CISless Surfer vs HP Doomsday

Started by OneDumbG035 pages

Originally posted by biensalsa
Trying to hide the IQ again? Such long responses.

Gotta go, kind of late and I have better things to do. 😮‍💨

You already posted a completely arbitrary deflection feigning nonchalance that unfortunately preceded disturbing homoeroticism like ten posts ago.

Uninspired, to say the least. Praising your style back then proved to be an error in judgment. How unfortunate.

In the meantime, Superman flying Doomsday around at high traveling speeds is not a combat superspeed feat for Doomsday just because onlookers cannot keep up with how fast Superman's flying around. That's just stucking fupid.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
You already posted a completely arbitrary deflection feigning nonchalance that unfortunately preceded disturbing homoeroticism like ten posts ago.

Uninspired, to say the least. Praising your style back then proved to be an error in judgment. How unfortunate.

In the meantime, Superman flying Doomsday around at high traveling speeds is not a combat superspeed feat for Doomsday just because onlookers cannot keep up with how fast Superman's flying around. That's just stucking fupid.

I've already stated this to you, but since you've chosen to ignore it, I'll say it again. On the panel that you linked is where I pulled my quote from. It's said in present tense. Superman does indeed fly at Doomsday and hit him, but the fighting is also still taking place there.

If it was a blur that was just flying by, it would have been a nanosecond. Before the guy even finished saying "I" they would have been gone. The fight continued and at a speed that appeared as a blur.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
This sh1t is getting old. The Supermandoppler Effect is even stupider than Wolverithmetics.

I'm afraid I'll be dumber for learning it, and regret asking, but I MUST know. What is this "Wolverithmetics" you type of?

Odg = butthurt? mmm

Originally posted by -Pr-
Odg = butthurt? mmm

What's new?

Originally posted by quanchi112
When it was destroyed the threat of Doomsday was over.

The ring responded immediately to him and he can't do this without the ring anyway. Can Doomsday fly without the ring ?


Nope.

So, what does Doomsday using the Power Ring to fly have to do with my request for proof on the Guardian couldn't overcome the Ring it's self? Of course, you failed to answer my question if you're saying tear gas>nukes in another thread, so I shouldn't be surprised.

Originally posted by quanchi112
http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/?action=view&current=DA1_41.jpg
I am saying the Guardian wanted to destroy the ring and he was a major threat because of the ring and his abilities paired together. That's an amp.
When the ring was destroyed he lost. Look at him ko'd and no longer a threat to the Guardian. He is knocked out which is a forum loss. Sorry but the whole reason he was an uber threat was his powerset coupled with the ring.

So what does this have to do with my question? Are you trying to argue that the Power Ring was still protecting him when it was destroyed? Are you saying he was protected when DD got hit with the force that ripped a hole in space?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Imperiex Prime didn't use a pure power blast to kill him. Imperiex prime used a specific attack I would venture to guess the power cosmic could replicate. I think the Radiant's specific attack failed but don't see Doomsday as immune to all energy blasts.

Where was it stated Imperiex Prime used a "specific attack?" We just see him blasted with energy, and a smoldering skeleton. Unless I'm not remembering some important dialogue or narration stating that Imperiex Prime used a SPECIFIC attack? And even if he did, what proof do you have Surfer could replicate it? For one, just because CIS is turned-off doesn't mean that Surfer would suddenly know a specific attack to kill Doomsday. But even if he knew it and could replicate it, what makes you think he'd have enough power to do it at the level Imperiex Prime did?

As for the Radiant's "specific attack," here's a showing from the fight with the original Radiant.

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/?action=view&current=hacsahunter-prey-02-30.jpg

I think calling that a "specific attack" would be stretching it a bit, but it's unclear if attacking him with energy in that manner is what actually killed him. When the second Radiant does that, he doesn't show surprise Doomsday is still standing. He says this--

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/?action=view&current=hacsahunter-prey-03-09.jpg

"I remember how you were beaten the first time! FULL INTENSITY ENERGY BLAST!"

