Superman Better than Goku?

Started by BloodRain12 pages

Originally posted by carver9
Thing gets destroyed by Hulk. Wonderman died when he was rammed into that moon. Thing isn't close as strong as you are trying to make him out to be...its debatable if he is a 100 tonner, something that kid Goku was during his child hood.

Okay? I never once denied that Hulk stomps him. That was in response to cdtm saying Thing's strength is nowhere near a Savage Hulk's strength, nothing more.

Really? So Thing's slave block feat which could anchor a city-sized spaceship is only worth a mere 100 tons, as in the weight of a heavy tank?

Thing is a regular 100-tonner in the sense that 100 tons is his average. He's not as strong as Hulk or Superman, but what does any of that have to do with Superman and Goku?

Originally posted by -Pr-
Thing is a regular 100-tonner in the sense that 100 tons is his average. He's not as strong as Hulk or Superman, but what does any of that have to do with Superman and Goku?

Everything.

He's replying to my point about it just being accepted that guys like Thing and Wonder Man can go toe to toe with guys like Hulk and Thor, and take punches without exploding, despite not having the strength feats to prove they can match them. Yet it's been argued Goku won't be able to survive a punch because he doesn't have the strength feats of Superman.

But the fact is, very few characters have strength feats anywhere near Supermans. We simply don't question that when a writer has someone like, I don't know, Knockout or Etrigan fight Superman, that it's not PIS.

It just seems like a double standard, to me.

I know Z fans kind of brought that on themselves over the years, to be fair, but an anti fanboy could be as bad as a fanboy, imo..

Originally posted by BloodRain
Yeah, the very best physical feat we have is that one clocking in at sub-Town level. Characters far weaker than Supes wreck that level.
There is some discussion that Kid Gohan's feat of destroying the Saiyan pod might actually be the best strength feat in the series.

Either it's because they fight in-verse, or their feats aren't monstrously different. Like Thing and Savage Hulk. They have fought before and their feats don't have a massive gap, so the claims of Thing standing up for a few secs has reason. And if Wonder Man does turn out to have near planetary strength, the a case can possibly be made to surviving Thor's punches. Thing is, as said, it's not impossible to see why in a purely physical senses these characters can face each other for a moment.

The single issue is when as you said the writer makes World Breaker Hulk break his fist on Captain America's American-chiseled chin, that we have to consider the PIS.

Other than that there isn't really any double standards going on with this, so long as the instances and feats check out.

Edit:

Originally posted by NemeBro
There is some discussion that Kid Gohan's feat of destroying the Saiyan pod might actually be the best strength feat in the series.

Saw that ages ago, not sure why though. What makes the pod so impressive? Can only recall the room sized creator they leave behind.

I know one thing. Frieza withstood a planet's destruction point blank but he would die in one punch from a serious Super Saiyan Goku. Super Saiyan 2, he would explode from a hit.

Terrible to use strength fts against characters that doesn't go around lifting things. The main purpose of DBZ is combat, not saving the day via getting cats out of trees.

http://media.animevice.com/uploads/0/9491/271087-trunks_slices_freeza_2_super.jpg Frieza sure did tank that, just look how intact he is, his entire head survived.

I agree, a Super Saiyan can kill him but a planet can't.

Originally posted by BloodRain

Saw that ages ago, not sure why though. What makes the pod so impressive? Can only recall the room sized creator they leave behind.
Tanked Nappa's super finger bang attack.

Originally posted by carver9
I know one thing. Frieza withstood a planet's destruction point blank but he would die in one punch from a serious Super Saiyan Goku.

But he didn't. And Goku was serious.

Originally posted by Bro SMASH
But he didn't. And Goku was serious.

Goku toyed with Frieza and ended it when he wanted. When was he serious? If anything he was arrogant.

Originally posted by carver9
Goku toyed with Frieza and ended it when he wanted. When was he serious? If anything he was arrogant.

You're right, but for a different reason, imo.

It's not Goku's arrogance that made him hold back. Goku isn't a killer by nature, and Freeza was defeated and humiliated. (So Goku thought.) Goku wanted to stop him without killing him.

Just like he begged Krillin to spare Vegeta, and yelled at Vegeta for killing the defeated Ginyu members.

Originally posted by carver9
Goku toyed with Frieza and ended it when he wanted. When was he serious? If anything he was arrogant.

Goku didn't toy with Frieza. He was serious that whole time, especially since he was pissed off.

Originally posted by cdtm
You're right, but for a different reason, imo.

It's not Goku's arrogance that made him hold back. Goku isn't a killer by nature, and Freeza was defeated and humiliated. (So Goku thought.) Goku wanted to stop him without killing him.

Just like he begged Krillin to spare Vegeta, and yelled at Vegeta for killing the defeated Ginyu members.

I agree. 👆

Originally posted by Bro SMASH
Goku didn't toy with Frieza. He was serious that whole time, especially since he was pissed off.

Goku isn't a killer and ALWAYS hold back.

Does he? He's no murderer, that's for sure, but there's no way in hell he was holding back against Cell during the end game of their fight. Or the middle game seeing as how he attempted to kill him by blowing away his top half.

Namek SSJ Goku couldn't one-shot Frieza. Experienced SSJ Goku who was able to deflect Trunks' swings with his finger would make Frieza explode with a single punch.

Originally posted by cdtm
Everything.

He's replying to my point about it just being accepted that guys like Thing and Wonder Man can go toe to toe with guys like Hulk and Thor, and take punches without exploding, despite not having the strength feats to prove they can match them. Yet it's been argued Goku won't be able to survive a punch because he doesn't have the strength feats of Superman.

But the fact is, very few characters have strength feats anywhere near Supermans. We simply don't question that when a writer has someone like, I don't know, Knockout or Etrigan fight Superman, that it's not PIS.

It just seems like a double standard, to me.

I know Z fans kind of brought that on themselves over the years, to be fair, but an anti fanboy could be as bad as a fanboy, imo..

Guys like Thing and Wonder Man rarely take full strength hits from the Hulks and Thors of the world because usually, the stronger a hero is, the more focus they put on how much they hold back.

I'm honestly not sure what you're getting at though. I mean, when Superman fights say, Etrigan, you have to remember that someone like that brings something to the table that gives them an edge (ie magic). When Superman fights, say, Knockout or Rampage or even say, Aquaman, the thing to remember is that you don't have to be stronger than or AS strong as Superman to knock him down. He still only weighs about 200 pounds, and if he isn't bracing he's going to be subject to the same laws of physics as anything else that gets punched by someone that can hit with the weight of 100 tons.

I get that comics are inconsistent in that regard, but someone like Thing can knock down someone like Superman if he gets the drop on him. He just has no real hope of actually keeping him down unless Superman makes no attempt to fight back.

Dunno about Goku, so can't comment.

Originally posted by carver9
I know one thing. Frieza withstood a planet's destruction point blank but he would die in one punch from a serious Super Saiyan Goku. Super Saiyan 2, he would explode from a hit.

Terrible to use strength fts against characters that doesn't go around lifting things. The main purpose of DBZ is combat, not saving the day via getting cats out of trees.

lol, u so mad.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Tanked Nappa's super finger bang attack.

Wouldn't that put that Gohan on Nappa's level?

Originally posted by BloodRain
Wouldn't that put that Gohan on Nappa's level?

Sometimes, Gohan probably was. 😄

Geta was worried enough to warn Nappa, and Gohan did force him to actively defend an attack (Characters on or near the same level do this all the time, if they can't tank or avoid it), which made his arm go numb..