Originally posted by Samurai100
What would happen when a lightsaber hits a dementor its plasma so probably the same as when it hits everything else
They're based on magic, they invisible and intangible. Sabre likely go through, if a Jedi were to somehow sense them.
RJ adding them now is nothing but spite. Guy is desperate for his beloved Potter franchise to
I'm still curious if they ever affected someone that couldn't see them, in the movies. ie have they ever done anything to a "muggle"?
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
No it's not, Bellatrix and Fenrir were inside the Burrow, in flight, for maybe 1/4 second, and the burrow was engulfed in flames. It's fast and deadly. It moves as fast as the caster desires.Pathetic? They are a weapon, a weapon the wizards can use, why not include them? Dont answer that, I already know, it's because even now you refuse to accept the true extent of a wizards power. Your Potter hatred is blinding you.
A weapon is a weapon. Invisible or visible. If the Jedi could go invisible, you'd be milking that cow all week.
Hey, alot could happen. Dont see too much force pushing/pulling while fiendfyre is all over their asses.
It needs to be cast first and it's relatively slow. Wizard would be open to a force-attack, lightsabre-blitz or blaster fire.
No, it's spite. Adding something that the opponent can't see, defend against or attack AFTER THE FACT, is SPITE.
Even with your gimp here, question still remains, have the Dementors every been able to do something to a "muggle"?
Originally posted by RobtardAs I said, if the Jedi could go invisible, or summon something like dementors, you'd be all over it. You're just butthurt.
They're based on magic, they invisible and intangible. Sabre likely go through, if a Jedi were to somehow sense them.RJ adding them now is nothing but spite. Guy is desperate for his beloved Potter franchise to
I'm still curious if they ever affected someone that couldn't see them, in the movies. ie have they ever done anything to a "muggle"?
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
As I said, if the Jedi could go invisible, or summon something like dementors, you'd be all over it. You're just butthurt.
No, I wouldn't make a thread where one opponent is (in theory) completely defenseless and clueless to an adversary.
Doing so is spite and you're doing it now, because you're butthurt over the 501st Vs Hogwarts, Palpatine Vs Potter and this thread, which didn't include the Dementors from the start, but now it does, because you desparately need Harry Potter to win.
Originally posted by Robtard
It needs to be cast first and it's relatively slow. Wizard would be open to a force-attack, lightsabre-blitz or blaster fire.No, it's spite. Adding something that the opponent can't see, defend against or attack AFTER THE FACT, is SPITE.
Even with your gimp here, question still remains, have the Dementors every been able to do something to a "muggle"?
Listen to me carefully....
Bellatrix and Fenrir flew into the burrow, which was not on fire.....They exited out the other side half a second later........While inside, while still in flight, they cast fiendfyre. Its not slow, Rob, you know it and I know it, the movie proves it.
After the fact? I included the Hogwarts staff in the OP. Umbridge is on the Hogwarts staff. She can control the dementors. Connect the dots, babe.
Yes, Dudley was being drained by one.
Originally posted by RobtardIf you say so.
No, I wouldn't make a thread where one opponent is (in theory) completely defenseless and clueless to an adversary.Doing so is spite and you're doing it now, because you're butthurt over the 501st Vs Hogwarts, Palpatine Vs Potter and this thread, which didn't include the Dementors from the start, but know it does, because you desparately need Harry Potter to win.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
If you say so.
It's clear to anyone reading. You started the thread as Jedi (with the Yoda, Anakin and Mace gimp, which you corrected, kudos) Vs Wizards. Which is a fair enough thread.
Once people proved that the Jedi would stomp, you bring in Dementors, AFTER THE FACT. Turning this into butt-hurt fueled spite thread.
This is a common tactic of yours, dude. When the side you're cheering for is shown to lose, you start angling changes and gimps to dictate the outcome.
Originally posted by RobtardThe Jedi would get pwned even without the Dementors. They have no way of battling fiendfyre. The dementors just turned an ass kicking into a curbstomp.
It's clear to anyone reading. You started the thread as Jedi (with the Yoda, Anakin and Mace gimp, which you corrected, kudos) Vs Wizards. Which is a fair enough thread.Once people proved that the Jedi would stomp, you bring in Dementors, AFTER THE FACT. Turning this into butt-hurt fueled spite thread.
This is a common tactic of yours, dude. When the side you're cheering for is shown to lose, you start angling changes and gimps to dictate the outcome.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
The Jedi would get pwned even without the Dementors. They have no way of battling fiendfyre. The dementors just turned an ass kicking into a curbstomp.
Nah, as the thread was started Jedi Vs Wizards in the temple. The Jedi would win in the end, for reasons listed, greater numbers, precog, speed, reflexes Force-powers and guns. Might only be 5 Jedi standing in the end, but that's a win.
Adding an enemy that the Jedi can't see and are completely defenseless against is spite and serves no purpose.
Then again, if the Jedi kill the wizard that's controlling the Dementors. You probably didn't think of that.
Originally posted by Robtard
Nah, as the thread was started Jedi Vs Wizards in the temple. The Jedi would win in the end, for reasons listed, greater numbers, precog, speed, reflexes Force-powers and guns. Might only be 5 Jedi standing in the end, but that's a win.Adding an enemy that the Jedi can't see and are completely defenseless against is spite and serves no purpose.
Then again, if the Jedi kill the wizard that's controlling the Dementors. You probably didn't think of that.
Fiendfyre, Rob. No defense against that.
Thats why she will be protected? Wouldnt be that hard to assign a second, one to take control should she be killed, one that the dementors would obey.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Fiendfyre, Rob. No defense against that.Thats why she will be protected? Wouldnt be that hard to assign a second, one to take control should she be killed, one that the dementors would obey.
Avoid it, kill the caster, avoid it again and move on.
Was that shown on film? Also, see the spite-angle at adding an opponent like the Dementors to begin with. Might as well add Q and try to argue it isn't spite.
Originally posted by RobtardAvoid it? How? It's a wall of flame, there is no escaping it. Read what I just told Mrs. M.
Avoid it, kill the caster, avoid it again and move on.Was that shown on film? Also, see the spite-angle at adding an opponent like the Dementors to begin with. Might as well add Q and try to argue it isn't spite.
The dementors are controlled by magic, dude. All wizards have magic. Doesn't really matter, she can control them from a mile away, she can be in Azkaban, she tells them where to go, what to do, and they do it.
Originally posted by RobtardThey can cast fiendfyre while half apparating, as shown in THBP. They can be far out of reach of the Jedi, hundreds of feet in the air.
Been said repeatedly, he won't accept that a Jedi is capable of doing so, since the wizards apparently can cast all their spells in less than a second, in his mind.
And yes, they CAN cast spells in under a second, HP did it in OOTP, I just watched Bellatrix do it in THBP, as she did in OOTP. It was shown onscreen, dude.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
They can cast fiendfyre while half apparating, as shown in THBP. They can be far out of reach of the Jedi, hundreds of feet in the air.
Being able to fly away wouldn't counter Jedi-precog, Jedi would know a second beore it happened and could react to it.
Also, being force-pushed/pulled while in the air would stop them from casting spells, might even make them drop to the ground.
Fiendfyre is dark-magic, so not every wizard here would use it. Edit: Only a few people did that half-shit too, seems to be an evil-wizard power only.