All-Star Superman Vs Silver Surfer

Started by Black bolt z16 pages

Surfer

All Star Superman.
Normal Superman I would give Surfer the majority though.

Originally posted by kgkg
Anyway there are plenty of example of Surfer moving real fast.

Just a few
Moves before a Nano Second is passed.: Nano Second is one billionth of a second

One nanosecond is to one second as one second is to 31.7 years.
http://img258.imageshack.us/img258/48/marvelcomicspresents001fk4.jpg

His brain can think and react at those speed as well

OK time is short and not enough time to answer everything

I just have to say, this thing with the silver surfer nanosecond reaction = flashe's 2000 punches in a second is just completelly out of context

I have seen several time in which characters with out super speed had reacted at those speeds and it does not mean they can punch 2000 times in a second

I have seen Batman dodging lasers which is = to a nanosecond reaction time
I have seen Hulk dodging laser wich is = to a nanosecond reaction time
I have seen GL reacting at thise speeds because after all GL'S move at the speed of light and to move at those speeds you need nanosecond reaction time.

Neither of those guys can punch 2000 times in one second

1.017 nanoseconds (approximately) – time taken for ligth to travel 1 foot.
So any of this guys dodging lasers must have super speed combat in the same sense as the Flash or Superman do.

If just by having nanosecond reaction time counts as someone being capable of having combat super speed then Batman, Hulk and GL have combat superspees in the same way Flash does.

If this wishful thinking rule of having nanosecond reaction time is = to 2000 punches in a second, then Superman can also travel between dimensions, because He has matched and Inverted the vibrational pattern of a ghost planet from another universe that was merging with earth, therefore if He can match the vibrational pattern and even invert it it means He can also travel between dimensions and universes even though it has never been shown he can do that in modern history.

I have never seen SS punching something the same way Flash, Superman, Quicksilver or even Thor can do (Yes Thor can punch the same way Flash can, but not as fast, because he has moved his limbs that fast in the past) Until I see the SS performing that feat, he has combat speed, BUT NOT in the same sense as Flash or Superman do, otherwise it becomes wishful thinking and if wishful thinking is the rule, then Superman can travel between dimensions.

it still surfer non jobbing SS in a forum fight would still make short work of supes even ASS

Originally posted by biensalsa
OK time is short and not enough time to answer everything

I just have to say, this thing with the silver surfer nanosecond reaction = flashe's 2000 punches in a second is just completelly out of context

I have seen several time in which characters with out super speed had reacted at those speeds and it does not mean they can punch 2000 times in a second

Nobody is saying that, we're saying he won't get blitzed because he can react in under a nanosecond and go nova or raise a force-field for instance - because that's what he does, he activates his powers through will and blasts people, he doesn't brawl. Nobody believes SS could possibly defeat SM in a h2h fight at superspeed, but the SS has reaction time and coordination to use his powers at lightspeed.


I have seen Batman dodging lasers which is = to a nanosecond reaction time
I have seen Hulk dodging laser wich is = to a nanosecond reaction time
I have seen GL reacting at thise speeds because after all GL'S move at the speed of light and to move at those speeds you need nanosecond reaction time.

Neither of those guys can punch 2000 times in one second

1.017 nanoseconds (approximately) – time taken for ligth to travel 1 foot.
So any of this guys dodging lasers must have super speed combat in the same sense as the Flash or Superman do.

If just by having nanosecond reaction time counts as someone being capable of having combat super speed then Batman, Hulk and GL have combat superspees in the same way Flash does.

That's aim dodging/writer's ignorace obviously. Both SS and SM have been clocked reacting to situations and doing things before a nanosecond came to pass between them realizing what was happening and taking action. As omega vision pointed out, SS can navigate and stop cold where he wants to get while moving at lightspeed. That shows he can react in speeds compatible with his travel.

If this wishful thinking rule of having nanosecond reaction time is = to 2000 punches in a second, then Superman can also travel between dimensions, because He has matched and Inverted the vibrational pattern of a ghost planet from another universe that was merging with earth, therefore if He can match the vibrational pattern and even invert it it means He can also travel between dimensions and universes even though it has never been shown he can do that in modern history.

I have never seen SS punching something the same way Flash, Superman, Quicksilver or even Thor can do (Yes Thor can punch the same way Flash can, but not as fast, because he has moved his limbs that fast in the past) Until I see the SS performing that feat, he has combat speed, BUT NOT in the same sense as Flash or Superman do, otherwise it becomes wishful thinking and if wishful thinking is the rule, then Superman can travel between dimensions. [/B]

Again, everyone acknowledges that he doesn't have or never showed lightspeed h2h agility. We're saying combat speed cannot be reduced to or equated with h2h speed, because people can fight without resorting to that. A TP like omega kid has a kind of combat superspeed because he could form thoughts at a much faster rate than regular humans and he attacks with his thoughts, but he never showed physical superspeed.

when SS fought the agent of oblivion he stated on panel while fighting and dodging blast that agent of oblivion's light speed blast are slow compared to SS. SS was circling the guy while dodging blast well above ftl iird correctly it was 3x speed of light by narration while circling the guy in a small circumference while blasting the guy back..

