Odin VS Gladiator (In a Fist Fight)

Started by Hyperion Prime12 pages
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
AndI know that a lot of people hate the Handbooks but honestly, I like them and think they are quite accurate and unbiased, even if I disagree with some things.

I agree with this 100%

Odin kills Gladiator (even though Glads has the best handbook PL on KMC 🙂...).

Gonna have to agree with Jake and Rage: handbooks are crap.

Originally posted by Harbinger
Gonna have to agree with Jake and Rage: handbooks are crap.

👆

Originally posted by Harbinger
Gonna have to agree with Jake and Rage: handbooks are crap.

👇

Originally posted by Harbinger
Gonna have to agree with Jake and Rage: handbooks are crap.

👆

Originally posted by Harbinger
Gonna have to agree with Jake and Rage: handbooks are crap.

Seems onpoint to me.

Handbooks are at best a secondary source of information. They're generally not usable, especially when it comes to power levels. Bada and I have always treated them as such...

Originally posted by Wodenson
If Galactus was being manhandled by Sentry, and Galactus admitted that he couldn't beat Sentry, you wouldn't accept this as proof of superiority?
Hell no! Also know that superiority is one thing and superior strength is another. Heimdall had superior durability on his side.


I know how comics work.

You mean like when Thor stated that his defeated condition was due to his bouts of weakness, and not the Juggernaut?

I don't doubt this. I just need to see it. Please post a scan or link or just me the issue number.


Just to clarify: If Mangog dominated Thor, but did not land a finishing blow, you'd consider him weaker than Gladiator?
Mangog dominated Thor due to his superior durability. If Mangog had the same durability as Thor but kept his same strength then Mangog wouldn't have dominated Thor. He would have actually lost the fight.
With that said, I view Glads at high confidence stronger than Thor (not by a whole lot though) and Mangog about twice as strong as Thor.
So mangog IMO would be either equals to Glads (at high confidence) or slightly weaker. But note: Mangog is stronger than average confidence Glads.

I think you're quite a ways off the mark.

Name one feat Mangog did that put his strength is more than twice that of Thor's. Because if I'm twice as strong as someone then I'm going to manhandle them like a rag doll.

😂

Do you have any available time coming up h1n8? We can do a battlezone regarding Thor's/Gladiator's strength. Or at least make a specific thread where we go feat for feat for the two.

I'll be honest, proving that Gladiator is twice as strong as Thor is a task too daunting for me. Of course, I'm only half as knowledgeable as you when it comes to the characters.

I'll BZ Glads vs Odin in hth.

no energy projection/amping. gladiator is extremely confident. no wrestling/grappling, kicking, flying. only bareknuckle punching allowed.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
😂

Do you have any available time coming up h1n8? We can do a battlezone regarding Thor's/Gladiator's strength. Or at least make a specific thread where we go feat for feat for the two.

I'll be honest, proving that Gladiator is twice as strong as Thor is a task too daunting for me. Of course, I'm only half as knowledgeable as you when it comes to the characters.

You would lose.

You up for the challenge Carver?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
You up for the challenge Carver?

Why would I when you honesltyonly have nothing but hyperbolic statements to aid you whereas I have on panel showings to aid mine. I can put up one scan from Glads that would make all of Thor physical showings look like sh**. You will have no way of countering it.

All of this is pointless since I give Thor a high majority against him.

So that's a no? It seems you don't really believe Gladiator has any strength edge over Thor. And here I thought you were a true fan of Gladiator. I guess I was wrong.

Double post.

Originally posted by carver9
Why would I when you honesltyonly have nothing but hyperbolic statements to aid you whereas I have on panel showings to aid mine. I can put up one scan from Glads that would make all of Thor physical showings look like sh**. You will have no way of countering it.

All of this is pointless since I give Thor a high majority against him.

How about next weekend? We can limit it to only a few posts so it shouldn't take even an entire day.

Originally posted by h1a8
Hell no!

Then we're not even speaking the same language if both visuals and admission are not sufficient proof of superiority. I mean, what else is there?

I don't doubt this. I just need to see it. Please post a scan or link or just me the issue number.

See the attached scan.

Mangog dominated Thor due to his superior durability.

Durability is what allowed Mangog to shrug off Thor's attacks. Strength is what allowed Mangog to bust Thor's arm and knock him out with little effort.

If Mangog had the same durability as Thor but kept his same strength then Mangog wouldn't have dominated Thor. He would have actually lost the fight.

The Destroyer is even more durable than Mangog, and it doesn't slap Thor around as badly as Mangog does (with strength). Not by half.

How do you explain this?

So mangog IMO would be either equals to Glads (at high confidence) or slightly weaker. But note: Mangog is stronger than average confidence Glads.

You must have a real love-on for Gladiator.

Name one feat Mangog did that put his strength is more than twice that of Thor's.

With a shrug, Mangog sent millions of tons worth of boulders careering through the air like 'grains of sand'. He killed 100 'elite' Asgardians within the 'space of a heartbeat'. He flattened an army of consisting of several hundred Asgardians with one punch. When Thor threw Mjolnir at Mangog, he simply punched it back at him.

Your turn, o' confident Gladiator.

Because if I'm twice as strong as someone then I'm going to manhandle them like a rag doll.

You mean like when Mangog was carrying Ulik around helplessly with one hand? Or like when Mangog literally chewed Thor up and spit him out like a bad yam?

Rage and Carv should meet each other somewhere.