Which universe is more powerful; Harry Potter or Lotr ?

Started by quanchi11214 pages

Originally posted by That Lotr Fan
I'm sorry I fell to this but time for some Quanchi debating;

"Show me the screenshot of someone being hit in the toe with the AK and dying. You need proof, whahahahahahahahahahah"

You shouldn't talk to yourself 😛

Watch the films. The kill curse kills when it strikes. You're very odd.

I'm also puzzled. In the 4th movie we see the AK used. First it is used on a spider, it dies as soon as it connects. Likewise, Cedric was dead as soon as the AK hit him.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Rubbish.

They keep dragons as tortured pets. In potter verse they all shit themselves in sight of one dragon. In porter verse they use them in their games.

Show me a stone giant disintegrating anything. You can't so the shield is more powerful based off feats.

Show me the shield desintegrating a stone.

Originally posted by Reflassshh
Show me the shield a stone.
please make some sense, kid.

First you go hiding and reply out of nowhere 2 months later and now you reply before I can edit?

You're strange.

Originally posted by Reflassshh
First you go hiding and reply out of nowhere 2 months later and now you reply before I can edit?

You're strange.

So I have to wait till someone can edit out the nonsense ? I mocked you changed it.

That isn't necessary. The shield can disintegrate wizards what have the stone giants disintegrated ?

I'll wait. Quit making up excuses and answer the question.

Quit avoiding the question 😬

Originally posted by Reflassshh
Quit avoiding the question 😬
You can't even grasp the thread. The two aren't facing each other. This is a test of power by way of feats, portrayal.

Shield disintegrates. Fact. Has the stone giant ?

😂

A stone giant is more effective in a fight than a dumb shield. So the stone giant is more powerful.

Originally posted by Reflassshh
A stone giant is more effective in a fight than a dumb shield. So the stone giant is more powerful.
Formidability is a differ t subject altogether than power. Try to stay on topic or is this too advanced for you ? That seems to be the case. Potter magic wrecks stone and quite easily.

Originally posted by Reflassshh
A stone giant is more effective in a fight than a dumb shield. So the stone giant is more powerful.

Not when this sheild can vaporize beings when they enter.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Not when this sheild can vaporize beings when they enter.
Reflash doesn't even grasp the difference between Formidability and raw power output. The best part is how easily the potter wizards would route these slow stone Giants with their superior speed and power on these massive targets.

🙂

The Dark Lord Sauron with the One Ring has built indestructible buildings such as Barad-dur, he maintains the Nazgul simultaneously, he can controll all of the Rings of power and mentally destroy the strongest minds in the verse, he also lifted up Gil-galad and disintegrated him with his bare hand.

He in a vastly weakened spirit form has godstomped Mithrandir and effortlessly resurrected the nine. He has mentally dominated Saruman, the most powerful Istari before Mithrandir became the white wizard. He has effortlessly decimated the fortress of Dol Guldur which was sustained by his own power. He was also capable of mentally contacting Durin's Bane, Shelob and Smaug.

These are feats that are mentioned in movie guides or stated by Peter Jackson, Philippa Boyens and others who produced/wrote the film saga, they are thus movie canon.

Originally posted by AncientPower
The Dark Lord Sauron with the One Ring has built indestructible buildings such as Barad-dur, he maintains the Nazgul simultaneously, he can controll all of the Rings of power and mentally destroy the strongest minds in the verse, he also lifted up Gil-galad and disintegrated him with his bare hand.

He in a vastly weakened spirit form has godstomped Mithrandir and effortlessly resurrected the nine. He has mentally dominated Saruman, the most powerful Istari before Mithrandir became the white wizard. He has effortlessly decimated the fortress of Dol Guldur which was sustained by his own power. He was also capable of mentally contacting Durin's Bane, Shelob and Smaug.

These are feats that are mentioned in movie guides or stated by Peter Jackson, Philippa Boyens and others who produced/wrote the film saga, they are thus movie canon.

He was also defeated by Galadriel. The nine were curb stomped by Elton and saruman. 😂

When they later got their bodies back aragorn defeated them with a torch. 😂

All canon.

Wanna talk about who killed Sauron thrifty seconds into the battle ?

Voldemort's feats of power are far greater than Sauron's. Hogwarts shield. Best it, guy.

Damn, LoTR still kicking ass 👆

Originally posted by Robtard
Damn, LoTR still kicking ass 👆
Here comes the girly cheerleader not bringing anything of value. Instead cheer on your fave, girl.

