to mind when you thought of villains in the X-Men movies. Who were really villains in HP besides the Death Eaters?
Dude, it is right there in black and white. "Brotherhood and death eaters." Deadpool was neither. End of story. Nor was he at hogwarts or in the X Men.

Originally posted by omgchos
U know a heart attack takes more that a second to kill you right?

Not a magical one, as magic defies nature.

Originally posted by KingD19
Such as is a relative term, he could mean every villain in every X-Movie, he used Brotherhood because they were what came to mind when you thought of villains in the X-Men movies. Who were really villains in HP besides the Death Eaters?

I;ve got to work later, but when I get back, I will continue to ask questions that get ignored, and put up proof that will be ignored as well, But alas, that's what you get when you debate fanboys.


LOL i see no fanboys. I've said it before i like x-men much more than HP. But whatever i can;t have an opinion without being labeled. And yes dumb questions get ignored. And so does non-existent proof.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
All the death eaters know it. Harry knows it. Any wizard worth a shit knows it.

I'm still waiting for you to show me a movie feat showing AV being used instantly, thereby defeating DP turning them all into ash.

Originally posted by Robtard
"Such as" doesn't mean 'only these two'. He's saying villains; Deadpool was a villain.

EDIT: someone beat me to it.

Give it up, its not your call, it's Will's call to include Deadpool or not. Right now we go with what he said, literally, and Deadpool does not fall under any of the categories listed. If he did, then hell, we'd be free to include every student that ever set foot in hogwarts, James and Lily included....But wait, they WERE shown in the movie. 😄

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
All the death eaters know it. Harry knows it. Any wizard worth a shit knows it.

But how many are willing to use it? Harry didn't try to use it against Voldemort.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Dude, it is right there in black and white. "Brotherhood and death eaters." Deadpool was neither. End of story. Nor was he at hogwarts or in the X Men.

Read the post above you please.

Originally posted by Robtard
I'm still waiting for you to show me a movie feat showing AV being used instantly, thereby defeating DP turning them all into ash.
Bellatrix killing Sirius Black in OOTP.

Anything else?

Originally posted by Robtard
Not a magical one, as magic defies nature.

This is exactly my point. It's a magical heart attack. A magical angurism. A magical air embolis. Take your pick. It ceases their life. U cant heal a heart attack caused by magic. He can regenerate tissue. Not restart his heart.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
But how many are willing to use it? Harry didn't try to use it against Voldemort.

Read the post above you please.


OK, is Xavier willing to kill innocents? Is he willing to kill Dumbledore or Harry? Is Magneto really gonna team with Xavier? See how that works?

Originally posted by omgchos
Thats not my point man. The movies are based off of the book. My point is that avada kedavra does nothing but eradicate life force. You never see any damage done to anyone who gets hit by it. They just crumple over dead.

The movies are based off of the comics and in the comics Jean was handling cosmic level beings so she should be able to easily stomp them by herself here then.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
OK, is Xavier willing to kill innocents? Is he willing to kill Dumbledore or Harry? Is Magneto really gonna team with Xavier? See how that works?

Yeah you cant have your cake and eat it too. Either they are willing to do whatever it takes to win, IE using Avada Kedavra, or most of those mutants hate each other and won;t cooperate.

Originally posted by omgchos
This is exactly my point. It's a magical heart attack. A magical angurism. A magical air embolis. Take your pick. It ceases their life. U cant heal a heart attack caused by magic. He can regenerate tissue. Not restart his heart.
Mmmmmmmmmhm. ✅

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
OK, is Xavier willing to kill innocents? Is he willing to kill Dumbledore or Harry? Is Magneto really gonna team with Xavier? See how that works?

Magneto did team with Xavier, have you seen the second movie? He doesn't even hate Charles, he threatened Pyro when he said he would kill Charles. They are still good friends.

Charles won't kill but he'll certainly stun and put them down.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
The movies are based off of the comics and in the comics Jean was handling cosmic level beings so she should be able to easily stomp them by herself here then.

Actually no. It's clearly stated in the movei that the phoenix is merely an alter ego, albeit an evil powerfull one. It negates the comic version completely. When a movie does that you can only say it's loosley based. If the phoenix had been the super pwnage cosmic entitiy from the comics then fine, but she wasn't.