Originally posted by quanchi112
The scan makes it clear they can't stay there or they will die. Superman isn't more powerful than that but in the end this kills DD. The writer made it clear physical force in Superman's all out 95 percent mode would be enough for the kill. That's the writer so you acting like he's superior to something the writer disagrees with is delusional thinking. He never contradicted his own story you've also been corrected on the notion that DD did indeed die. You show a lack of comprehending the comic as it made it painfully clear to begin with.

No, I wasn't corrected, I was misunderstood. I was referring to what we see. Them not surviving it indefinitely is a pointless argument because there was nothing left TO survive from. Doomsday was still alive when around it's gravitational force. So, answer my question. Did the writer's opinion contradict his story, or is Superman more powerful than this?

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/?action=view&current=Hunter-Prey-03-42.jpg

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/?action=view&current=Hunter-Prey-03-43.jpg

Or will you continue to nitpick so you don't answer the question?

Originally posted by quanchi112
A pure power attack is different than say the power cosmic leeching off energy or something to that effect. Surfer isn't close to Imperiex Prime in power but his attack used was never just pure power.

Again, where's it stated Imperiex Prime didn't use a pure blast of power? Second Radiant said Doomsday was originally killed with a "full intensity blast" so it was just a pure blast. As far as I remember, Imperiex Prime did the same thing, just to a greater level. And again, even if you can prove that Imperiex Prime did some effect, it's still an irrelevant argument as you admit Surfer isn't near his level, so you'd have to provide evidence that even if Surfer can produce an equivalent effect, that it'd be powerful enough to work.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor is more powerful than Doomsday.

Not physically. So this is irrelevant. Or do you think Thor is stronger than Doomsday?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Hulk is the poster child of bricks so doing well against him should be enough especially since his strength is dynamic.

Surfer almost always does well against Hulk. Hulk's the ONLY brick I've seen him consistently do well against. Or did you miss that point?

Originally posted by quanchi112
DD has never shown the ability to use teleportation so you can't just give him never before seen abilities just because you say so. It isn't an option is what I am saying.

🙄

You continue to miss the point. But to say Doomsday couldn't develop teleportation is stupid. This creature became immune to time being frozen around him. He didn't show that ability either before he had to. And if you try to argue the teleportational tube during DOOMSDAY WARS, doesn't work. Doomsday was never fully solidified to adapt. Of course I wasn't arguing that Doomsday WILL develop teleportation to deal with Surfer BFRing him in the first place, was merely pointing-out that's the only way I think Doomsday could win a majority here under the scenario given, but then you must say I'm wrong and say it isn't an option that a creature who's whole point is to adapt to new threats in the first place and has adapted to become immune to time freezing around him can't develop teleportation.

Your best bet would be to just drop the teleportation thing. I never argued this WILL happen, but you're utterly wrong to say it isn't a possibility.

Read what I posted above. I'm beginning to think you're losing perspective on this. Being tackled in a straight line by a flyer flying at superspeeds isn't proof that the "tacklee" is fighting at superspeeds. I'd rather not argue this point further.

Irony is ironic. Hulk can achieve escape velocity with his leaps. He's also jumped hundreds of miles in the space of seconds. But you're right. Traveling speed feats are pretty solid, but he's not fighting. Same with Doomsday in that scene. I could explain to you further why I believe Darkseid's and Lobo's superspeed feats are rather puerile. And I think if I walked you through my reasoning, you'd almost assuredly agree. And if that sounds like an invitation or even a challenge, you wouldn't be wrong. But I'm afraid it'd go too off-topic as we're speaking of Doomsday's superspeed (or lack thereof).

Doomsday never appeared as a blur on-panel to my recollection. Nobody referred to him as a blur either (aside from when he was tackled at superspeeds by a flying Superman). I don't disagree he's got speed that complements his power enough such that it makes it extraordinarily hard for superspeedsters to fight him. But that's more a testament to his sheer power and the deadly combination that sheer power presents when coupled with surprising speed (not superspeedster speed).

