Hal Jordan and Flash (Wally) vs Thor and Hulk

Started by Rage.Of.Olympus13 pages

Originally posted by abhilegend
Speed-force upgrade? You mean something which has stuck since? Its not surfer or Iron man's upgrades.

You said its a cheapshot by all accounts, its presented as a cheapshot by dialogue but not by art.

As easily as a mind-controlled superman twoshotting cap? No, because we've seen cap suckerpunch superman both before and after and it didn't took him out. You've seen an IMP fail? Where?

Don't talk like him then.

I meant,"Do you say it everytime?"

I didn't mean it doesn't count. Although, Wally was riding on a high at the time.

Which is exactly my point. Sucker shots fluctuate wildly in comics in regards to effectiveness. You want contradictory evidence? Wally once got a running start and hit Grodd with all he had. The attack didn't put the Gorilla down IIRC and I know it broke his hand.

Only when I start getting bored.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Stop lying. How can the Infinite Mass Punch be his trademark ability if he's used it only once, maybe twice? Maybe if it was a rare move he tapped into in the most dire of situations like Thor's God Blast, you'd have a point but as it stands? Speed stealing has far more evidence to support it being a trademark ability, and frankly, I'd think it'd be more effective in this fight.

I don't just look at the pretty pictures, I also read the text. I recommend that you do so as well, the art is good, but Morrison is an even better writer.

😂

He actually uses aoe attacks to beat Spider-Man, Moongoose and Quicksilver.

I was referring to it's popularity and not how frequently he used it. I also considering Thor's god blast a trademark ability even though it's usually not the first thing he pulls out of his ass when he's in a fight.

You're absolutely right, speed stealing would be just another of many ways Flash could steamroll Thor 😎 glad we finally agree on something

Originally posted by Mihsnme
I was referring to it's popularity and not how frequently he used it. I also considering Thor's god blast a trademark ability even though it's usually not the first thing he pulls out of his ass when he's in a fight.

You're absolutely right, speed stealing would be just another of many ways Flash could steamroll Thor 😎 glad we finally agree on something

Which is kind of my point. Some idiots see a scan posted once, and they think this is how a character responds to all situations. The God Blast however has far more grounds to being a trademark ability then the punch.

The simple fact that you think Wally would own Thor indicates you've read very little Flash. A ground slam from Hulk would very often be a great counter to a speedster.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Which is kind of my point. Some idiots see a scan posted once, and they think this is how a character responds to all situations. The God Blast however has far more grounds to being a trademark ability then the punch.

The simple fact that you think Wally would own Thor indicates you've read very little Flash.

The simple fact that Wally would own Thor is just that, the simple fact, and considering I'm not the only person who thinks so, I guess everyone else who agrees has no knowledge of the character, you apparently have so much knowledge that the only argument you can think of is weather Wally sucker punched Zum or not, and even that's not relevant since Thor is no more durable and no where near as fast as he is.

Originally posted by Mihsnme
The simple fact that Wally would own Thor is just that, the simple fact, and considering I'm not the only person who thinks so, I guess everyone else who agrees has no knowledge of the character, you apparently have so much knowledge that the only argument you can think of is weather Wally sucker punched Zum or not, and even that's not relevant since Thor is no more durable and no where near as fast as he is.

Yes, clearly anyone who thinks Thor would beat Flash has no knowledge of the character. Lol, this guy.

Well, agree to disagree then. If I post contradictory evidence, I'll just get it thrown in my face by Carver later or something.

You are going to have to prove that Zum is as durable as Thor.

Anyways, I'm going to go play some dishonored, bye Fangirl.

Dishonored rocks. 👆

Too bad my iso ****ed up >_<

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Yes, clearly anyone who thinks Thor would beat Flash has no knowledge of the character. Lol, this guy.

Well, agree to disagree then. If I post contradictory evidence, I'll just get it thrown in my face by Carver later or something.

You are going to have to prove that Zum is as durable as Thor.

Anyways, I'm going to go play some dishonored, bye Fangirl.

