Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Yeah but that was like 30 years ago. Lucas did the script for the original Star Wars. And probably had a writing hand in most of the Indiana Jones films.
For me, he's a kickass story teller. He isn't too risky with his stories and they are not very heady (except dat father reveal...one of the greatest reveals of all time in movie history, imo). But they still have mass appeal and still can satisfy at least some critics.
I try not to think of the ST, too much. If I do, I will overhype it and be hugely disappointed.
For me, the Matrix Reloaded and Revolutions sequels met and exceeded my expectations. I could not believe Revolutions followed up with such a kickass sequel to Reloaded and The Matrix. While feeling very different from The Matrix, Reloaded was such an entertaining and enjoyable film that I did not think the third could do any better. But, my opinion is in the minority among geeks (unfortunately). I see this happening with the Star Wars ST; the ST will not deliver what the fans want. I think I may fall into the "man, did not live up to hype" group only because I expect so much out of the films.
I grew up watching the OT and PT. Damnit...I don't want the hype. People like focus4chumps and Lord Lucien are offering probably accurate and sobering predictions about the ST that I just don't want to be true.
Palpitine's masterful rise to power and Luke's growth into a Jedi Knight are very very tough stories to top, imo. I just don't see how we can get something better and/or more well written even if we get some old talent back. Financially, if we get something on part with the PT, it will be a massive success. I want something just a tad better than the PT. Just a tad...
If we get that, I am sure the fans that were angry with the PT will be more forgiving. Kind of like a compromise that works in business negotiations*. They will think, "Well, it's better than the PT...that's a start."
*In negotiations, if you offer the lesser deal, first, it may not be accepted. However, if you offer a shitty deal, first, "they" might be more receptive to the lesser deal when you offer it. This has been researched and is a fairly interesting phenomena. I am, of course, horribly extrapolating that phenomena for the PT to ST "service satisfaction." lol, here's hoping I'm right.