And the exact same thing could be said of the Hulk. And it has. On-panel. Moreover, it's been reinforced by measurable speed feats. Not just character statements. [/B]

i agree that scan in no way supports dd's speed. as far as taking this off-thread open a new one and we can continue in whatever direction you'd like. i'd open one but i'm not completely clear what you're thinking about. we could hulk' speed vs dd's or open a thread in the discussion forum or just a vs thread comparing the speeds of all of the people involved--thor, hulk, lobo and dd. that might be fun and interesting.

i'm good with whatever.

Originally posted by carver9
Galan...he was weakened...very weak and would have died in a panel if he faced Doomsday without those amps. It's pretty obvious it took him back to his previous power level and from his appearance durability wise, how easily Doomsday was able to hurt him, its debatable if it even took him back to his original power levels if you base it off of their previous and battles after that.

Tell me Carver, if Superman was weakened at the time, why is it he stated he could travel through space?

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/Superman%20speed/?action=view&current=doomsdayhunterprey1pg42.jpg

"I can travel through space these days. All I need is a map or a star chart--"

While it doesn't specify just HOW fast he can fly, he clearly would have to travel faster than light to be able to travel to other stars. And yes, this is before he ever gets the Mother Box. By the way, this was also before your scan of him stating, "I can't go faster than light" when Wally lends him speed, and isn't the only example from before your scan that contradicts it.

Are you thinking of during RETURN OF SUPERMAN when he was weakened? Well, he wasn't "near human." He was far weaker than previously, but unless you're saying Byrne-era Superman's not much more than 10 times stronger than a normal human(as RETURN OF SUPERMAN had Superman specify he was at about 1/10th of his normal strength level) you're wrong. And oh yeah, the end of that storyline also had him powered-up from the Kryptonite-X. SUPERMAN: THE MAN OF STEEL #30 was all about showing Superman's grown more powerful.

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/VS%20Lobo/MOS%2030/?action=view&current=supesmos-30-09.jpg

Lobo: "That haymaker had more KICK than I remember!! You been WORKIN' OUT, right?"

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/VS%20Lobo/MOS%2030/?action=view&current=supesmos-30-12.jpg

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/VS%20Lobo/MOS%2030/?action=view&current=supesmos-30-13.jpg

"My knuckles don't even sting! My powers ARE increasing!"

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/VS%20Lobo/MOS%2030/?action=view&current=supesmos-30-14.jpg

"Can't BREATHE. But somehow...I'm FINE!!" "I'm stronger now...and a single BREATH must have so completely OXYGENATED my blood......that I simply don't need to BREATHE anymore!"

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/VS%20Lobo/MOS%2030/?action=view&current=supesmos-30-16.jpg

"WHOA! that ship is the SIZE of a small MOON. I should have barely been able to break the INERTIA to push it away......much less THROW it!! And no problems CATCHING UP to it either!"

So, even before getting the Mother Box, Superman was more powerful than the first time he fought Doomsday. Yet, Superman was still physically less powerful.

Originally posted by carver9
Im not agreeing with One Dumb or the people that's going against him. I'm in a completely different topic. I do agree with One thing though...Doomsday has never done anything on panel that Hulk haven't replicated. No denying this.

So Carver, when did Hulk adapt to chronol stasis?

Originally posted by Delta1938
So, what does Doomsday using the Power Ring to fly have to do with my request for proof on the Guardian couldn't overcome the Ring it's self? Of course, you failed to answer my question if you're saying tear gas>nukes in another thread, so I shouldn't be surprised.
You using 40 year old scans to pretend tear gas is still as relevant today as it was back then isn't a case. My post always had to do with Doomsday being a threat due to his powers coupled with the ring. You want to ignore that, entirely. DD was still ko'd. That's a forum loss so who cares if he wasn't killed. DOS Superman killed him after this minus the ring. 🙂


So what does this have to do with my question? Are you trying to argue that the Power Ring was still protecting him when it was destroyed? Are you saying he was protected when DD got hit with the force that ripped a hole in space?[/B]
No, when the ring was destroyed he was ko'd aka he lost. Thor can easily rip a hole in space/time so why is this impressive to you ? DOS Superman killed DD with force.


