Thor vs Silver Surfer vs Superman · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

Bentley Seitei

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ So Superman's magic weakness is also non-existent here?

Yes.

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by Bentley
Yes.

So only one person get a benefit while the other 2 doesn't?

Batman-Prime Kryptonian Scientist

Originally posted by carver9
So only one person get a benefit while the other 2 doesn't?

That's why this person would take the slight majority. With weaknesses it's about even.

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
That's why this person would take the slight majority. With weaknesses it's about even.

I would still give Thor the majority but overall, its not fair. I guess this shows just how much Surfer and Thor is above him since they need no handicaps to make it a fight. 😈

I'm still giving Thor the majority even though Bently is riding something serious.

Dizzlerx Restricted

.

carver9 Senior Member

Thor and Surfer can hit a 100 times in a second as well.

Wodenson Senior Member

Superman gets hit all the time by people slower than Thor. Also show me Superman hitting someone on Thor's level with anywhere near 100 punches per second.

Dizzlerx Restricted

.

Dizzlerx Restricted

.

Dizzlerx Restricted

.

Wodenson Senior Member

Originally posted by Dizzlerx
thats called cis you idiot. which doesnt hold any relevance in battle forums. its the same reason why wolverine was able to blitz thor before.

It's not CIS. Superman either has the ability and he uses it, or he doesn't. I know Superman has super-speed, but I've never seen him throw more than half a dozen punches in a row.

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by Dizzlerx
no they cant, neither have ever done this before.

I know they haven't and neither has Superman but since it sounds good to me... Thor punches Superman 1000 per second while making himself some grape koolaid.

-Pr- Hey Yo!

Guys, please don't respond to obvious socks.

D-Block Senior Member

Good Fight Thor wins.

OneDumbG0 Find Your Own Fire

Originally posted by -Pr-
Guys, please don't respond to obvious socks.

Reported for accusing someone of being a sock. biscuits

Newjak I am Beyond Power

Originally posted by illadelph12
Yeah...
...and Surfer [b]still wins. [/B]

I still say it is a toss up between Thor or Surfer.

nimbus006 Accuser

I honestly believe if these 3 fought 900 times, each would win 300 battles depending on the day.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
That's why this person would take the slight majority. With weaknesses it's about even.

So even with his weakness it's an even split ? LOL.

Brockalizer A midget among dwarves.

Originally posted by Bentley
Since Surfer isn't outgunned and the debate is still going on this is a valid thread.
Keep in mind that without considering weaknesses we can actually gauge their feats as if they were generic instead of depending and defining the battle around weaknesses. This opens a range of strategies and possibilities that are better explored than dismissed for the sake of "fairness".

If the point is to see who the best flat out melee brawler is, then I'd have to go with Thor. He's been brawling with herald class opponents and often winning for thousands of years.
If the point is to see which character would have the best strategy, then weakness exploitation is certainly within character for Silver Surfer and he is probably the one I would pick. Mentioning it was enough to keep Gladiator in line.
If the point is to eliminate a characters invulnerabilties (except for greatest invulnerability, his writers) while simultaneously handicapping the other two in an effort give said character an easy victory, then I would have to pick Superman.

Batman-Prime Kryptonian Scientist

I think, honestly that Superman proved already that he should be trans, that's why I give the others equal chances with weakness exploits. Without they lose, but both Surfer and Thor are the high end of the herald level and near trans themselves.