Harry Potter vs Darth Vader

Started by Rogue Jedi45 pages

Originally posted by Robtard
Dude, come on. Stop being a jack-ass. It's getting sad now.

The Padme scene I just explained to you in more than one way, not sure I can dumb it down further. He clearly has control in choking/The Force. Why he can choke someone and they can still speak, why he can choke someone to death and can only gurgle or KO someone the moment he needs.

He choked her for a while, then KO'd her.

He choked Ozzel for a while, then killed him.

Screen feats dictate that Vader has to force choke for a while THEN ko/kill. Screen feats dictate that the choking must be done for a bit, and only then may he ko/kill. Never, not once, is he shown koing/killing right away.

Accept it.

Screen feats dont dictate that. If a noob like Luke can choke Gammoreans immediately so could a Master 100x better than him, logically. End of.

Vader's instant crush of the machines in that room in ROTS completely destroy what you're saying...It shows that he pulls his punches when choking, until he decides enough is enough.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Screen feats dont dictate that. If a noob like Luke can choke Gammoreans immediately so could a Master 100x better than him, logically. End of.

Vader's instant crush of the machines in that room in ROTS completely destroy what you're saying.

You're not looking at the big picture. On a regular basis, how does Vader execute force choke? He chokes for a bit, then KO's/kills.

✅ Out of preference, clearly... Not from the lack of ability to kill/destroy quickly.

So as we can see, from that, its actually you who needs to step back for the broader view....then when the smoke clears and you see the wizard carcasses and rubble, the truth will be upon you

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
He choked her for a while, then KO'd her.

He choked Ozzel for a while, then killed him.

Screen feats dictate that Vader has to force choke for a while THEN ko/kill. Screen feats dictate that the choking must be done for a bit, and only then may he ko/kill. Never, not once, is he shown koing/killing right away.

Accept it.


Choked her; she could still speak; KO'd her the moment he needed.

Killed him without making him pass-out and he could only gurgle.

Clearly indicates that Vader (and likely any powerful Force-User) has precise control. If he could only apply 'X' amount of force and has to wait as you claim, then Ozzel would have passed out first, not just gurgled and died and Padme wouldn't have been able to speak, she would have gurgled like Ozzel.

It's there to see and logic dictates he has control, if we factor in how the Force is used in the six films. You really need to accept that Harry Potter isn't the end all be all.

HP lacks the ability to have faster reflexes than Spiderman, unlike force users according to RJ..

Originally posted by Robtard
Choked her; she could still speak; KO'd her the moment he needed.

Killed him without making him pass-out and he could only gurgle.

Clearly indicates that Vader (and likely any powerful Force-User) has precise control. If he could only apply 'X' amount of force and has to wait as you claim, then Ozzel would have passed out first, not just gurgled and died and Padme wouldn't have been able to speak, she would have gurgled like Ozzel.

It's there to see and logic dictates he has control, if we factor in how the Force is used in the six films. You really need to accept that Harry Potter isn't the end all be all.

haermm End to be all? haermm

No, I just think HP magic is more powerful and more diverse than the Force. A wizard can do much more powerful things.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
HP lacks the ability to have faster reflexes than Spiderman, unlike force users according to RJ..

Ah, but HP wizards all have the ability to slow them down to an ants crawl, even freeze them. Or vanish them.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
haermm End to be all? haermm

No, I just think HP magic is more powerful and more diverse than the Force. A wizard can do much more powerful things.

Being able to pull flowers out of yer vagina is not a skill found to be too handy on the battlefield.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Ah, but HP wizards all have the ability to slow them down to an ants crawl, even freeze them. Or vanish them.

Not in a universe where its governed by the force.

And for the Jedi and Sith (Symbiotes with the force) to be involved the force is there as given.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Not in a universe where its governed by the force.

And for the Jedi and Sith (Symbiotes with the force) to be involved the force is there as given.

Nah. Magic works just fine on Jedi, and the Force works just fine on wizards.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Not in a universe where its governed by the force.

And for the Jedi and Sith (Symbiotes with the force) to be involved the force is there as given.


I'm not that familiar with the rules of the MVF, but in the Comics Versus forum we have a shared Universe rule where the powers of both combatants work.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
I'm not that familiar with the rules of the MVF, but in the Comics Versus forum we have a shared Universe rule where the powers of both combatants work.
That's how it works here.

Well without forbidden spells Harry doesn't stand much of a chance here. Even with them I think Darth Vader can still take a majority. Don't the forbidden spells require you to be 100% committed to them? Harry was completely bloodlusted when he used the torturing curse on Bellastrix (it was her right? been a while) and I don't think he'd ever be bloodlusted enough to use the killing curse and make it work.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
I'm not that familiar with the rules of the MVF, but in the Comics Versus forum we have a shared Universe rule where the powers of both combatants work.

Indeed. Thats a good way of working it, but within those rules, the force and its users can interfere with every wizard and spell due to how the force works.

Its just the way this particular match plays out. 🙂

YouTube video

A blank post?

Nah, just laughing at you and your idiocy.

MY Idiocy? 😂

How sweet of you to say.
YouTube video

But no Im not. I wouldn't wanna steal your gig.

"the force and its users can interfere with every wizard and spell due to how the force works." crylaugh