Where was it stated Imperiex Prime used a "specific attack?" We just see him blasted with energy, and a smoldering skeleton. Unless I'm not remembering some important dialogue or narration stating that Imperiex Prime used a SPECIFIC attack? And even if he did, what proof do you have Surfer could replicate it? For one, just because CIS is turned-off doesn't mean that Surfer would suddenly know a specific attack to kill Doomsday. But even if he knew it and could replicate it, what makes you think he'd have enough power to do it at the level Imperiex Prime did?[/B]
I love how you honestly think it was just a pure force attack. His bacteria was expunged.

You already said the Surfer wins so it's pointless to try and convince you. You already agree with me about the outcome.


As for the Radiant's "specific attack," here's a showing from the fight with the original Radiant.

I think calling that a "specific attack" would be stretching it a bit, but it's unclear if attacking him with energy in that manner is what actually killed him. When the second Radiant does that, he doesn't show surprise Doomsday is still standing. He says this--

"I remember how you were beaten the first time! FULL INTENSITY ENERGY BLAST!"[/B]

They had a week long battle in which he didn't adapt to him. That level of force needed to be surpassed to destroy him in hp and since it wasn't it failed. That's all. It was just a pure force attack.


No, I wasn't corrected, I was misunderstood. I was referring to what we see. Them not surviving it indefinitely is a pointless argument because there was nothing left TO survive from. Doomsday was still alive when around it's gravitational force. So, answer my question. Did the writer's opinion contradict his story, or is Superman more powerful than this?[/B]
You misunderstood what the dialogue meant. The dialogue made it clear spending too much time there would kill them all hence Superman and Waverider leaving. The writer didn't contradict anything. You not comprehending basic english isn't my problem. You trying to twist around simple sentences isn't my problem.

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/?action=view&current=Hunter-Prey-03-42.jpg

http://s1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/?action=view&current=Hunter-Prey-03-43.jpg

Or will you continue to nitpick so you don't answer the question?[/B]

Waverider says he can stave off the effects for a few seconds and they make it clear this is DD's end.


Again, where's it stated Imperiex Prime didn't use a pure blast of power? Second Radiant said Doomsday was originally killed with a "full intensity blast" so it was just a pure blast. As far as I remember, Imperiex Prime did the same thing, just to a greater level. And again, even if you can prove that Imperiex Prime did some effect, it's still an irrelevant argument as you admit Surfer isn't near his level, so you'd have to provide evidence that even if Surfer can produce an equivalent effect, that it'd be powerful enough to work.[/B]
In the scan I posted above when he killed DD. Yes, DD wasn't kiled by a specific attack he just wasn't strong enough to survive something that destroyed 1/5 of a planet. Surfer can destroy entire planets while holding back. 😂 Expunging bacteria isn't a difficult attack for the power cosmic. Sorry.


Not physically. So this is irrelevant. Or do you think Thor is stronger than Doomsday?[/B]
Radiant wasn't stronger than DD. Thor's power greatly exceeds radiant's. I also never said Surfer was stronger but he is more powerful just like Thor. Teehee.


Surfer almost always does well against Hulk. Hulk's the ONLY brick I've seen him consistently do well against. Or did you miss that point?[/B]
Name a brick he does badly against since Hulk is the premiere brick in all of comicdom.

You continue to miss the point. But to say Doomsday couldn't develop teleportation is stupid. This creature became immune to time being frozen around him. He didn't show that ability either before he had to. And if you try to argue the teleportational tube during DOOMSDAY WARS, doesn't work. Doomsday was never fully solidified to adapt. Of course I wasn't arguing that Doomsday WILL develop teleportation to deal with Surfer BFRing him in the first place, was merely pointing-out that's the only way I think Doomsday could win a majority here under the scenario given, but then you must say I'm wrong and say it isn't an option that a creature who's whole point is to adapt to new threats in the first place and has adapted to become immune to time freezing around him can't develop teleportation.

Your best bet would be to just drop the teleportation thing. I never argued this WILL happen, but you're utterly wrong to say it isn't a possibility. [/B]

If you weren't arguing that then you concede. I accept.

