Cass (Batgirl) vs Captain America

Started by pym-ftw15 pages

You realize standard humans use 100% of their brains right, and like Slade, Cap also has a super brain...

Cap wins based on both stats and attrition, not to mention her best chance of her dropping him is based soley on him fighting her battle ie: strike/counter strike

Originally posted by namorsubby
That was their 2nd fight where cass claimed he was hard to read. Im thinking slades whole 90% brainpower enhancement had something to do with it and/or he adjusted somehow from the first fight. Cap doesnt have that. So again, why couldn't cassandra read him like a book?

You are right. Id simply like to know what it is though.

I don't know about other people, but for me, her body language reading will work, it just won't be enough to help her win. Why? Because Cap is stronger than her. He's at least as fast, if not faster. He's more durable. He's arguably as skilled, if not more skilled.

She's going to have a tougher time against him purely because even if she sees a punch coming, it's still coming at her with the speed and strength of a top tier MA. You could argue that she might hit him more than vice versa, but I honestly don't believe any gap on her end is going to make the difference.

Also, Steve can take more hits than she can.

Originally posted by -Pr-

Also, Steve can take more hits than she can.
thats sexist

Originally posted by Starscream M
thats sexist

lol, no it isn't. Not in the slightest.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I can your point, cdtm, but really, in some cases, those "iconic" characters really do have the feats to warrant them being the favorite in their bout. In terms of the high end "street level" tier, in a fight with no weapons or gear, Steve is arguably the top guy.

Val Armorr disagrees.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I don't know about other people, but for me, her body language reading will work, it just won't be enough to help her win. Why? Because Cap is stronger than her. He's at least as fast, if not faster. He's more durable. He's arguably as skilled, if not more skilled.

She's going to have a tougher time against him purely because even if she sees a punch coming, it's still coming at her with the speed and strength of a top tier MA. You could argue that she might hit him more than vice versa, but I honestly don't believe any gap on her end is going to make the difference.

Also, Steve can take more hits than she can.

i have a distinct sense of deja vu.... 😂

i second this. and third it. and think i've said the same thing so i fourth it as well.....

Originally posted by abhilegend
Val Armorr disagrees.

Val has jobber aura stronger than Cap.. He's beyond street.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Val has jobber aura stronger than Cap.. He's beyond street.

Nope. He's still a street leveler.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I don't know about other people, but for me, her body language reading will work, it just won't be enough to help her win. Why? Because Cap is stronger than her. He's at least as fast, if not faster. He's more durable. He's arguably as skilled, if not more skilled.

She's going to have a tougher time against him purely because even if she sees a punch coming, it's still coming at her with the speed and strength of a top tier MA. You could argue that she might hit him more than vice versa, but I honestly don't believe any gap on her end is going to make the difference.

Also, Steve can take more hits than she can.

Nice break down Pr.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I don't know about other people, but for me, her body language reading will work, it just won't be enough to help her win. Why? Because Cap is stronger than her. He's at least as fast, if not faster. He's more durable. He's arguably as skilled, if not more skilled.

She's definitely the smaller target and more agile, though. He's got more mass, meaning more momentum, he doesn't change directions and positions as fast (and not just talking how it *should* work in real life, we all know that doesn't apply, but in how they're *draw*). She's got the actual better speed feats.

And she's arguably more skilled- Cass has been training from birth and not only can pick up moves at Taskmaster speed, but has intense hands-on training from Batman and Shiva, as well as experience with many other top fighters.

And this is without shield.

I think, bare minimum, you're talking 50/50, but probable edge to Cassandra. She was designed to be the best martial artist in modern DC, and her feats hold that up.

Originally posted by Starscream M
thats sexist
Originally posted by abhilegend
Val Armorr disagrees.

Val Armorr ain't street level. His "super karate"/PIS puts him in a whole other league.

Originally posted by Starscream M
thats sexist

You're gonna tell me Cass' stamina and durability is equal to or even superior to Steve's?

Originally posted by JayDaDon

😂

and good to see you back jake. sensible posters always welcome. 🙂

Nice to see ya, Leo! And it's good to be back.

I need a favor from you again Jake. I need you to change my Sig again.

You don't know how to do it? Or does your computer not let you?

Welcome back, Jake.

Originally posted by carver9
I need you to change my Sig again.

😆

I guess you're fed up with jokes about Hulk riding Supes' dick?

😂

And thanks, Stilt.

Originally posted by Q99
She's definitely the smaller target and more agile, though. He's got more mass, meaning more momentum, he doesn't change directions and positions as fast (and not just talking how it *should* work in real life, we all know that doesn't apply, but in how they're *draw*). She's got the actual better speed feats.

And she's arguably more skilled- Cass has been training from birth and not only can pick up moves at Taskmaster speed, but has intense hands-on training from Batman and Shiva, as well as experience with many other top fighters.

And this is without shield.

I think, bare minimum, you're talking 50/50, but probable edge to Cassandra. She was designed to be the best martial artist in modern DC, and her feats hold that up.

I'm not in any way trying to lowball Cass. I've read her too. 😛

Even if I were to agree with you in terms of agility and momentum, I honestly wouldn't see it as enough of an advantage to win her the fight. If I'm being honest, yes, I think she's more skilled. I just don't think the gap is big enough for her to overcome Steve's superiority in other areas.

Just my personal opinion.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank

You're gonna tell me Cass' stamina and durability is equal to or even superior to Steve's?

Stamina wise, she doesn't need to better him. I don't think many can beat his stamina, tbh.

Steve doesn't have the market cornered on never getting tired, but how many fights get settled through attrition?

She CAN keep going full steam for a long time, at full steam, as many top MA's can. Many hours, or even days if need be..