Originally posted by BloodRainThat is thread derailment. That's the point I've already said Marnie controls him. You want to derail threads into circular arguments.
Its a concession when i say im done, or 'nah' in your case. Death would win unopposed, you can't and won't counter, so that's that. Can move on back to the thread.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Well I do get around and make some noise.What we know is Marnie controls the dead and Death can be controlled. Pretty logical conclusion here.
That does not matter as people less powerful than Death have controlled him before. All ghosts are immortal and she bound Antonia to her. Awesome feat.
You are angry that all the evidence supports me and nothing supports you.
But it doesn't support anything your saying at all. In fact all you have to go on is that Sam and Dean have bound him and Marnie has not bound anything in his league which means that Magic in supernatural must be stronger then in TB. After all we clearly see Sam and Dean bind him and it takes God Cass to break it. So if you wanna argue from that point of view then not only has Marnie never pulled something like that off but there is nothing to prove she can put out that kind of strength........
I was personally going the route that Death isn't dead but either way there is no proof that she could bind him......
Originally posted by BlackZero30xNo, it does not. Prove they operate on a higher plane since salt and simple diagrams can bind them.
But it doesn't support anything your saying at all. In fact all you have to go on is that Sam and Dean have bound him and Marnie has not bound anything in his league which means that Magic in supernatural must be stronger then in TB. After all we clearly see Sam and Dean bind him and it takes God Cass to break it. So if you wanna argue from that point of view then not only has Marnie never pulled something like that off but there is nothing to prove she can put out that kind of strength........I was personally going the route that Death isn't dead but either way there is no proof that she could bind him......
She controls the dead. He's death.
Yes, he can be bound and she can bind dead beings due to necromancy. She controls him.
Originally posted by quanchi112Then concession til otherwise, you continuing this with BlackZero says you still think its arguable but will still refuse to answer my question for 'derailment'. So unless you can answer why being the title means he is the state, a state he only governs over.. you see my point.
That is thread derailment. That's the point I've already said Marnie controls him. You want to derail threads into circular arguments.
New strat to add to the others: Eve 'works out' a vampire trapped in hell, comes back later and shuts down all vamps powers. :T
Originally posted by quanchi112
No, it does not. Prove they operate on a higher plane since salt and simple diagrams can bind them.She controls the dead. He's death.
Yes, he can be bound and she can bind dead beings due to necromancy. She controls him.
Actually it does proves exactly what I say lol My proof is this....
Sam and Dean bound Death and you can't show anyone near his power level that Marnie has controlled......
So whatever they did with that "salt and diagrams" was clearly more powerful. I can't believe that you are perusing this. You don't seem to have a grasp on how levels of power work. You say "Prove they operate on a higher plane since salt and simple diagrams can bind them." trying to talk their binding method down. Point is Death is as I said a primordial being of enormous power that can exist on any plane he wants and can grant life and death as he wishes. If "Salt and Diagrams" were able to bind him then that means those are items of power in magic in the SN universe and not in the TB universe. In fact almost all different shows or books like these have different rules regarding magic and how it works.
Prove to me Necromancy can even affect Death from SN, Prove to me That death is Dead other then the terrible argument of "Hes the concept", Prove to me he can be controlled by anything but the spell used.
Ooh and btw the "Salt and Diagrams" isn't how he was bound anyways 😉
Originally posted by BloodRainI will get the last word in with this guy.
Then concession til otherwise, you continuing this with BlackZero says you still think its arguable but will still refuse to answer my question for 'derailment'. So unless you can answer why being the title means he is the state, a state he only governs over.. you see my point.New strat to add to the others: Eve 'works out' a vampire trapped in hell, comes back later and shuts down all vamps powers. :T
Marnie controls all the dead characters and they kill each other. 😂
Originally posted by BlackZero30xIf someone weaker than Marnie can control Death then so can Marnie. I was just using that as a reference of weaker characters than Marnie doing so.
Actually it does proves exactly what I say lol My proof is this....Sam and Dean bound Death and you can't show anyone near his power level that Marnie has controlled......
So whatever they did with that "salt and diagrams" was clearly more powerful. I can't believe that you are perusing this. You don't seem to have a grasp on how levels of power work. You say "Prove they operate on a higher plane since salt and simple diagrams can bind them." trying to talk their binding method down. Point is Death is as I said a primordial being of enormous power that can exist on any plane he wants and can grant life and death as he wishes. If "Salt and Diagrams" were able to bind him then that means those are items of power in magic in the SN universe and not in the TB universe. In fact almost all different shows or books like these have different rules regarding magic and how it works.
Prove to me Necromancy can even affect Death from SN, Prove to me That death is Dead other then the terrible argument of "Hes the concept", Prove to me he can be controlled by anything but the spell used.
Ooh and btw the "Salt and Diagrams" isn't how he was bound anyways 😉
If humans can control Death then why can't a more powerful character with power over the dead ?
The answer is clear you just say nuh uh. Common sense dictates Marnie controls him since humans can who really have in power level.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Yeah, he is a real troublemaker.
lol, we both know I was talking about you. I thought even you would put more effort in to a deflection like that.
Also, you really should watch Supernatural. Your arguments about Death make no sense at this point, tbh. That's not even me having a go at you; they're actually factually incorrect and using bad logic.