Originally posted by biensalsa
OK time is short and not enough time to answer everything

I just have to say, this thing with the silver surfer nanosecond reaction = flashe's 2000 punches in a second is just completelly out of context

I have seen Batman dodging lasers which is = to a nanosecond reaction time
I have seen Hulk dodging laser wich is = to a nanosecond reaction time
I have seen GL reacting at thise speeds because after all GL'S move at the speed of light and to move at those speeds you need nanosecond reaction time.

😐 There is a difference between dodging stuff knowing where the lasers and bullets and coming from and outright having nano-speed reaction.

I just have to say, this thing with the silver surfer nanosecond reaction = flashe's 2000 punches in a second is just completelly out of context
That was the context

Originally posted by 753
Nobody is saying that, we're saying he won't get blitzed because he can react in under a nanosecond and go nova or raise a force-field for instance - because that's what he does, he activates his powers through will and blasts people, he doesn't brawl. Nobody believes SS could possibly defeat SM in a h2h fight at superspeed, but the SS has reaction time and coordination to use his powers at lightspeed.

That's aim dodging/writer's ignorace obviously. Both SS and SM have been clocked reacting to situations and doing things before a nanosecond came to pass between them realizing what was happening and taking action. As omega vision pointed out, SS can navigate and stop cold where he wants to get while moving at lightspeed. That shows he can react in speeds compatible with his travel.

Again, everyone acknowledges that he doesn't have or never showed lightspeed h2h agility. We're saying combat speed cannot be reduced to or equated with h2h speed, because people can fight without resorting to that. A TP like omega kid has a kind of combat superspeed because he could form thoughts at a much faster rate than regular humans and he attacks with his thoughts, but he never showed physical superspeed.

SS has been tagged by people moving at fast speeds and He has not used any defenses

"SS can navigate and stop cold where he wants to get while moving at lightspeed. That shows he can react in speeds compatible with his travel."

Agreed, but this is like a pilot reacting in a jet fighter, He has higher reaction than a regular human but He is not supersonic. A pilot can react at speeds compatible with his travel as well and We are not Supersonic

Since SS has been tagged by people moving at fast speeds, there is nothing that suggest that SS will be able to react at Superman's attack.
His light pilot reflexes won't work vs Superman, Flash or Thor.

so why did it work during his fight against agent of oblivion? mhmm

Originally posted by kgkg
😐 There is a difference between dodging stuff knowing where the lasers and bullets and coming from and outright having nano-speed reaction.

That was the context

At least We agree that SS cannot punch 2000 times in a second

and I don't see what is the difference it will still be nanosecond reaction time.

You can see where the laser is shotting but by the time you realize it, it is already too late

Originally posted by King Castle
so why did it work during his fight against agent of oblivion? mhmm

The same reason why it has not worked other times

WRITTERS!

so i guess this all applies across the board with supes, flash and whatnot.. u know getting smacked around by a human lvl reaction brick..

@753

"That's aim dodging/writer's ignorace obviously."

Didn't you told me that only high end feats work on the forum?

Batman or Hulk dodging a laser will count as a high end speed feat and as a nanosecond reaction time.

Or only high end feats count for the Surfer?

Originally posted by biensalsa
SS has been tagged by people moving at fast speeds and He has not used any defenses

"SS can navigate and stop cold where he wants to get while moving at lightspeed. That shows he can react in speeds compatible with his travel."

Agreed, but this is like a pilot reacting in a jet fighter, He has higher reaction than a regular human but He is not supersonic. A pilot can react at speeds compatible with his travel as well and We are not Supersonic

Since SS has been tagged by people moving at fast speeds, there is nothing that suggest that SS will be able to react at Superman's attack.
His light pilot reflexes won't work vs Superman, Flash or Thor.


Hasn't Supes been tagged by plenty of people with "human" speed/reactions?

Originally posted by King Castle
so i guess this all applies across the board with supes, flash and whatnot.. u know getting smacked around by a human lvl reaction brick..

Yes I agree.

I actually think that SS getting smacked by bricks is stupid, but I also believe some of high end feats are also stupid. and that is for everyone
including Superman and mind reading with Azarello

Originally posted by darthgoober
Hasn't Supes been tagged by plenty of people with "human" speed/reactions?

Yes He has.

That does not change the fact that SS can be tagged by Superman.

so neither is goin to blitz the other right off the bat... what they will do is gauge and react accordingly...

this is how i see it and why SS will win.

Originally posted by biensalsa
Yes He has.

That does not change the fact that SS can be tagged by Superman.


But it shows us that Supes can also be tagged by Surfer. There are more people who make the claim that Supes can't be touched than there are people saying the same for Surfer.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Hasn't Supes been tagged by plenty of people with "human" speed/reactions?
only when he wants to be

Originally posted by darthgoober
But it shows us that Supes can also be tagged by Surfer. There are more people who make the claim that Supes can't be touched than there are people saying the same for Surfer.

Superman can be tagged by SS with a blast I believe, not with his hands