Originally posted by quanchi112
he just wasn't strong enough to survive something that destroyed 1/5 of a planet.
That battle happened hundreds of thousands of years BEFORE the events of Death of Superman. Doomsday's abilities grew by leaps and bounds over that time. Heck during H/P, DD was unscathed by a force equal to a million nuclear blasts. If a million nuclear weapons were to be detonated on earth, I can assure you that FAR more than 1/5 of it would be laid waste to.

Just saying that it's faulty to use a low showing against Doomsday, when he was at his WEAKEST levels.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I love how you honestly think it was just a pure force attack. His bacteria was expunged.

You already said the Surfer wins so it's pointless to try and convince you. You already agree with me about the outcome.
They had a week long battle in which he didn't adapt to him. That level of force needed to be surpassed to destroy him in hp and since it wasn't it failed. That's all. It was just a pure force attack.

Hold up.

I haven't read this thread, and it's not one I care to get involved in. But I did catch this post, and I'm not sure what you're saying here.

What exactly do you think that panel shows Imperiex doing to DD?

Originally posted by Galan007
That battle happened hundreds of thousands of years BEFORE the events of Death of Superman. Doomsday's abilities grew by leaps and bounds over that time. Heck during H/P, DD was unscathed by a force equal to a million nuclear blasts. If a million nuclear weapons were to be detonated on earth, I can assure you that FAR more than 1/5 of it would be laid waste to.

Just saying.

Yes, I know that took place a while back but in dos Superman bested him with power. The writer of the arc still maintains Superman had the power to best him. I maintain the Surfer has the power to best him. Just because radiant doesn't and the fact in a week long battle he still didn't adapt to radiant's attacks to avoid death.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes, I know that took place a while back but in dos Superman bested him with power.
Yet an AMPED Superman was unable to so much as stagger H/P Doomsday 'with power'. So your point there is moot.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Just because radiant doesn't and the fact in a week long battle he still didn't adapt to radiant's attacks to avoid death.
That, again, was HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF YEARS AGO. We saw H/P Doomsday evolve beyond Waverider's chronal energies VERY rapidly--in fact, he evolved beyond them over the span of a few pages. Clearly his ability to evolve beyond energies sped up astronomically over the years--heck, he was even evolving physical traits on the fly, as well.

Like I said, you cannot use showings against H/P Doomsday that occurred when he was at his WEAKEST levels. That's like using showings from Action Comics #1 to try and prove why Superman from Action Comics #800 was weaksauce. Simply does not work.

Originally posted by Galan007
Yet an AMPED Superman was unable to so much as stagger H/P Doomsday 'with power'. So your point there is moot.
That Superman wasn't all out he was overcoming his own fear of DD in the arc. The arc made it clear this was far from Superman's best unless of course you think this was his best. Do you ?

That, again, was HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF YEARS AGO. We saw H/P Doomsday evolve beyond Waverider's chronal energies VERY rapidly--in fact, he evolved beyond them over the span of a few pages. Clearly his ability to evolve beyond energies sped up astronomically over the years--heck, he was even evolving physical traits on the fly, as well.[/B]
You are missing the point Dd didn't adapt past all energy attacks he just became stronger than that specific force blast.

Like I said, you cannot use showings against H/P Doomsday that occurred when he was at his WEAKEST levels. That's like using showings from Action Comics #1 to try and prove why Superman from Action Comics #800 was weaksauce. Simply does not work. [/B]
I am using an example brought up by someone else in this thread. The feat occurred in hp. I can also compare a gl DD to a dos Doomsday. Try and keep up.

Originally posted by Cogito
Hold up.

I haven't read this thread, and it's not one I care to get involved in. But I did catch this post, and I'm not sure what you're saying here.

What exactly do you think that panel shows Imperiex doing to DD?

