Victory-Class Star Destroyer vs. Modern Day Earth

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
I didn't realize that mine was a spite thread (if it was); otherwise why would I argue that it isn't?

You didn't realize it was a spite thread? You should really re-read the first pages of the thread. You actually say that you do not believe the Empire can win. I can give you quotes if you want. Something like 'I can't believe 500 000 stormtroopers stand a chance against the entire Earth'. So according to you it wasn't fair. Thus, spite.

On the second page I asked why you would make a thread when you were positive one side would win. Then you responded with:

Generally, when people take a side in a debate, they're positive that their side would win.

He won't answer that. He has a tendency to "overlook" things which ultimately defeat him.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
He won't answer that. He has a tendency to "overlook" things which ultimately defeat him.

Janus has taught him well. haermm

Originally posted by Gideon
Janus has taught him well. haermm

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Thank you Eminence for supporting me and backing me up against the tyranny and oppression of trolls.

Originally posted by Janus Marius
Yoda vs Sidious w/ scans, say what?

no u haermm

Originally posted by Eminence
I did this!

When did this happen? I always thought Faunus was on the troll side...

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
You didn't realize it was a spite thread? You should really re-read the first pages of the thread. You actually say that you do not believe the Empire can win. I can give you quotes if you want. Something like 'I can't believe 500 000 stormtroopers stand a chance against the entire Earth'. So according to you it wasn't fair. Thus, spite.

On the second page I asked why you would make a thread when you were positive one side would win. Then you responded with:

Do you realize that for the first half of the thread Lucien, Nai and Gideon argued FOR the Empire and claimed that they would win "easily" and quickly "break the will" of the world via simple mind tricks? So you're claiming that I should have realized that it's a spite early on in the thread, but Lucien, Nai and Gideon didn't until much later and yet you don't blame THEM.

(an argument that I predict you will make) "Well that's because you twisted the thread and it wasn't a spite at first so that's why they argued for the Empire!" Well if it wasn't a spite a first then that means that I WOULDN'T HAVE RECOGNIZED THAT IT WAS A SPITE IN THE EARLY PAGES BECAUSE IT WASN'T!!!!!

You do not get what I'm saying. **** spite.

I don't care what they said. I said that YOU made that thread while YOU were sure Earth would win. Tell me now, honestly, that you wouldn't have thought that the Earth would definately win the thread, before anyone posted.

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
You do not get what I'm saying. **** spite.

I don't care what they said. I said that YOU made that thread while YOU were sure Earth would win. Tell me now, honestly, that you wouldn't have thought that the Earth would definately win the thread, before anyone posted.

Let me try to say it clearly:

I thought (pretty surely) that Earth would win. HOWEVER, I admitted that the Empire would put up a VERY good fight. That's why I voted "Earth wins" and not "Earth pwns"

The others thought that the Empire would win and that they would easily just capture a single nuclear country, blackmail the other countries and use their super ultra pwning tech to win. They also thought that we would NOT EVEN BE ABLE TO HARM the imperials in any way. So basically, they have a 0 casualty win.

AND, you say that you don't care about what they said but you do care about what I said? It's not fair that you yell at me for doing X but NOT at them for doing X as well. Either yell at both of us or neither of us.

Anyway, Earth still wins in this one, but the Eclipse one is DEFINITELY a spite...

Dude guys its over already. Stop arguing. Janus got banned for doing that, and you may be banned soon as well.

I understand that. So guys: why don't we just all stop arguing? I was GOING to stop, but then Slash KMC came and said something against me...and now that I've posted a rebuttal I suspect that he won't respond to it, or just quote it and say "you're pathetic" but now actually responding to my points.

Let's stop now. Besides, we aren't really "arguing", since you aren't responding to my arguments, thus making it a flame war. Peace 🙂

Now let's get back to actually (gasp!) discussing something instead of arguing over whether or not this is a spite (note that I DIDN'T MAKE THIS THREAD). I think that Earth wins this one, but loses miserably in the Eclipse vs Earth one.

dude Eclipse is so goddamn cheap. superlaser and its over.

Or is the superlaser not allowed?

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
I understand that. So guys: why don't we just all stop arguing? I was GOING to stop, but then Slash KMC came and said something against me...and now that I've posted a rebuttal I suspect that he won't respond to it, or just quote it and say "you're pathetic" but now actually responding to my points.

The hell? I don't get why Janus gets banned and you don't. This cocky attitude of yours plus the inside the box thinking is really getting on my nerves.

First, I said it to you before you were 'going to stop'. And second. Saying stuff like this: "and now that I've posted a rebuttal I suspect that he won't respond to it, or just quote it and say "you're pathetic" but now actually responding to my points." is clearly provoking me into answering your post and I know a troll like yourself would just get too much satisfaction out of it.

where does it say eclipse in my op?

wrong thread. 😛

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
The hell? I don't get why Janus gets banned and you don't. This cocky attitude of yours plus the inside the box thinking is really getting on my nerves.

First, I said it to you before you were 'going to stop'. And second. Saying stuff like this: "and now that I've posted a rebuttal I suspect that he won't respond to it , or just quote it and say "you're pathetic" but now actually responding to my points." is clearly provoking me into answering your post and I know a troll like yourself would just get too much satisfaction out of it.

dudes how about lets just stop before everyone on this thread gets banned... (but not me cuz I need to study) lol

still got chem, math, spanish, and history finals left.

and hewhoknowsall... why do you have to provoke people like that? before, slash was ok with you, now you get him pissed, you might/probably will get banned along with Janus.

you do know that Slash has extremely good points there...
saying stuff like

've posted a rebuttal I suspect that he won't respond to it

,

you're pathetic

I was GOING to stop, but then Slash KMC came and said something against me..

and

we aren't really "arguing", since you aren't responding to my arguments

perhaps you should just say " Kotorfan has made a good point. Lets just end it now. Peace 😄"

that would be alot better instead of stuff like the above as quoted...

AND.. don't put the blame on other ppl by saying:

(note that I DIDN'T MAKE THIS THREAD).

and I miracously still have nothing against you (I know lots of ppl who can't stop talking), but you should really learn to keep quiet...

That's what my thread was about: let's either:

1. Make peace and continuing debating about the actual subject

2. If we have problems with eachother, then politely discuss them and actually answer eachother's arguments.

BACK ON TOPIC, Earth wins, although I'm starting to doubt whether or not they can destroy the Victory class...

They really can't. No nuclear warhead will be able to get past the ship's guns to detonate within an effective range and I know of nothing that can make it to the ship and get through the shields. Utilizing its TIE contingent, the ship can defend both itself from attack and the ground forces marching beneath it. In such a manner, the Imps can stroll along from location to location, eliminating resistance and securing regions.

how well do you think the SD will fare against an emp attack?

idk.. send one tie as a sacrifice to block it..?

I'm not exactly sure what an emp is though.

btw WO polaski, in your sig, the k in polaski looks like an H...