Originally posted by The MISTER
In America it is optional and there are many countries where it isn't. I'd say that if a person is willing to sacrifice themselves to serve and protect their countrymen then they are a heroic person. They have the potential to become heroes. Soldiers have many people like this amongst their ranks no matter what country they come from. Even a nazi soldier that saved the life of his friend in a battle is perhaps a hero to that friends great great grandchildren. They may not regret that the heroic fellow was in those ranks.
Interestingly enough, those countries where it is not optional rarely go to war. Since it is the option of an individual American citizen to serve in the military, then they are no more heroes than are any other person who applies for a job and is accepted for hte position. It isn't the job that makes someone a hero, it's how a person acts in a given situation. As I said, soldiers in an active army have the greatest chance of finding themselves in a situation where their behavior can be heroic.
I think getting into the whole great great grandchildren angle muddies the waters. This isn't an abortion debate, it's a conversation about soldiers being heroes based solely on their career choice.
As Bill Maher has said, we consider firefighters, police officers and soldiers heroes because they work cheap, and we shold pay them accordingly if we really consider them the heroes we hold them out to be.