Superman vs Thor (punching contest)

Started by carver920 pages

Originally posted by -Pr-
👆

Though just fyi, randomly naming off a bunch of enemies isn't proof, as there's no comparison involved.

That's why I said high fts. 😕

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...too bad I'm right. Thor has withstood attacks from Galactus, Ego, Odin, Surtur, Desak, Destroyer, Celestials, Mangog, a being that was empowered by 10000 gods, Zeus, and the list goes on. When I say withstood, I mean withstand attacks and kept fighting.

So basically, I am right.

Well Carvy, I was trying to find a good "OH YOU!!" picture, but couldn't find a slightly original one. However, I did find this during my search.

I just thought I should share. I felt it would be a disservice to the board if I didn't.

Anyways, moving on. First-off, Zeus? Wouldn't his energy attacks be refreshing Thor? That'd be almost like blasting Superman with plasma canon that perfectly mimics our Sun. But for the physical attacks? You want to admit Thor is way more durable than Hulk, be my guest. 😄

So, for Superman when it comes to opponents, we've got Pocketverse Superboy, Doomsday, Quex-Ul, Cythonna, Despero, Darkseid, Superboy Prime, Blaze, Shazam, Emperor Joker(took everything Joker dished-out and bounced back up until getting his heart ripped-out), and more. He wasn't incapacitated by that Sun-Eater thing even though he was weakened. Black holes? I heard that Thor didn't believe he could survive in one. Superman on the other hand has been fine in them. For a few examples.

Originally posted by Delta1938
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties#USSR

Do you see "Russia" anywhere there? Do you? No? K concession accepted. Not my fault you don't remember your history old timer.

Google it but anyways Superman has a slight edge with his fists but mjolnir hits far harder than Superman's fists.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Google it but anyways Superman has a slight edge with his fists but mjolnir hits far harder than Superman's fists.

Proof?

Originally posted by biensalsa
Proof?
Two hammers colliding and affecting all of reality.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Two hammers colliding and affecting all of reality.

That was the mystical energies from both hammers interacting. It had nothing to do with hitting power due to force and strength. If both had indestructible adamantium hammers instead then nothing would have happened whatsoever.

Originally posted by carver9
That's why I said high fts. 😕

Still isn't proof.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Two hammers colliding and affecting all of reality.

I guess if shared feat of TWO Mjolnir's colliding with each other is enough for you.

I just find SINGLE punches that retcon history more impressive

Even considering the context of both feats

Originally posted by h1a8
That was the mystical energies from both hammers interacting. It had nothing to do with hitting power due to force and strength. If both had indestructible adamantium hammers instead then nothing would have happened whatsoever.
We are discussing it's mystical power as well. You don't get to discount it just because it's mystical in nature. The hammers are mystical not adamantium that's the point.

Originally posted by biensalsa
I guess if shared feat of TWO Mjolnir's colliding with each other is enough for you.

I just find SINGLE punches that retcon history more impressive

Even considering the context of both feats

Due to certain factors being present sure. But punches from Superman don't just retcon reality in a regular environment.

Originally posted by carver9
Spiderman vs Superboy was a good one as well. I also liked the JLA vs the Justice League.

The JLA fought the Justice League?

Originally posted by Silent Master
How much is "by a lot" Let's say that a strike by Thor w/Mjolnir = 100, what would a Superman strike rank as?

Same question in regards to strengh, if Thor = 100.....Superman =?

Over 9,000.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Google it but anyways Superman has a slight edge with his fists but mjolnir hits far harder than Superman's fists.

You finding it on Google only proves that Google is helpful for the clueless.

Oh and Superman has a pretty large edge.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Due to certain factors being present sure. But punches from Superman don't just retcon reality in a regular environment.

How do You know? How many battles have you seen of Superman all out vs another Superman?

I know for a fact that Superman's body can with stand time shattering forces even when there was no Multiverse. He has even survived forces that open Hypertime.

For all you know in a regular environment all out Superman punches have the same effect as the hammers.

I can say the same thing. Single Mjolnir collision alone does not has the same effect.

And I saw plenty top tiers like Black Adam not holding back vs SBP, Why this did not happened when Adam hit SBP?

Why did only happened with the Kryptonians?

Originally posted by Delta1938
The JLA fought the Justice League?

Over 9,000.

You finding it on Google only proves that Google is helpful for the clueless.

Oh and Superman has a pretty large edge.

I meant to say, I liked the Xmen vs the JLA.

Originally posted by carver9
I meant to say, I liked the Xmen vs the JLA.

You would. Low showings all around.

Originally posted by -Pr-
You would. Low showings all around.

Naah, that wasn't a low showing...you can tell both teams was holding back. I mainly liked the Batman showing in the beginning. He was working the Xmen.

Originally posted by carver9
I meant to say, I liked the Xmen vs the JLA.

Technically that wasn't DC VERSUS MARVEL, it was ALL-ACCESS, a sequel. And ironically I just reread it this evening. Or yesterday even, whatever you want to call it.

Originally posted by carver9
Naah, that wasn't a low showing...you can tell both teams was holding back. I mainly liked the Batman showing in the beginning. He was working the Xmen.

No, there were plenty of low-showings there.

Originally posted by carver9
Naah, that wasn't a low showing...you can tell both teams was holding back. I mainly liked the Batman showing in the beginning. He was working the Xmen.

You saying that only shows your bias.

Originally posted by cdtm

I guess you don't know the context there.

Originally posted by Delta1938
I thought Kurse was 4 times stronger, not 5. Collective? Was that the bacteria that were altered into higher lifeforms by the Celestials similar to the Eternals, or am I mixing them up?

Most eternals are around low to mid, to high Herald level in power (i.e. Ikaris, Ajak, and Sersi). Zuras might be high herald, trans or skyfather depending on who you ask.

A Celestial is a match for a well fed Galactus (some are even MUCH more powerful than that), and they can slap around skyfathers like you and I would swat a fly.

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
Most eternals are around low to mid, to high Herald level in power (i.e. Ikaris, Ajak, and Sersi). Zuras might be high herald, trans or skyfather depending on who you ask.

I despise the term "Herald."

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
A Celestial is a match for a well fed Galactus (some are even MUCH more powerful than that), and they can slap around skyfathers like you and I would swat a fly.

That's nice, but what does it have to do with what I asked?