Lets just analyze this for a second

You stated that Wally cheap shotted Zum correct? Lets assume he did

What's to stop him from doing the same thing to Thor? We already know THor is no where near as fast as Zum is, Wally stated that he could hit Zum a thousand more times before he could blink...

What do you think is going to happen to Thor? Thor who's been blitzed by street levelers?

The only thing you've stated is that Thor could use an AOE attack. An attack that Wally could more than likely avoid.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I didn't mean it doesn't count. Although, Wally was riding on a high at the time.

Which is exactly my point. Sucker shots fluctuate wildly in comics in regards to effectiveness. You want contradictory evidence? Wally once got a running start and hit Grodd with all he had. The attack didn't put the Gorilla down IIRC and I know it broke his hand.

Only when I start getting bored.


He is still riding it high. Speedsters take on bricks all the time in DC.

Wally was going at Mach 10 at that point. His human level strength at that speed isn't enough to beat a top tier, I agree.

😂

Also wally needs no stinkin' godblast. He can just punch a lot and do more damage.

funny how every flash thread seems to denigrate into--he can and will IMP every time in the first attosecond of a match. 😂

except, well......he doesn't. EVER. in ANY COMIC. EVER. and i'm actually with rage here--i do not think the IMP=insta-ko on thor, and certainly not on hulk. hulk has ALSO hit thor into space/near space, and thor basically shrugged it off like it was a fly that stung him. it only po'd him. thor has definitely got the feats to suggest he could take it and come back more po'd than when he left. for that matter etrigan (magical demon) punched kal to the MOON and supes was like, whatever, and back in the fight immediately.

IMP is (for the one or 2 times it has ever been used in history) is definitely a solid attack. greater than a good cl100 good deliver? i doubt it imo. supes, hulk, thor, cm--all could deliver at least as powerful a blow and most, if not all, have better striking feats than one-shot ko'ing a martian......

as for the match--either team could win. i see the marvel guys as harder to put down though. not sure who i'd take. with bfr flash and hal should def take more. sans bfr it's a very tough call imo.

Rage and Abhi going at it... Well, it was nice while it lasted, I guess...

while it lasted....?

Originally posted by leonidas
funny how every flash thread seems to denigrate into--he can and will IMP every time in the first attosecond of a match. 😂

except, well......he doesn't. EVER. in ANY COMIC. EVER. and i'm actually with rage here--i do not think the IMP=insta-ko on thor, and certainly not on hulk. hulk has ALSO hit thor into space/near space, and thor basically shrugged it off like it was a fly that stung him. it only po'd him. thor has definitely got the feats to suggest he could take it and come back more po'd than when he left. for that matter etrigan (magical demon) punched kal to the MOON and supes was like, whatever, and back in the fight immediately.

IMP is (for the one or 2 times it has ever been used in history) is definitely a solid attack. greater than a good cl100 good deliver? i doubt it imo. supes, hulk, thor, cm--all could deliver at least as powerful a blow and most, if not all, have better striking feats than one-shot ko'ing a martian......

as for the match--either team could win. i see the marvel guys as harder to put down though. not sure who i'd take. with bfr flash and hal should def take more. sans bfr it's a very tough call imo.

It isn't impossible to beat a morals on Flash. But lets look at what you just posted. You're judging how strong the IMP is based on the distance it knocked Zum.

Knocking someone back doesn't equate to doing more damage to them. In one of their earlier fights Lobo was devastating Superman in a fight, he didn't punch him out of orbit, but his hits were doing more damage than Etrigan's moon punch

Darkseid is another example, he's backhanded Superman and drew blood from him, didn't knock him back more than a few feet but still did more visible damage than Etrigan did.

We already know that Wally's standard punches can harm Mongul [who owned Wonder Woman and fought Kal several times] so we already know that the IMP would deliver greater effects. In the scan already posted in this thread Wally one shotted a character with Superman level durability with it. It can one shot Thor and Hulk and even without it, neither of them can withstand getting hit a thousand times in an instant with punches with enough force to hurt Mongul, and they still don't have a defense against speed stealing.

