Originally posted by Sr J-BiebI've noticed it being posted throughout the thread over and over, and I think this is the first time I've addressed it.
Not really, it's just getting ignored.Galactus vs Zoom is getting old? Is that what you're talking about, Galactus vs Zoom? Because it seems you're talking about Galactus vs Zoom.
It just seems like it if it was gonna make its point it would have by now. I understand your just trying to make the point that people who say Zoom wins vs Odin yet can say Zoom can not beat Galactus. I understand you are trying to expose the hypocrisy of it all. But I've never felt taking something to the extreme to try and balance out something like that works very well.
I also have a question for CM and Galan. You guys seem to say that Odin can win. I was wondering how do you think Odin wins if he can?
Originally posted by SasuOna
Make a Zoom vs Galactus thread and maybe then I'll say something on the matter.
As it stands that question has no bearing on Odin vs Zoom
I made the thread like you asked.
Originally posted by NewjakI haven't said anything about it really.
I've noticed it being posted throughout the thread over and over, and I think this is the first time I've addressed it.It just seems like it if it was gonna make its point it would have by now. I understand your just trying to make the point that people who say Zoom wins vs Odin yet can say Zoom can not beat Galactus. I understand you are trying to expose the hypocrisy of it all. But I've never felt taking something to the extreme to try and balance out something like that works very well.
I also have a question for CM and Galan. You guys seem to say that Odin can win. I was wondering how do you think Odin wins if he can?
Although I am highly curious to see the responses
Originally posted by leonidas
and that's where at least h1 takes things to its end. if you think he--and all others in dc--can IN THEORY hit with force enough to destroy galaxies, and you DON'T see that as a problem, wellllll......... shrugand you're right--i DON'T accept it. NOT becasue i don't like it. but because there is ZERO proof of anything remotely close to that--on panel OR 'in comicbook theory'--to support it.
It's easy. What is the IMP based on and why is it even called INFINITE MASS PUNCH? Does the word INFINITE ring a bell?
It is clear from canon comics that the IMP is based off the special theory of relativity which states that the closer an object with mass gets to the speed of light then the more mass it gains and thus producing a higher kinetic energy and higher momentum (also explained in the comics).
Using Lorentz transformation
m=m0/sqrt(1-v^2/c^2), where m is relativistic mass, m0 is rest mass, v is velocity, and c is the speed of light in a vacuum, we see that the closer v is to c then the closer the denominator gets to 0 from the positive side and thus making the relativistic mass astronomical. The limit of this function is infinity and hence the name INFINITE MASS PUNCH.
Agreed some writers chose not to champion relativity and some have.
Some writers chosen not to champion neither relativity nor the idea that punching power is based off speed and mass but purely strength.
Zoom's punching power has been championed by ALL of these viewpoints. Thus choosing Zoom at his best we must champion the idea of Zoom's punching power being based off relativity.
With CIS off Zoom can plan, before the bell, on hitting Odin with a strike at 1x10^-88% away from the speed of light (more kinetic energy than several galaxies) and killing him outright.
Originally posted by h1a8
It's easy. What is the IMP based on and why is it even called INFINITE MASS PUNCH? Does the word INFINITE ring a bell?It is clear from canon comics that the IMP is based off the special theory of relativity which states that the closer an object with mass gets to the speed of light then the more mass it gains and thus producing a higher kinetic energy and higher momentum (also explained in the comics).
Using Lorentz transformation
, where m is relativistic mass, m0 is rest mass, v is velocity, and c is the speed of light in a vacuum, we see that the closer v is to c then the closer the denominator gets to 0 from the positive side and thus making the relativistic mass astronomical. The limit of this function is infinity and hence the name INFINITE MASS PUNCH.
[B]m=m0/sqrt(1-v^2/c^2)With CIS off Zoom can plan, before the bell, on hitting Odin with a strike at 1x10^-88% away from the speed of light (more kinetic energy than several galaxies) and killing him outright. [/B]
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t551795.html
On topic, Do those calcs apply to anyone that can go lightspeed or above?
Originally posted by Silent Master
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t551795.htmlOn topic, Do those calcs apply to anyone that can go lightspeed or above?
Yes in anyone in the D.C. universe only and not in Marvel.
Originally posted by WodensonZoomOdin canblow up planets with a snap of his fingersincrease his speed to the point where he blitzes an amped Wally West and is standing still in time? That's the kind ofpowerspeed it takes tothreatenmatchOdin.Zoom.
I thought you'd catch up on what I was trying to say the first time.
I keep overestimating people, thinking they have the basic ability of understanding simple things.