Captain America vs. Marv

True. But he outclasses him everywhere else so that's a bit of a moot point.

Originally posted by KingD19
True. But he outclasses him everywhere else so that's a bit of a moot point.

Agreed. That's why Cap wins in all scenarios except the 2nd.

Based on these scenarios Cap wins every one. The closet probably being durability because Marv can take a bullet to the head but Cap can tank some big blunt force trauma.

i think cap is stronger.. think

Marv takes round 2 (the guy was laughing when shocked multiple times by the god damn electric chair and wouldn't sign the papers until his mother was threatened and he knew that the cops could get to her)

round 3, marv may or may not be stronger but he is durable as ****, seriously he doesn't get put down and cap loses

Originally posted by Newjak
Based on these scenarios Cap wins every one. The closet probably being durability because Marv can take a bullet to the head but Cap can tank some big blunt force trauma.

👆

With WS and AOU, there's no doubt Cap > Marv in strength and generally all around.

Originally posted by Genesis-Soldier
i think cap is stronger.. think

Marv takes round 2 (the guy was laughing when shocked multiple times by the god damn electric chair and wouldn't sign the papers until his mother was threatened and he knew that the cops could get to her)

round 3, marv may or may not be stronger but he is durable as ****, seriously he doesn't get put down and cap loses

How would Cap lose the fight? He is more agile, stronger, faster and far more skilled.

Originally posted by Genesis-Soldier
Marv takes round 2 (the guy was laughing when shocked multiple times by the god damn electric chair and wouldn't sign the papers until his mother was threatened and he knew that the cops could get to her)

Closets thing I can think of in regards to energy based attacks to Cap was in Avengers when he took a Chitauri rifle blast to the abdomen and while it phased him some, he got up and continued to kick ass.

Cap also took those Shield stun batons.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Cap punched through a submarine window. Casually tossed people in armor up in the air.

If you ask me, I think Marv is naturally stronger but Cap is more powerful. In a fighting context (or even arm wrestling), Cap will win.

Marv is more durable though. Best durability feat I have for Cap is him jumping out of that elevator and surviving the fall even if he did land on his shield.

Originally posted by NemeBro
He took a hit in the chest from a Chitauri blaster.

People forget that Marv's story happened within the span ot a night.

Kevin kills both

Originally posted by 0mega Spawn
Kevin kills both

They would both would heal from Kevin both are smart enough to win.

Cap is just plain faster than Kevin.

Cap tanked Thor's hammer with his shield. You're telling me you think Marv survives that in the same position? Unobtanium or no, the force still gets translated down into the body, and no way Marv rides that kind of punishment out. Cap is more durable all day, everyday.

Originally posted by Ascendancy
Cap tanked Thor's hammer with his shield. You're telling me you think Marv survives that in the same position? Unobtanium or no, the force still gets translated down into the body, and no way Marv rides that kind of punishment out. Cap is more durable all day, everyday.

Only the shield endured hits from Mjolnir. The Vibranium it's built with does wonders for negating and redistributing energy. You could give anybody that shield, and they'd tank the hit exactly the same. That's why in Age of Ultron, Thor smacked the shield with Mjolnir and made an energy shockwave.

I can see Marv tanking the chitauri blast. I can't see Cap tanking the same shots Marv went thru

Apparently Cap's metabolism is fast enough to include a healing factor. He got shot 3 times with an assault rifle in Winter Soldier, and no mention is made in Ultron. So he seemed to have just healed being shot.

Cap takes all 3 of these contests. Especially after WS, and even more after Civil War.

Cap will win the first and third handily. However the durability much depend on what kinda punishment they are to endure. It could imo go either way.