You're so angry and short.

Originally posted by Robtard
You're so angry and short.
This is what you've been reduced to while,others debate. Carry on, girly.

Originally posted by quanchi112
He was also defeated by Galadriel. The nine were curb stomped by Elton and saruman. 😂

When they later got their bodies back aragorn defeated them with a torch. 😂

All canon.

Wanna talk about who killed Sauron thrifty seconds into the battle ?

Voldemort's feats of power are far greater than Sauron's. Hogwarts shield. Best it, guy.

Galadriel who is a first age Elf and arguably one of the top five strongest elves in the mythos.. whom by the way bore Nenya the Ring of Adamant. Galadriel by the way used her power to create Lorien make Lothlorien timeless, she literally stopped the laws of time in Lothlorien and maintained the power of that place all by herself, infact so strong was her control over the forest that Sauron himself could not see into it. The only place in Middle-Earth in which his gaze cannot pierce. Once she left the forest went into ruin and the power of the place vanished.

Elrond half-elven was also an extremely powerful elf, but his name isn't half-elven for nothing, he is part maia, much like the Istari are Maia. He also weilded Vilya the ring of air. He is extremely powerful much like Galadriel and maintained a similar control over Imladris, remember the massive wave of water that overwhelmed the Nazgul? Elrond sent that.

Gil-Galad was High-King of the Noldor and all Elves and was the strongest of them all, his blood was pure and he was a first age Elf, he wielded Vilya before his death and gave it to Elrond, but even as mighty as he was he to fell to Sauron.

As far as Telcontar using flame to damage the Nazgul you forget that this was at Aman Sul and the power of the nine is greatly diminished when they are considerable distances from Sauron.

Isildur cut off his finger because he had gotten over confident, namely because he just godstomped the most powerful leader in their army and then godstomped another.

The shield summoned at Hogwarts was sustained by a far smaller number of wizards, mostly students at that and was subsequently barraged by hundreds if not thousands of Death Eaters before Voldemort used the Elder Wand to finish it. One of the deathly hallows defeating a shield after it had just been attacked by hundreds of death eaters... wow what an immense god-like feat you have there.

I guess Voldemort is universal manipulator tier.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Galadriel who is a first age Elf and arguably one of the top five strongest elves in the mythos.. whom by the way bore Nenya the Ring of Adamant. Galadriel by the way used her power to create Lorien make Lothlorien timeless, she literally stopped the laws of time in Lothlorien and maintained the power of that place all by herself, infact so strong was her control over the forest that Sauron himself could not see into it. The only place in Middle-Earth in which his gaze cannot pierce. Once she left the forest went into ruin and the power of the place vanished.

Elrond half-elven was also an extremely powerful elf, but his name isn't half-elven for nothing, he is part maia, much like the Istari are Maia. He also weilded Vilya the ring of air. He is extremely powerful much like Galadriel and maintained a similar control over Imladris, remember the massive wave of water that overwhelmed the Nazgul? Elrond sent that.

Gil-Galad was High-King of the Noldor and all Elves and was the strongest of them all, his blood was pure and he was a first age Elf, he wielded Vilya before his death and gave it to Elrond, but even as mighty as he was he to fell to Sauron.

As far as Telcontar using flame to damage the Nazgul you forget that this was at Aman Sul and the power of the nine is greatly diminished when they are considerable distances from Sauron.

Isildur cut off his finger becaused he had gotten over confident, namely because he just godstomped the most powerful leader in their army and then godstomped another.

The shield summoned at Hogwarts was sustained by a far smaller number of wizards, mostly students at that and was subsequently barraged by hundreds if not thousands of Death Eaters before Voldemort used the Elder Wand to finish it. One of the deathly hallows defeating a shield after it had just been attacked by hundreds of death eaters... wow what an immense god-like feat you have there.

I guess Voldemort is universal manipulator tier.

This is films only. You can cite whatever shitty hyperbole you want to. A torch defeated the nazgul. Those are the guys you ranted and raved about that Aragorn defeated.

The spirits were smashed by saruman and Elrond who later was killed by wormfreak.
This was in close proximity to Sauron.

None of this is explored in the films and it's all hyperbole. Movie feats only, sport. 😂

We see mcgonagall and other professors reinforce it. We do see hundreds of wizards attack it but only when Voldemort gets pisses does it destroy it rather quickly. The amazing thing about it he did this despite the elder wand resisting him.

I do agree Isildur got lucky. Galadriel however did not against his spirit form.