Question bump

Originally posted by quanchi112
That Superman wasn't all out he was overcoming his own fear of DD in the arc. The arc made it clear this was far from Superman's best unless of course you think this was his best. Do you ?
Was Superman scared? Yes. However, he made multiple comments that he was attacking DD with 'everything he had'. Unfortunately, everything he had+Mother Box tech was nowhere near enough. That's all I'm saying.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You are missing the point Dd didn't adapt past all energy attacks he just became stronger than that specific force blast.
He evolved beyond every attack used against him. On the fly.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am using an example brought up by someone else in this thread. The feat occurred in hp. I can also compare a gl DD to a dos Doomsday. Try and keep up.
The story of the original Radiant killing DD was told in the pages of H/P, however, the actual event took place HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF YEARS AGO:

Therefore, it is outright stupid to try and use it as a low feat for H/P Doomsday. Perhaps you should take your own advice and try to keep up?

Originally posted by Galan007
Was Superman scared? Yes. However, he made multiple comments that he was attacking DD with 'everything he had'. Unfortunately, everything he had+Mother Box tech was nowhere near enough. That's all I'm saying.
All I am saying is the writer of the arc said he wasn't all out. The amp was rather pathetic imo. He still had the moral restraint which sometimes cripples him in comics.

He evolved beyond every attack used against him. On the fly.

The story of the original Radiant killing DD was told in the pages of H/P, however, the actual event took place HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF YEARS AGO:

Therefore, it is outright stupid to try and use it as a low feat for H/P Doomsday. Perhaps you should take your own advice and try to keep up? [/B]

When someone is citing doomsday annual feats which precede hp I am within my right to compare that DD to Dos DD. I didn't just bring up these things out of the blue. You don't pay attention to the argument going back and forth and then jump in here spouting nonsense.

My argument is in response to another posters who is using pre dos showings so yes my counter is valid TO HIS argument.

Originally posted by quanchi112
All I am saying is the writer of the arc said he wasn't all out. The amp was rather pathetic imo. He still had the moral restraint which sometimes cripples him in comics.
Superman was scared--he was fighting the creature that killed him, after all... But again: he outright stated, multiple times, that he was striking DD with 'everything he had'. He also tried to fight smarter then he did in their first battle--using ranged HV attacks and New God/Mother Box weaponry. Despite all that, he barely managed to knock DD down.

Originally posted by quanchi112
When someone is citing doomsday annual feats which precede hp I am within my right to compare that DD to Dos DD. I didn't just bring up these things out of the blue. You don't pay attention to the argument going back and forth and then jump in here spouting nonsense.

My argument is in response to another posters who is using pre dos showings so yes my counter is valid TO HIS argument.

😂 So mad.

Upon reading your retort it certainly seemed as though you were picking a 'low' feat DD acquired some 200,000 years before the events of DoS, and trying to use said feat against a FAR more powerful version of Doomsday... Which is idiotic.

If you weren't trying to do that, then great! 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
Superman was scared--he was fighting the creature that killed him, after all. But again: Supes said, multiple times, that he was striking DD with 'everything he had'. He also tried to fight smarter then he did in their first battle--using ranged HV attacks and New God/Mother Box weaponry. Despite all that, he barely managed to knock DD down.

😂 So mad.

I don't think he was without his moral constraints. You do so let's just agree to disagree because neither is budging. I've seen Superman do better in DD wars but whatevs.

Upon reading your retort it certainly seemed as though you were picking a 'low' feat DD acquired some 200,000 years before the events of DoS, and trying to use said feat against a FAR more powerful version of Doomsday... Which is idiotic.

If you weren't trying to do that, then great! 👆 [/B]

Wen someone is citing the doomsday annual as proof of how uber he can while casually dismissing the gl ring amp he had it's within my right to counter with a dos example which is relevant to that particular DD. That isn't relevant to HP DD since he was beyond the dos DD. My argument is tailored to him alone I wouldn't use this for a HP DD thread in general.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I've seen Superman do better in DD wars but whatevs.
I assume you're referring to their fight toward the end? Heh, Superman still failed to so much as knock Doomsday down, and was owned with a single punch. Prior to that, DD gave Supes [arguably] the worst non-lethal beating of his career.

Originally posted by quanchi112
My argument is tailored to him alone I wouldn't use this for a HP DD thread in general.
Good man. 👆

For a second, I was worried you were stupid.