Khan Noonien Singh vs. Yoda

Started by Mindset201 pages

Has everyone accepted that Quan won yet?

Originally posted by dadudemon
Even though Lucas sold Star Wars, Chee is still employed and making canon administration efforts. Which means Lucas' statements regarding G-level canon still counts.

Which means it is not up for debate whether or not Mace Windu beat Palpatine fair and square: he did.

Edit - Wait, we already have PR up in dis b*tch. I don't think we need Queeq to clarify. Imp's decisions on this would override anything we say, though. Are we done with this avenue of discussion or are there those that still doubt Mace beat Palpatine fair and square?

Well I wouldn't call it "fair and square," considering Mace began the fight with 3 other Jedi aiding him. That's hardly the definition of "fair and square."

Also Lucas confirmed Mace overpowered Palpatine in the Saber fight, but he also confirmed Palpatine was pretending to be weak with his Lightning in front of Anakin. So he may have been capable of continually firing the Lightning to keep Mace's blade away from him.

Originally posted by Mindset
Has everyone accepted that Yoda won yet?

I see what you did there mmm

Originally posted by quanchi112
Lucas made the film

Originally posted by quanchi112
Lucas sold the rights.

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
Yes, he sold the rights but he shot the scene and its clear Windu won. Nothing has retconned that, kiddo.

Originally posted by Bentley
Quan never proved the ratio of fire of Khan's weapons. You can see him dancing around the issue for about four pages here ermm
Watch the scene and watch any single clones fire by himself. Not even close.

Wrong again.

5:08

YouTube video

ARCTroopers FTW. And yes, Arcs ARE in the movies, as well as this canon part of the story..

w r

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Wrong again.

5:08

YouTube video

ARCTroopers FTW. And yes, Arcs ARE in the movies, as well as this canon part of the story..

I cannot view this evidence. Are you doing this on purpose ? iPad, killer.

So? It still proves it to everyone else.

"Faulty workmen blame their tools."

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
So? It still proves it to everyone else.

"Faulty workmen blame their tools."

I have an iPad and you purposely did so. Khan still wins despite your shenanigans.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I have an iPad and you purposely did so. Khan still wins despite your shenanigans.

Here's the link:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=WIj7gIDFDe4

Simply touch that link and it will open up the already included youtube application on your iPad and then play the movie. I don't like this way of doing things so I have an alternative for you, below.

If you want to view the embedded youtube videos from your iPad, when on KMC:

1. Hit the red play button in the center of the video in the person's post (such as Sadako's).
2. Watch the video (it will automatically open up in a different screen and start playing).
3. Hit "done" at the top left hand corner when you are done watching the video (it will take you back to KMC).

Originally posted by dadudemon
Here's the link:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=WIj7gIDFDe4

Simply touch that link and it will open up the already included youtube application on your iPad and then play the movie. I don't like this way of doing things so I have an alternative for you, below.

If you want to view the embedded youtube videos from your iPad, when on KMC:

1. Hit the red play button in the center of the video in the person's post (such as Sadako's).
2. Watch the video (it will automatically open up in a different screen and start playing).
3. Hit "done" at the top left hand corner when you are done watching the video (it will take you back to KMC).

This is different from how the lasers were portrayed in the movies. The cartoons are completely different IMO.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes, he sold the rights but he shot the scene

Originally posted by quanchi112
Lucas also doesn't own Star Wars any more. Do you not know what sold the rights actually means.

Great logic from Quan

Quan's logic > G-Canon.

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
He shot the scene and nothing has overruled his interpretation of the scene. No retcon has taken place, kiddo.

Originally posted by Kazenji
Great logic from Quan

Quan's logic > G-Canon.

It is obviously vastly different from the portrayals within the movies anyway. Be honest for a change.

Originally posted by quanchi112
He shot the scene and nothing has overruled his interpretation of the scene.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Lucas sold it.
Originally posted by quanchi112
You are right Windu is greater than the failure that was Yoda.

Whether Windu is greater or lesser than Yoda is irrelevant to the point I am making.

I claim that Yoda can reflect Khan's blaster fire (the small one, specifically) back at him, as we have seen him do before, and Khan has no real defense against this. You asking why Windu didn't do that against Jango is irrelevant to Yoda, just like other Jedi during Order 66 are irrelevant to Yoda.

So yeah. Can Khan do anything?

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
You concede then by replying like the brick wall that you are.

Originally posted by The Scenario
Whether Windu is greater or lesser than Yoda is irrelevant to the point I am making.

I claim that Yoda can reflect Khan's blaster fire (the small one, specifically) back at him, as we have seen him do before, and Khan has no real defense against this. You asking why Windu didn't do that against Jango is irrelevant to Yoda, just like other Jedi during Order 66 are irrelevant to Yoda.

So yeah. Can Khan do anything?

We have never seen him do so against someone as skilled as Khan. That's the point.

Skill level matters hence the point. M

Khan can shoot down Yoda. He has shown the accuracy while in battle to do so.