Thor VS Wolverine (With a Red Lantern Ring)

thor wasn't hurt...he was merely shocked/annoyed imo

Originally posted by Starscream M
but it looks like logan held back as well or thor would've died

Originally posted by Starscream M
thor wasn't hurt...he was merely shocked/annoyed imo

Oh ya, who do I think I'm talking to? It's brucey, you don't have to make sense.

logan is a dead duck.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
Logan thought he was fighting Sabretooth, his archenemy that he already killed once. He wasn't holding back at all.

Originally posted by Starscream M
his claws were not out regardless of his mental state...the scan shows that.

As for the thread I can see Logan getting wins, considering the ring turns someone into a herald level being. Thor would need to take him out fast and keep his distance otherwise he's dead meat. Who gets the majority? IDK or better said I don't really wanna side here.

Originally posted by Starscream M
his claws were not out regardless of his mental state...the scan shows that.

I already addressed this.

This thread's reached critical mass a long time ago.

Thor wins.

Originally posted by Damborgson
He does not.

Why would you doubt it though? The motion lines that came down when Wolverine attacked Thor should be evidence enough that those were not just his fists. Also Thor yelled out in pain when he was hit. Thor taken harder blows without complaining. Had it been a stab though then yeah he has every reason to be in pain. But even when Thor took a direct slash to the face by wolverine he only had small superficial cuts. So I dont think its out of the question that he could take being stabbed without Wolverine necessarily driving his claws right through him.

Can I swing a different way of looking at that scan at you guys? That noise Thor made looked more to me like a sound you make when you're extremely annoyed. Like more of a, "aaaargh! I'm done with this bulls#it!" than a scream of pain. If you look at those two panels he goes, "aaaargh! Enough!" which is basically the same thing.

We're still arguing whether it was a punch or claws?

Has Wolverine ever, EVER, hurt a character on Thor's level with fists? Or even attempted attacking a brick with his bare hands?

Ever?

Another delusional troll thread where Wolverine obviously stomps yet the mods leave open for some baffling reason? Yeah, that's a check.

I once met an insane man at a party who told me that rich Jews orchestrated the holocaust and framed Hitler, and that guy's believes are reasonable relative to the bullshit insanity that comes out of the mouths of Rage and cdtm. 😎

srank, rage is still arguing that wolverine had his claws out when he landed on thor's back....despite a panel later showing he obviously never had his claws out. had his claws been out, thor would've been mortally wounded as logan's claws would've punctured through thor's back into his lungs

Originally posted by srankmissingnin

Another delusional troll thread where Wolverine obviously stomps yet the mods leave open for some baffling reason? Yeah, that's a check.

[/B]

Originally posted by Starscream M
srank, rage is still arguing that wolverine had his claws out when he landed on thor's back....despite a panel later showing he obviously never had his claws out. had his claws been out, thor would've been mortally wounded as logan's claws would've punctured through thor's back into his lungs

The motion lines indicate a stabbing motion, and Logan tried a similar tactic to stab Thor from behind at the very beginning. It's pretty clear what happened imo but whatever.

I've told you many times why that reasoning is non conclusive. Also, Thor's Asgardian skin is almost certainly too thick for that to happen.

This won't go anywhere, I'm going to ask the guy directly somehow.

Originally posted by Starscream M
srank, rage is still arguing that wolverine had his claws out when he landed on thor's back....despite a panel later showing he obviously never had his claws out. had his claws been out, thor would've been mortally wounded as logan's claws would've punctured through thor's back into his lungs

Yes I'm quite aware that Rage is completely insane and fully content with ignoring the detials that have been explained to him ad nauseum for several years now.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Obviously. I mean Thor's already basically a slow a chump to Wolvy so adding the red lantern ring makes this spite. Amirite?

If the Red Lantern ring gave Wolverine no extra abilities other than a force field powered by his rage and flight, those abilities coupled with his healing factor would still be more then enough to net a win the vast majority of the time.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
The motion lines indicate a stabbing motion, and Logan tried a similar tactic to stab Thor from behind at the very beginning. It's pretty clear what happened imo but whatever.

I've told you many times why that reasoning is faulty and non conclusive. Also, Thor's Asgardian skin is almost certainly to thick for that to happen.

This won't go anywhere, I'm going to ask the guy directly somehow.

All the motion lines indicate is that his arms were swung in a downwards arc from above his head. He jumped with his hands raised, and then brought his arms down to grab a hold of his target. Simple.

He was holding his side and in pain from a glancing incision across his oblique. If Wolverine had stabbed him through the torso and punctured both his lungs with six foot long claws... Thor would have been instantly incapacitated. Use your head. Please.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
The motion lines indicate a stabbing motion, and Logan tried a similar tactic to stab Thor from behind at the very beginning. It's pretty clear what happened imo but whatever.

I've told you many times why that reasoning is non conclusive. Also, Thor's Asgardian skin is almost certainly too thick for that to happen.

This won't go anywhere, I'm going to ask the guy directly somehow.

answer me this, why in the very next panel as thor knocks logan off are his claws NOT out?

Originally posted by Starscream M
you're going against common sense to reach your conclusion

answer me this, why in the very next panel as thor knocks logan off are his claws NOT out?

No reason at all, I'd wager.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
All the motion lines indicate is that his arms were swung in a downwards arc from above his head. He jumped with his hands raised, and then brought his arms down to grab a hold of his target. Simple.

He was holding his side and in pain from a glancing incision across his oblique. If Wolverine had stabbed him through the torso and punctured both his lungs with six foot long claws... Thor would have been instantly incapacitated. Use your head. Please.

Originally posted by Starscream M
you're going against common sense to reach your conclusion

answer me this, why in the very next panel as thor knocks logan off are his claws NOT out?

We've done this dance before, I'm not going to waste time anytime. I'll attempt to contact the writer first thing tomorrow. That will settle things one way or another.

It's non conclusive Starscream because of what happened in the previous page:
http://s673.photobucket.com/albums/vv95/galanphotos/?action=view&current=wolvie_thor4.jpg

Logan's claws were out and then retracted when he was put in the air immediately. It's not the first comic to do portray it that way.