Originally posted by Nephthys
What, like the Nazi's deserved to win? Tarrlok is manipulating the situation amd making himself look like the saviour of benderkind. The populace is scared because of Amon, the police follow orders and the council are puppets. Basically in power isn't actually in power. If he was actually in charge he wouldn't need to ask the council for permission or merely 'advise' the police chief on matters. He could just rule.
If every single one of them supported Tarrlok's obviously evil actions, then Amon can take the bending of every single person. Because honestly that means he is right. And basically in power is being in power. He doesn't seem to desire to get rid of Tenzin, who is the only person outside of his pocket. He seems content where he is. Bei-Fong's proposal just offered him a chance to pull a Xanatos Gambit.
Originally posted by Nephthys
Korra is right, but not in all areas. She's still a stubborn teenager and she still needs to learn how to be spiritual and deal with these situations by actually thinking. This has been the point about her that has been stressed the most imo, in her actions and her inability to learn airbending. Since the first episode, as you said there have been times when Korra very clearly is not in the right on a situation. Did you even watch the episode? Look at when Tarrlok points out that he's handling things pretty much just like she is. Korra stumbles over her response because he's [b]right. And thats amazing. When a villain can point that out and be right, unnerving the protagonist in that way? That's goddamn quality storytelling.[/B]
That is why she is my favorite character. The problem? It's stupid. Tarrlok can say that Korra acts like him but actions speak louder than words. Tarrlok at that point had done irredeemable things. Korra can feel slightly guilty about being a bit of a bully but really that is just dumb. It's not horrible storytelling but it can be told far better.
Originally posted by Nephthys
I guess we'll see whether they'll work or not. as you've said he's been very effective in his hand-line approach so far, so I don't see why you think it won't.Yeah he was. You may not have seen it, but Tarrlok was obviously a bad guy since he first appeared.
Korra unlikable in the first episode? You mean when she refused to stand by and let some thugs break up a shop or when she said she wanted to help Tenzin fix Republic City? And now? Fighting bankrobbers and the Equalist's? Trying to help that crowd? I can see how goddamn entitled she is, using her powers to help others. That b1tch.
Seriously she doesn't wreck the city any more than Superman does, and only to stop bad guys. Property damage? Effing lol! Give an earthbender 5 minutes and he'd have cleared everything up and even if not, keeping people safe and stopping the Equalist rightly trump some ****ing property damage. She's depicted as being right because she is.
No, it will probably work. Bad writing tends to justify itself regardless. Like, say, everyone calling Shirahoshi a brave and strong person for not telling her dad about Hodi Jones...right when Hodi has them all hostage. Good job there kid.
The thing is, calling Tarrlok as a villain is easy. It's something everyone predicted. To me, that is just boring. It's so easy to spot that it's boring. I didn't want him to be the villain because, well, I think the alternative is more interesting and more subtle. Instead, Tarrlok started acting evil. And you cannot point to a single instance in the last 2 episodes he was in and call it evil.
Yes, she was lol. She tries to do good things(has a good heart) but she thinks because she is the Avatar that it excuses her. This is evident in the first episode. This is evident in the latest episode. Regardless of whether or not she is trying to do good things, the excuse of "I'm the Avatar so I can do this stuff" is unlikable. Korra is more complicated than that of course but that trait is still unlikable.
Yes, property damage. That thing she got in trouble for in the show. Then it was a bad thing, now it's not...because Tarrlok is the bad guy. Lin gives it to her word for word in episode one, "You can't just come here and do what you want." At the very least there is was at least a grey area of morality because Bei-Fong had a point. Here it's not because...well she is the Avatar and compared to the shit Tarrlok is doing, it hardly matters.
Originally posted by Nephthys
Yes, because you're ridiculously hard to please, and are being kind of whiny. You thought Tarrlok was this morally ambiguous anti-hero who is kind of a jerk but dammit he gets the job done, when actually he's a crazy fascist. Just because you were worng doesn't make the writing stupid. This has been the best written episode so far imo.Edit: This post may have been more agressive than i intended. I don't mean to have a go at you Aura. I enjoy talking about this really.
I'm hard to please? Hardly. Keep in mind, overall I like the episode, mainly for the ending. And no, quite honestly I only thought of Tarrlok based on what I saw of him. I hoped he would be that. I knew there was a strong chance for him to be what he turned out to be(though no, I didn't expect these extremes so early). There really is nothing wrong in that stance. My hope simply didn't happen. And not really. The best episode was Voice in the Night, for me anyway.
Nah, it doesn't bother me. Truth be told it is fun to talk about things with someone who disagrees with ya. Educates them and yourself a bit more. It's a kids show and neither one of us loves it to the point to get genuinely mad about it. Least, I don't think.