Thor vs Superman-HTH

Started by Newjak20 pages

Originally posted by Silent Master
Why are the people who complained that I posted armed feats posting feats where Superman was armed?
I'm not, you said he blocked bullets with a trash can lid. The scan I saw showed no such thing, but abh said he posted the wrong scan.

Originally posted by Deadline
Ok you did see these posts right?

Would you then exclude alot of Cap h2h feats because he uses his shield alot, or alot of DD feats because he uses his billyclub?

Why would I do that? As long as they show h2h skill, on top of their proficiency with the weapon of choice, there's no problem.

Now show me Thor displaying hand to hand skill superior to Superman, besides his skill with weapons.

Originally posted by Deadline
Well superspeed is off and Superman does not have a big, durability, strength and stamina advantage. Obvoulsy you're going to tell me he does.
The difference is that I've read comics of both, while you were furiously rubbing your nipples to Punisher blowing up Wolverine's balls.

Originally posted by Deadline
Of course he may have some feats that are better than Thors, but alot of Thors feats are better in general. I'm pretty sure that Falcon has some fighting feats better than Cap, doesn't mean hes better.
What in the world are you talking about, drooly?

Originally posted by Deadline
Still waiting for proof.
I'm still waiting for Thor feats that are worth countering, and not a scan dihareea copy/pasted from some respect thread.

Originally posted by Newjak
I'm not, you said he blocked bullets with a trash can lid. The scan I saw showed no such thing, but abh said he posted the wrong scan.

I know, the guy you quoted posted a "bullet blocking" feat that required the use of a weapon. I didn't mean to accuse you of doing it.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Why are the people who complained that I posted armed feats posting feats where Superman was armed?

Except...Superman is not armed in the first few panels of that scan, correct?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Except...Superman is not armed in the first few panels of that scan, correct?

The feat was post as an example of "bullet blocking" can you point out where he does that without the use of a weapon?

Originally posted by Newjak
Wasn't that Superman with WW and Batman helping or combined with him or something like that?

What are you talking about. None of the bullets hit the trash can...He ran sideways covering his head until he threw it at the guy.

He did not block or deflect any bullets in that scan 😐


No, their personalities were merging but the fighting skills were all of superman's. Superman's martial art skills

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v655/pr1983/18-2.jpg

Originally posted by Newjak
Then post the right one man 😛

I'm finding it in my mess of an account.

Always loved these.

ha-som

Originally posted by Silent Master
The feat was post as an example of "bullet blocking" can you point out where he does that without the use of a weapon?

Well I can't...because Abhi admitted he posted the wrong scan. So whatever the label was (Superman takes a dump on the Watchtower toilet, Superman thrashes Black Lightning at Dance Dance Revoultion), it doesn't matter.

What DOES matter, is Superman, whilst depowered, leaping rather athletically over some guys and owning them. Then doing a Steve Rogers on them.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Always loved these.

ha-som


That doesn't count. Superman doesn't have teh skillz of mantis to use nerve strikes even though he has done it to an atlantean, human, maxima, ultraman, mongul, kryptonian etc.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Well I can't...because Abhi admitted he posted the wrong scan. So whatever the label was (Superman takes a dump on the Watchtower toilet, Superman thrashes Black Lightning at Dance Dance Revoultion), it doesn't matter.

What DOES matter, is Superman, whilst depowered, leaping rather athletically over some guys and owning them. Then doing a Steve Rogers on them.

Kind of like the scans of Thor being depowered and keeping up with Cap in a running battle that included things like jumping up to a second story fire escape?

Originally posted by Philosophía
Why would I do that? As long as they show h2h skill, on top of their proficiency with the weapon of choice, there's no problem.

They have already posted those.

Originally posted by Philosophía

Now show me Thor displaying hand to hand skill superior to Superman, besides his skill with weapons.

Haven't they done this already? The problem is that you have Superman using pressure points, but I've only seen him using it on one martial arts expert. Batman was possesed so that doesn't really count. Ultraman is not a martial arts expert. What about the load of Thor feats where he is depowered? I don't know but for some strange reason beating a grizzly bear is pretty impressive, got to say it's more impressive than using pressure points against a guy who isn't or is a martial arts (depends on how good I guess) expert. No just because he didn't use a flykick doesn't mean it wasn't martial arts.

As already stated some of Supermans feats will be better but Thor has alot more.

Originally posted by Philosophía

The difference is that I've read comics of both, while you were furiously rubbing your nipples to Punisher blowing up Wolverine's balls.

So have I. I've read tons of Thor comics and with him in it. I've read alot of Superman comics but nowhere near as you, it's still enough.

FYI information I've got at least several years worth of comic reading on all major marvel titles and some obscure ones.

Originally posted by Philosophía

What in the world are you talking about, drooly?

I'm still waiting for Thor feats that are worth countering, and not a scan dihareea copy/pasted from some respect thread.

