Wizard, Death Eater, Jedi or Sith?

Originally posted by Robtard
Prove it isn't!

Well, it's quite obvious, you have not proven that what makes lightsabers be able to cut through doors and what stops avadakedavras from going through doors are the same properties.

For a convoluted example, imagine a world in which ghosts can't go through salt (for example supernatural), yet they are able to go through doors, using a similar logic to yours that would mean that salt can go through doors, however that is not the case.

Or take a real life example, very similar, fire (a blow torch for example) can burn through steel doors, bullets are stopped by steal doors, yet a bunsen burner can not stop a bullet.

In the second case it is the time of exposure you would not have taken into equation (you could claim that lightsabers are instantaneous, but you'd have to prove that), in the first it is specific supernatural properties (though similar examples could exist in the real world) which operate differently (to disprove that you'd have to show that spells operate like other types of matter (which you can't) or you'd have to show that lightsabers can destroy magical or ethereal things (which you can't either).

Was that thorough enough?

How about Lightsabers can cut through doors, death spells can not, therefore lightsabers are better at cutting through doors than death spells?

Originally posted by Grate the Vraya
How about Lightsabers can cut through doors, death spells can not, therefore lightsabers are better at cutting through doors than death spells?

That's logical....yet useless

Nah, all I want to do is cut through doors all day long. No eating; no sleeping; just cutting through doors. So I would prefer to be a sith.

Originally posted by Bardock42
Well, it's quite obvious, you have not proven that what makes lightsabers be able to cut through doors and what stops avadakedavras from going through doors are the same properties.

For a convoluted example, imagine a world in which ghosts can't go through salt (for example supernatural), yet they are able to go through doors, using a similar logic to yours that would mean that salt can go through doors, however that is not the case.

Or take a real life example, very similar, fire (a blow torch for example) can burn through steel doors, bullets are stopped by steal doors, yet a bunsen burner can not stop a bullet.

In the second case it is the time of exposure you would not have taken into equation (you could claim that lightsabers are instantaneous, but you'd have to prove that), in the first it is specific supernatural properties (though similar examples could exist in the real world) which operate differently (to disprove that you'd have to show that spells operate like other types of matter (which you can't) or you'd have to show that lightsabers can destroy magical or ethereal things (which you can't either).

Was that thorough enough?

You do realize that wasn't necessary, right?

Originally posted by Grate the Vraya
Nah, all I want to do is cut through doors all day long. No eating; no sleeping; just cutting through doors. So I would prefer to be a sith.

Why not a Jedi then?

Sith generally have horrible short lives, and even if they don't, they tend to not enjoy it. It seems badass from the outside, but being it? Nah.

Originally posted by Robtard
You do realize that wasn't necessary, right?

Had time. Enjoyed it.

Originally posted by Bardock42
Why not a Jedi then?

Sith generally have horrible short lives, and even if they don't, they tend to not enjoy it. It seems badass from the outside, but being it? Nah.

Like Mods/Goth/Emo?

Originally posted by Bardock42
Why not a Jedi then?

Sith generally have horrible short lives, and even if they don't, they tend to not enjoy it. It seems badass from the outside, but being it? Nah.

Originally posted by Robtard
Like Mods/Goth/Emo?

Except for the badass part, yes.

Bardock, are you one of those door-to-door jedi converters or something?

Originally posted by Grate the Vraya
Bardock, are you one of those door-to-door jedi converters or something?

Well, I'm campaigning for wizards usually, but I'm moonlighting today.

Wizard all the way! 😍

Originally posted by Grate the Vraya
K...hmmm I think I would be a sith then. Are there really any rules/restrictions for them?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Become a quadruple amputee, get burned nearly alive, whine alot.

Originally posted by Grate the Vraya
K...hmmm I think I would be a sith then. Are there really any rules/restrictions for them?

Not exactly rules or restrictions but certainly a negative point is they tend to betray each other a lot, which usually leads to amputations and decapitations.

Yeah but it's always the master who is betrayed by his apprentice, so I could just remain an apprentice until I've lived to a ripe old age, enjoying my life of raping, pillaging, and cutting through doors, before finally becoming the master in the end.

Originally posted by Grate the Vraya
Yeah but it's always the master who is betrayed by his apprentice, so I could just remain an apprentice until I've lived to a ripe old age, enjoying my life of raping, pillaging, and cutting through doors, before finally becoming the master in the end.

What movies have you been watching? Sidious goes through apprentices faster than other people through underwear.

Originally posted by Bardock42
What movies have you been watching? Sidious goes through apprentices faster than other people through underwear.

Originally posted by Bardock42
What movies have you been watching? Sidious goes through apprentices faster than other people through underwear.