Originally posted by Mihsnme
It isn't impossible to beat a morals on Flash. But lets look at what you just posted. You're judging how strong the IMP is based on the distance it knocked Zum.

Knocking someone back doesn't equate to doing more damage to them. In one of their earlier fights Lobo was devastating Superman in a fight, he didn't punch him out of orbit, but his hits were doing more damage than Etrigan's moon punch

Darkseid is another example, he's backhanded Superman and drew blood from him, didn't knock him back more than a few feet but still did more visible damage than Etrigan did.

We already know that Wally's standard punches can harm Mongul [who owned Wonder Woman and fought Kal several times] so we already know that the IMP would deliver greater effects. In the scan already posted in this thread Wally one shotted a character with Superman level durability with it. It can one shot Thor and Hulk and even without it, neither of them can withstand getting hit a thousand times in an instant with punches with enough force to hurt Mongul, and they still don't have a defense against speed stealing.

and you're judging how strong the IMP is because it knocked out one white martian. so your initial argument has a flaw--it presupposes that you have full knowledge of zum's durability. can you show me his durability feats? you're assuming via abc logic that his durability was superman-esque. i disagree. completely. i'd say it's less than jonn's. probably considerably below jonn's. and his his durability is far below superman's. thor has feats that would put him kal's class.

if we suddenly think zum's durability is in question, then the overall power of the IMP is in question. even if we say zum=jonn (which again, i'd highly doubt) that doesn't mean a punch that ko'd him would ko thor or hulk.

and knocking someone back doesn't necessarily imply greater damage in comics, i agree, but it doesn't mean the punch was LESS effective or powerful either. different writers show damage differently and it is IMPOSSIBLE to say etrigan's punch<IMP. there are tons of examples to support either notion. just like i've seen flash throw 1000s of punches at FAR less power than those he threw at mongul. using just high feats leads to skewed arguments. thor has withstood celestials' blasts. doesn't mean i think it takes a celestial to harm him.

i also don't agree with your premise that the IMP>1000s of punches from flash. at least, not from the damage that can be accumulated from said punches. and i'm not one who thinks he can throw 1000s of IMPs either.....

so, yeah, i think it is completely reasonable to think thor and hulk could both handle an IMP since we don't really know what level the IMP is in the first place, and i don't think that it can be assumed flash will be using the same type of attacks he used against mongul. he COULD i suppose, but the vast majority of in-character flash battles has him doing much less than that.

now, the one argument i cannot criticize is the speed steal. he SHOULD be able to do that. if he does his team wins every time. but....it is also not a common form of attack. in fact, it's exceedingly rare and so should be consider a possible way for them to win, but not the main reason at all, imo.

Originally posted by leonidas
while it lasted....?

Yeah, okay. It's been shit from the start.

😂

Originally posted by abhilegend
Also wally needs no stinkin' godblast. He can just punch a lot and do more damage.

Wasn't he just in Barry's body

Speed steal for the win.

Originally posted by nwg202
Speed steal for the win.

No, he was just transported to the past.

Also, if someone doesn't has read this, read it. Morrison specifies that the white martians were "as tough" as superman.

I would laugh at anyone who thinks that Thor is in superman class durability.

something that makes me laugh is the fact that jonn has showed greater durability than superman at one point and superman. and it's a feat, not narration. but the narration i choose to believe is the one where jonn says he's as powerful as superman. picking and choosing which narration to believe certainly does make these debates easier, i agree. 👆

i also wonder if supes meant ALL white martians. cuz that would make the scene where jonn takes on several of them.....pretty impressive given that supes could hardly handle a single one. inverse ninja for the excuse win? lol feats>>>>>>then one melodramatic panel of narration. at least imho.

i'd actually laugh at the durability comparison as well, just not as hard and there are feats thor has that put him in that class--just has supes has feats that show he could be dropped by things much less than his highest feats. all feats need to be taken into account.