Don't be silly want to turn this into a slanging match i'll just ignore you

Originally posted by Silent Master
Kind of like the scans of Thor being depowered and keeping up with Cap in a running battle that included things like jumping up to a second story fire escape?

Hey, check back to my posts (tip: they have my account name). I said they were impressive.

But to answer your question, yes, they are kinda like that. Except of course, Superman's scan actually had him fighting in HtH combat. Like the OP said.

Of course, if its a high jump feat war you want.....

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Hey, check back to my posts (tip: they have my account name). I said they were impressive.

But to answer your question, yes, they are kinda like that. Except of course, Superman's scan actually had him fighting in HtH combat. Like the OP said.

Of course, if its a high jump feat war you want.....


😂

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Hey, check back to my posts (tip: they have my account name). I said they were impressive.

But to answer your question, yes, they are kinda like that. Except of course, Superman's scan actually had him fighting in HtH combat. Like the OP said.

Of course, if its a high jump feat war you want.....

Except when he used the trash can lid as both a shield and weapon. BTW, Thor's running battle also had him using agility, kicks and punches so it had him using HTH.

Originally posted by Deadline
They have already posted those.
They've flooded with copy/pasted scans from a respect thread. It's not my job to select the ones that prove their argument, from the ones where he swings swords or throws his hammer accurately.

I could post 2 pages of random Superman feats, and have you select the ones that are relevant, drooly.

Originally posted by Deadline
Haven't they done this already? The problem is that you have Superman using pressure points, but I've only seen him using it on one martial arts expert. Batman was possesed so that doesn't really count. Ultraman is not a martial arts expert. What about the load of Thor feats where he is depowered?
That's one more martial artist than Thor has, who is not is not a martial arts expert in the first place, so how is this relevant, drooly?

Superman has beaten a highly skilled martial artist in an inferior body, and is capable of paralyzing or knocking out people with a single finger touch.

Thor by comparison is non-existent.

Originally posted by Deadline
FYI information I've got at least several years worth of comic reading on all major marvel titles and some obscure ones.
Man, tons of congrats, drooly.

Originally posted by Deadline
Don't be silly want to turn this into a slanging match i'll just ignore you
It would be better if you cried, but kept typing through it, like a manly little b itch.

Look you're just dodging points.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Thor is not a martial arts expert either, so how is this relevant, drooly?

Superman has beaten a highly skilled martial artist in an inferior body, and is capable of paralyzing or knocking out people with a single finger touch.

Thor by comparison is non-existent.

OOOO I see so you have your own narrow defintion of what a martials arts expert is? So unless it doesn't use pressure points then it's not martial arts?

He beat Kobra who got beaten by Mister Terrific. What people is he capable of paralysing? One martial arts expert with no feats, Ultraman who has no martial arts training and a possessed Batman (who obvoulsy was in a much inferior state).

Somehow these three feats trump Thors craploads of great showings, lets not forget Batman had to save a depowered Superman from some thugs.

You're just showing you're immaturity I saw you're edit. In some cases they don't have to be martial arts experts. Obvoulsy using fighting skill to beat a Grizzly bear is impressive, a Grizzly doesn't need to know martial arts I shouldn't have to explain that.

Going up against trained guards and zodiac henchmen they are obvoulsy trained fighters.

I have also told you this already, ONE feat doesn't win a feat war we average feats out and on average Thor wins.

Originally posted by Deadline
Look you're just dodging points.

OOOO I see so you have your own narrow defintion of what a martials arts expert is? So unless it doesn't use pressure points then it's not martial arts?

He beat Kobra who got beaten by Mister Terrific. What people is he capable of paralysing? One martial arts expert with no feats, Ultraman who has no martial arts training and a possessed Batman (who obvoulsy was in a much inferior state).

Somehow these three feats trump Thors craploads of great showings, lets not forget Batman had to save a depowered Superman from some thugs.

You're just showing you're immaturity I saw you're edit. In some cases they don't have to be martial arts experts. Obvoulsy using fighting skill to beat a Grizzly bear is impressive, a Grizzly doesn't need to know martial arts I shouldn't have to explain that.

Going up against trained guards and zodiac henchmen they are obvoulsy trained fighters.

I have also told you this already, ONE feat doesn't win a feat war we average feats out and on average Thor wins.


So your reasoning is that the people with martial art training can't be paralyzed by pressure point attacks? Hal jordan has knocked out a grizzly bear with punches. OMG Hal izz teh besterest!!!!!!!

Originally posted by abhilegend
So your reasoning is that the people with martial art training can't be paralyzed by pressure point attacks?

What on earth are u talking about?

Originally posted by Deadline
What on earth are u talking about?

Originally posted by Deadline
[b]What people is he capable of paralysing? One martial arts expert with no feats, Ultraman who has no martial arts training and a possessed Batman (who obvoulsy was in a much inferior state).
[/B]

This.