ROTS Mace Windu Vs AOTC/ROTS Count Dooku

Started by DARTH POWER35 pages
Originally posted by Intrepid37
They're peers and for one to decide the outcome is preference.

👆

Which is why Dooku wins 😛

Mace beat Ventress, who lost to Anakin, who is able to see ships moving at sublight speeds in slow motion, who himself is unable to see Palpatine movements as only as a blur.
When Ventress fights Mace, she wasn't overwhelmed by sheer speed by Mace. If Mace was fighting with the same speed he fought vs Palpaine, she wouldn't even be able to see his strikes.
Dooku is also able to fight Mace without being overwhelmed by Mace's speed either, who was able to hold off Anakin for some time.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
👆

Which is why Dooku wins 😛

lol

I didn't mean that kind of preference, more like Vaapad+shatterpoint vs Makashi+lightning for example.

😉

Wow!!! Are U Serious?
35 pages long!!! I missed alot.
I don't have to say much everything's been said.
Mace still wins.....

You brought up some very good points.

Why Bulq lost to Dooku, I have a thought about that.
Bulq Force pushing Mace didn't happen.

Bulq (imo) was underestimated..
Heck,Sora Depa,Quinlan Vos were underestimated...
Even the Dark Woman. (imo).

I'll just end it on that note and save my replies for another post or topic.

How ever you look at Vaapad is the deciding Factor of this duel.
We talked about this...
This is n't Sora Bulq or Tholme,This is Mace Windu.

Like I said pages ago....Dooku's Mastery of Makashi, Force lightning and TK won't save him.
His Mastery of Makashi will be over-powered by Vaapad as well as the lightning and the TK.
KT explained this Flawlessly
So just hang it up Dooku loses just like he lost against Anakin.
Anakin's Djem So over powered Dooku's Makashi .

I agree with KT and the majority...Mace still wins.
It didn't save him from Anakin....and his Furious Djem So...
IMO Vaapad is better than Makashi.
Heck Djem So is better than Makashi ...

Makashi has it's strong suits just simply not in this duel.
We all are well aware of Makashi's weaknesses. That's why Djem So was created to answer
the weaknesses of both Soresu and Makashi.

Your source wookieepedia/light saber combat.
Path of the Jedi (maybe).

Dooku's Force Lightning also has its strong suits,just not in this duel
And most certainly not against Vaapad,you'll be terribly disappointed if you thought so.

Last but not least the debatable TK.
Dooku can lift and throw all the heavy objects he wants, the simple fact that now it,too
is debatable Dooku's fatigue...he will tire from (A) Throwing those heavy objects
(B) Using the Force to help him defend/parry
those Overwhelming blows from Vaapad.

Just like Anakin over-powered him.
Mace will do the same.
Dooku's shatter point is his pride,his fatigue, and his overconfidence.
And Makashi's weak points.

I failed to mention that through Vaapad he'll use the count's Darkness against him.
either feeding on it or letting it pass through him, either way it goes Mace
will use that power,energy ,either one against Dooku.

Originally posted by juyomaster34
KT explained this Flawlessly

😆

I mean seriously need I say more?IMO KT explained it.nicely...
Why put all this hype on Dooku beating Mace?
When clearly Mace wins this duel. It won't be easy,but it will be a win,
for Mace. 😆 😆 😆

As per Star Wars: The Ultimate Visual Guide:

- Mace is one of the best lightsaber duelists of the Order.
- During Clone Wars, Mace once turned the tide of a battle by single-handedly destroying a huge seismic tank.
- Sidious defeated Mace with aid of Anakin.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
As per Star Wars: The Ultimate Visual Guide:

- Mace is one of the best lightsaber duelists of the Order.

But not "The Best." Dooku also has this claim as a Jedi.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
- Sidious defeated Mace with aid of Anakin.

That doesn't necessarily mean Sidious required Anakin's help. It's just stating a fact, that Sidious killed him with Anakin's aid. Which we all know from the movie.

Mace still wins, and while difficult to do, he'll get the job done.

I'd say Mace beats AOTC/ROTS Dooku, but I see a younger peak Dooku beating peak Mace.

Mace is "The Best" Light Saber duelist of the Order.
Dooku was the best as a Jedi before Mace...

That claim belongs to Mace... with no aids... I know he had the wanna be's with him to arrest Palpatine...trust me they were not there to help Mace,they were there to witness the arrest and probably keep him from using the full power of Vaapad.

Every Jedi,knight,master or padawan dreamed of fighting side by side with Master Yoda against a Sith Lord except(maybe) Anakin..,

It was very poor judgement if those Jedi Masters chosen to Arrest Palpatine were even dare I say close to Yoda in skill with a light saber.

Mace was enough imo. but making a strong case of saying he was indeed a sith lord,you will need witnesses. And for the record Palpatine
was in fact too dangers to be left alive or taken in alive.

Dooku not so much,Palpatine,hell yeah....
too weak and unarmed? please!!! A true Sith Lord is never unarmed.

that's what happens when you send a boy to do a man's job.
Anakin was too close to Palpatine and he let him corrupt and confuse his mind. I agree with the council's decision of not promoting him to master.

he wasn't ready for the title or the responsabilities.
And for the record I don't care about Anakin's pov,of Palpatine,
Palpatine is a Sith Lord,armed or not...he is dangerous and not to be

taken lightly as weak.. or unarmed..remember the Code there is no ignorance there is knowlege.

Originally posted by juyomaster34
Mace is "The Best" Light Saber duelist of the Order.
Dooku was the best as a Jedi before Mace...

No. Yoda was the greatest duelist of the Order. Mace is at best on par with Dooku while Yoda was stated to be the best of them all.