If Sadako of Girth is correct about apparation counting as leaving the battlefield, you would have had to make an exception in the OP or within the first few posts, which you didn't.
However, that is only if he's right about it being considered leaving the BF....I haven't seen the ruling, so I'm not taking a side yet.
Originally posted by Silent MasterSaddie has changed threads 4 pages in.
If Sadako of Girth is correct about apparation counting as leaving the battlefield, you would have had to make an exception in the OP or within the first few posts, which you didn't.However, that is only if he's right about it being considered leaving the BF....I haven't seen the ruling, so I'm not taking a side yet.
Originally posted by Silent MasterHe's not correct.
If Sadako of Girth is correct about apparation counting as leaving the battlefield, you would have had to make an exception in the OP or within the first few posts, which you didn't.However, that is only if he's right about it being considered leaving the BF....I haven't seen the ruling, so I'm not taking a side yet.
He's not correct.
He's butthurt.
Nope. Im correct it was made a cople of years ago when RJ was trolling with it making up/abusing 'half apparating' (Always half that benefitted the wizard rather than the Jedi it fought, conveniently 🙄 IE blaster/force proof but able to be tangible enough to deliver strikes) because of his massive butthurt.
Ask Imp, SM...
Originally posted by Sadako of GirthPlease calm down.
Nope. Im correct it was made a cople of years ago when RJ was trolling with it making up/abusing 'half apparating' (Always half that benefitted the wizard rather than the Jedi it fought, conveniently 🙄 IE blaster/force proof but able to be tangible enough to deliver strikes) because of his massive butthurt.Ask Imp, SM...
Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Nope. Im correct it was made a cople of years ago when RJ was trolling with it making up/abusing 'half apparating' (Always half that benefitted the wizard rather than the Jedi it fought, conveniently 🙄 IE blaster/force proof but able to be tangible enough to deliver strikes) because of his massive butthurt.Ask Imp, SM...
Are you talking about the "Harry Potter Magic versus the Force" thread?
Originally posted by quanchi112
McClane has slow reflexes though. He gets frozen as soon as he touches his gun. DH4.
😂 more downplaying, it's all you have. He was fast enough to disarm and beat a man who had a gun aimed at him in DH5.
Pulling gun and trigger is faster than pulling wand and spell casting.
Originally posted by RobtardOk and ? We see Hermione fine tuning her reflexes/spells in more films than McClane has.
😂 more downplaying, it's all you have. He was fast enough to disarm and beat a man who had a gun aimed at him in DH5.Pulling gun and trigger is faster than pulling wand and spell casting.
You can't just ignore the time where an unarmed women showed far greater reflexes than a man with a gun aimed at her. It takes more time to disarm someone than to pull a trigger as well. Granger wins.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Ok and ? We see Hermione fine tuning her reflexes/spells in more films than McClane has.You can't just ignore the time where an unarmed women showed far greater reflexes than a man with a gun aimed at her. It takes more time to disarm someone than to pull a trigger as well. Granger wins.
Pull gun & pull trigger > pull wand & cast spell. Deal.
Apples to oranges comparison. Lihn was a very fast and agile fighter and McClane turned his attention towards Farrell for a moment. This is a quick-draw style duel where the combatants have to do certain things before the fight starts; it heavily favors the guy with the guy.
Hermoine dies via single bullet to the head or chest. If you want to see McClane lose to Hermione, make a thread where the conditions do not heavily favor the guy with a gun.
Originally posted by RobtardTo disarm someone with a gun is far harder than to pull a trigger and McClane failed horribly there as well. Hermione's reflexes are fast enough to beat someone a mere muggle can disarm.
Pull gun & pull trigger > pull wand & cast spell. Deal.Apples to oranges comparison. Lihn was a very fast and agile fighter and McClane turned his attention towards Farrell for a moment. This is a quick-draw style duel where the combatants have to do certain things before the fight starts; it heavily favors the guy with the guy.
Hermoine dies via single bullet to the head or chest. If you want to see McClane lose to Hermione, make a thread where the conditions do not heavily favor the guy with a gun.
He wasn't a very quick draw there just as he won't be there. The difference here is that his opponent has a weapon as opposed to not having one.
Originally posted by quanchi112
To disarm someone with a gun is far harder than to pull a trigger and McClane failed horribly there as well. Hermione's reflexes are fast enough to beat someone a mere muggle can disarm.He wasn't a very quick draw there just as he won't be there. The difference here is that his opponent has a weapon as opposed to not having one.
Sure, ignore the context. Nope, pulling trigger > wand waving spell casting.
And a False Analogy. You sure do like to use logical fallacies.