Harry Potter vs Darth Vader

Started by Sadako of Girth45 pages
Originally posted by Lestov16
Well, although I understand Sadako's argument of The Force being the macro end-all-be-all, I'm going to (*sighs*) agree with RJ, that, in battle, Potter wizards would pawn serious ass. Once again, I understand what you are saying Sadako. the Force is over all things. However, Jedi and Sith's abilities to manipulate the Force to the potential they will need to beat the wizards is virtually non-existent (in the films at least). As far as the Star Wars saga's characters go (not including EU charcters and feats), they simply can not compare to Wizards, who are summoning shit out of mid-air at will

A well written post.

Balancing point:

Force lightning, Using the force to rip rock down from ceilings, Force Pull/Push, Crush/Choke, Precog and all that are all shown numerous times being effective in combat.

Likewise HP magic has no answer for their attacks when they lack the power to overide something that overides what ever they do. Especially with Precog intell too. Wizards in the grip of a vicious Dark Side force attack definitely couldn't cast spells.

If Vader is emotional about the meeting (Emotional like the end of ROTS) then Harry is crushed along with the whole room in a single "NOOOOO".

Originally posted by Nephthys
Never has an avatar and its owner been so in sync. Its beautiful.

Absolutely. Complete symbiosis, ethically.

💃

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
LOL 😂 Teasle.

Nope theres no desperation other than to get you to understand how one sided SW/HP matches are when the SW side isn't gimped.

Your attempt to bring in Voldemort in a Harry Potter VS Vader thread in response to a perfectly viable screen feat based move by Vader, is the REAL sign of who is truely desperate here. 😮‍💨

I figured you'd get and appreciate the Teasle comment haermm Say hello to Gault for me.

I did that because the convo unfortunately turned to the Force versus Magic in general.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
A well written post.

Balancing point:

Force lightning, Using the force to rip rock down from ceilings, Force Pull/Push, Crush/Choke, Precog and all that are all shown numerous times being effective in combat.

Likewise HP magic has no answer for their attacks when they lack the power to overide something that overides what ever they do. Especially with Precog intell too. Wizards in the grip of a vicious Dark Side force attack definitely couldn't cast spells.

If Vader is emotional about the meeting (Emotional like the end of ROTS) then Harry is crushed along with the whole room in a single "NOOOOO".

Whole room? Did you even read the OP?

Whole Prison then.
Wizard semantics by you the master of Wizard seman.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I figured you'd get and appreciate the Teasle comment haermm Say hello to Gault for me.

I did that because the convo unfortunately turned to the Force versus Magic in general.

Hello Gault. 😛

Well you you kept trying to ignore legitimate force user pwnages of wizards....so course I was gonna up the ante within the legitimate confides of SW screenfeats. 🙂

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Hello Gault. 😛

Well you you kept trying to ignore legitimate force user pwnages of wizards....so course I was gonna up the ante within the legitimate confides of SW screenfeats. 🙂

I'm just going with the high end screen feats for force attacks.

Except you've attempted to downplay and gimp them the whole way.

Nah, if I did, quote me.

Oh good. You DO agree. 🙂

What I'll do is keep THAT quote handy for future instances where downplay/gimping taking away Precog/Star Destroyers - which are standard equipment - is attempted.

haermm Agree to what? haermm

Star Destroyers are not standard Jedi gear. Jedi do not pilot them, Jedi do not man them. They are manned by Clones and the Imperial Navy.

No Star Destroyers, no Death Stars.

I know that you're trying to paint your way out of the corner, but you're failing.

That there'll be no SW gimping.

The Jedi gear (Anakin's gear) in the clone wars. 🙂
They are sith (Vader's gear) gear post Clonewars.

It is you who is in the corner.. and that "wizard hat" has a "D" on it. 🙂

Originally posted by Lestov16
Well, although I understand Sadako's argument of The Force being the macro end-all-be-all, I'm going to (*sighs*) agree with RJ, that, in battle, Potter wizards would pawn serious ass. Once again, I understand what you are saying Sadako. the Force is over all things. However, Jedi and Sith's abilities to manipulate the Force to the potential they will need to beat the wizards is virtually non-existent (in the films at least). As far as the Star Wars saga's characters go (not including EU charcters and feats), they simply can not compare to Wizards, who are summoning shit out of mid-air at will

Tsk tsk Lestov. You should be ashamed of yourself bro. The Force does infact rule over all including Harry Potter magic. Wizards of waverly place magic is even better than Harry Potter magic. I watched like 2 episodes with my nieces and all I thought was A) Selena Gomez is hot. And B) This is gay. But as they were using magic, they used it without wands and without spell casting. To say that someone couldn't use the force to instantly push or pull a wand from someone is insane. Especially Vader's control of the force.

Originally posted by Kaibs
Tsk tsk Lestov. You should be ashamed of yourself bro. The Force does infact rule over all including Harry Potter magic. Wizards of waverly place magic is even better than Harry Potter magic. I watched like 2 episodes with my nieces and all I thought was A) Selena Gomez is hot. And B) This is gay. But as they were using magic, they used it without wands and without spell casting. To say that someone couldn't use the force to instantly push or pull a wand from someone is insane. Especially Vader's control of the force.

My 1st post on page 1. Has yet to be trumped or properly gimped away by RJ.

Originally posted by Robtard
The Force rapes here.

Correct.

....along with all other Sw points raised, preemptively ignored by the wizard molester. 😛

Originally posted by Kaibs
Tsk tsk Lestov. You should be ashamed of yourself bro. The Force does infact rule over all including Harry Potter magic. Wizards of waverly place magic is even better than Harry Potter magic. I watched like 2 episodes with my nieces and all I thought was A) Selena Gomez is hot. And B) This is gay. But as they were using magic, they used it without wands and without spell casting. To say that someone couldn't use the force to instantly push or pull a wand from someone is insane. Especially Vader's control of the force.

No, it doesn't. HP magic has vastly superior screen feats.

There are also spells that do not require a wand. ✅

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
That there'll be no SW gimping.

The Jedi gear (Anakin's gear) in the clone wars. 🙂
They are sith (Vader's gear) gear post Clonewars.

It is you who is in the corner.. and that "wizard hat" has a "D" on it. 🙂

Nah, no Death stars, no star destroyers.

Just the Jedi and their powers.

Originally posted by Robtard
My 1st post on page 1. Has yet to be trumped or properly gimped away by RJ.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
No, it doesn't. HP magic has vastly superior screen feats.

There are also spells that do not require a wand. ✅

Nah, no Death stars, no star destroyers.

Just the Jedi and their powers.

OK, Star Destroyers and Death stars are standard for Vader.

So if they go, so do wands, spellbooks and capes.

So stop crying.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
OK, Star Destroyers and Death stars are standard for Vader.

So if they go, so do wands, spellbooks and capes.

So stop crying.

also standard eq for Vader is his TIE Fighter 😄