Originally posted by Patient_Leech
I think there's something about the alien from Alien(s) that is a little more believable and visceral than the Predators. It plays on our evolutionary fear of earthly animal predators (meaning lions, tigers, bears, oh my). It's more terrifying to me because the aliens just kill out of instinct because that is just what they do. Predators appear to be doing it for sport, which just isn't as scary. Hell, we hunt for sport. That being said, I like Predator 1 and the more recent Predators quite a lot... great sci-fi action/adventure films.
Just a quick reply... Point is yeah you can relate to an Alien killing out of animal instinct. But a Predator is more akin to a serial killer, killing for the sake of pleasure (& sadistic pride). Look at the recent back lash to trophy hunting, there is a distinctive element of repulse to people who do it, not an understanding or
acceptance that it's normal.
So I think our evolutionary fear would be towards a Predator for not quite understanding their motive to kill.