Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Should i call the Phoenix Force gods power cos in Secret Avengers the firebird avatar is referred to as a [B]seraph?(Literally means "burning ones" gods winged fiery angels who bring about Gods Judgement on Earth with a cleansing fire)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seraph
NO[/B]
Do I even need to try and debate this for you to see the error behind comparing "Literally means "burning ones" gods winged fiery angels who bring about Gods Judgement on Earth with a cleansing fire" and God's power?
Hell, calling it a Seraph actually goes against what you're trying to say... simply calling her an angel doesn't mean she's utilizing God's power or even close.
But let's just go a little farther here...
Not only have you failed to reproduce the seraph scan, but you're connecting both sets (even if one was produced) very loosely through a What-If where one set doesn't state that it's a seraph at all. It just does the role (and role is not the same power) like 30 years earlier...
And since I figure you're going to make something of the role/power thing, allow me to explain.
Power and Role aren't equal parts. You taking the role of say God doesn't mean you have the power. An example being the Skyfathers taking the roles of "God". Another example would be Galactus being stated to have a greater role than Eternity, yet Galactus' power isn't as great.
And for the seraph part, even a skyfather could clense the Earth in a fiery pit of death, yet that wouldn't raise it's power level, for an example of role vs power... like Odin has...
All of your scans taken in the way you want them would mean she is connected to God. And that wouldn't be so bad, since even Wolverine is connected to God. Even Ghost Rider is I believe "God's Wrath". However, what you failed to do was prove in any way any of these claims. You just took a throwaway line in each case and ran it to the ****ing ground.
And all of your scans taken literally do not beat "God's Power"... especially since the best statement means that God's power has taken mortal form...
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
However as you can see, the Phoenix Force in continuity, on multiple occasions has faaaar more reason to be likened to Gods power than the HOTI.
No she hasn't. She never had a whole mini explaining that her power is God's power. She never had an entire universe rebel against her because she is unworthy of God's power. She never had abstracts talk to her about her having God's power. She never easily defeated the Living Tribunal. Etc.
Also, her being likened to God's power was throwaway lines that in some cases were overwritten in the same page, and her role was likened to God's power, not her power.
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Not at all. LT as stated is a conceptual being that utilizes M bodies. Theres one LT entity, however there are many LT m-bodies that he can employ.The LT Mbody has shown its not infallible.
Its attack has been thwarted by Korvac.
Its power has been re-directed at it by Reed Richards destroying it.
Its Mbody was absorbed by Thanos.
Beating an Mbody or representation is not the same as tackling the entity in its entirety. Beings like LT and the Phoenix are multiversal as stated on panel, a universal manifestation of them does not represent all that they are. They deal with issues on a multiversal scale.
Well, that's just one giant ass assumption.
Even if he was an M-Body, which you have absolutely no proof to say he was, he doesn't tap into the universes' power.
The "M-Body" attack wasn't thwarted by Korvac. When all you do is blow up a sun, and accomplish this... well it's hard to get thwarted. It's like saying Nova thwarted Galactus' attack because he destroyed the Annihilation Wave but failed to destroy him.
Why LT figured a sun going nova could defeat Korvac is beyond me... shoddy writing.
It displaced them. Scan saying it destroyed them?
Has LT ever actually been stated to have used M-Bodies?
Not only that, but why would anyone use M-Bodies in this scenario? LT got every being he could get to fight Thanos. He clearly didn't go "Well gee, maybe my M-Body and every single being in the universe could take him". This was the most drastic length LT has ever went... yet he's going to use an M-Body? Give me a break.
The most powerful being to really exist that LT thinks has God's power and he sends an M-Body against him? Laughable.
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Irrelevant when you wield considerably greater powers than all that is contained within the universe. The IG by current continuity taps into the energies of the Big Bang and it absolutely stomped all of the abstracts fighting back merely cos it had greater access to said power. White Phoenix taps into those same energies but again on a greater scale as the Phoenix host and she manipulated the whole universe in her palm at an atomic level, rendering little fisticuffs within the little universe irrelevant. 😬
The IG got retconned to using that power. When it actually beat abstracts it used to be the one being of reality. It got retconned what? Three times. Why would we assume it's power stayed the same?
The current IG is not beating Abstracts. Hell, Infinity War IG got blasted to shit by Eternity/Infinity (mind you it was missing one gem).
And even right after IG, Eternity actually stated he was using an M-body... so there's that.
The only reason you think fisticuffs are irrelevant is because Phoenix has nowhere near the level of battle feats as other beings. Real talk.
And yes, battle feats are power showings, especially when you beat a bunch of abstracts and LT.
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Given the considerably greater energy output it would take to manipulate an entire universe at the atomic level as opposed to fighting fragments of said universe then it stands to reason that if it was her desire the WP could completely stomp the abstracts. No single abstract wields the entire universes power, they all have it divided between them. She showed exponentially greater power than any of them individually or as a whole.We'll never know if Thanos could have done the same thing. However given he never displayed anything as high level or as intricate as that, he gets ranked below. Simple.
That makes no sense. Warping the universes energy just sitting there is not better than beating almost every abstract in existence. Manipulating a universe > beating LT and recreating him (along with a universe)? Not a chance.
Actually, post a scan that says the abstracts split power between them. And then tie that into Phoenix wielding all of that. I mean, this is the whole crux of your argument after all. It'd be interesting for you to prove it (this isn't me going against it btw, I just want you to prove this and tie Phoenix above it).
We do, because he did it. The guy fixed a universal flaw that no other being could detect (along with recreating all the beings he kills). Phoenix made it so that Scott and Emma were together...
Now you tell me what's more intricate... well, not you, but someone.
Originally posted by GalacticStorm
He warped a place of residence, not the entity itself. Jamie Braddock was later pitted against the First Fallen said to be the Phoenixes counterpart and got stomped. I'd place Jamie Braddock below the abstracts.
He warped the place with little Phoenix's inside it. And as you stated earlier, the "Crown" is... oh how did you put this...
"Should i call the Phoenix Forces power Gods power because the White Hot Room is called "the Crown" and the Phoenix host is connected to its power through the crown?
The Crown is represented by white. (White Hot Room/White Phoenix Of The Crown) It is the realm of superconsciousness and the closest you can get to the Divine. The Crown is also represented on the body as the head and through this the consciousness meets the Divine and the Divine bends the consciousness to its will:"
Good old picking and choosing. It was certainly impressive earlier in your post, yet now it's not? Oh you
Oh, Jamie Braddock got stomped by the First Fallen? Because the First Fallen hasn't been seen since, and Jamie Braddock... well, let's just say he was very much alive. So...
But I agree with him being below the abstracts. Just wanted to bring that up since it pertains to Phoenix.
---
I know I did nothing to convince you (you and MM like to argue afterall), and I haven't the time to infinite debate you (since this post took long enough), so I acknowledge you're likely going to respond with a bevy of posts. However, I just wanted to get that out since it was bugging me, and figure it should convince anyone else, besides you.
There's also the fact that I'm debating HOTU having better feats than Phoenix... which is so ****ing redundant it's ridiculous.