Heralds CIS off Battle!!! Who Comes Out as The Winner?

Surfer

Thor

Superman

Kyle

No weakness exploiting. Straight up war!!! Fight takes place in open space. Pre Reboot versions of DC characters.

CIS-free? Surfer wins this.

Surfboard makes salami out of Kyle, Superman gets dumped into another dimension and Thor gets Loki'd until Surfer's ready to kill him.

Superman wins

CIS off doesn't mean forum avatar.

That said, Superman or Surfer.

Originally posted by -Pr-
CIS off doesn't mean forum avatar.

Understood 👆

My reason for giving it to Clark in this instance is due to the "no weakness exploitation" stipulation.

Likely Surfer, though I've usually sided with Thor in similar threads. Either could win, as could Kal.

Lol at Kyle being here. At least send Hal...he'd be less of a sacrificial lamb in this context.

Originally posted by Odekahn
Understood 👆

My reason for giving it to Clark in this instance is due to the "no weakness exploitation" stipulation.

Surfer and Thor doesn't have weaknesses and they also have more, far more powers to call upon. Thor has everything everyone else have on the battlefield, including the the ability of being just as versatile as Surfer.

I'm giving this to Thor.

Originally posted by carver9
Surfer and Thor doesn't have weaknesses and they also have more, far more powers to call upon. Thor has everything everyone else have on the battlefield, including the the ability of being just as versatile as Surfer.

I'm giving this to Thor.

Surfer's definitely the most versatile and he has demonstrated the more imaginative applications of his powers than Thor (Superman's done crazy things with his H-V and other powers, but overall he's not very versatile).

Originally posted by carver9
Surfer and Thor doesn't have weaknesses and they also have more, far more powers to call upon. Thor has everything everyone else have on the battlefield, including the the ability of being just as versatile as Surfer.

I'm giving this to Thor.

Has Surfer's powers ever been drained? If so, that's a weakness that could be exploited imo. And Thor is dependent on mjolnir, if he were to be cut off from it that's a tactic directed at a weakness.

But in this scenario there is no weakness exploitation, so I see the fight as an all out brawl. Superman has more tools under the conditions of this thread.

Surfer comes in a close 2nd imo, followed closely by Thor and then Kyle.

Originally posted by janus77
Thor's slower

Fair enough.

Originally posted by janus77
(much much slower),

Calm down, son.

Originally posted by janus77
less mobile,

How is this different than speed?

Originally posted by janus77
weaker overall and hasn't demonstrated half the powers Surfer's shown.

Aaaand here's where you jump the shark. Mjolnir has more powers than Mega Man on the final boss. And the "weaker" claim has contrary evidence on at least a couple occasions.

...

There's nothing wrong with backing Surfer in this thread. I did above. But overstatement doesn't suit such evenly matched combatants.

Superman or Surfer.

Either Superman or Thor.

Surfer would be too busy being a pussy, and Kyle is too squishy.

Superman.

Originally posted by Odekahn
Has Surfer's powers ever been drained? If so, that's a weakness that could be exploited imo. And Thor is dependent on mjolnir, if he were to be cut off from it that's a tactic directed at a weakness.

But in this scenario there is no weakness exploitation, so I see the fight as an all out brawl. Superman has more tools under the conditions of this thread.

Here you go debating crazy again. How is this going to turn into a brawl? Surfer have the fire power to put anyone down here. You must didn't read the comic where Surfer blasts was creating a black hole light yrs wide or him destroying planets, etc...you are crazy if you think Surfer can't drop anyone here with his fire power.

None of these people needs weakness exploiting to win. Surfer, Thor, Superman, and Kyle are powerful enough to hurt each other off strength alone, add in versatility and power output, this become outrageous with Thor and Surfer leading the crew.

Definitely Surfer. Most dangerous and lethal with CIS off and most well rounded With fewest weaknesses

Originally posted by carver9
Surfer

Thor

Superman

Kyle

No weakness exploiting. Straight up war!!! Fight takes place in open space. Pre Reboot versions of DC characters.

Superman or Thor
Then Surfer or Kyle.

Silver Surfer is vulnerable to a fist/hammer to the face tactic, proved more then once, and both Superman and Thor are quite good at this.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Superman or Thor
Then Surfer or Kyle.

Silver Surfer is vulnerable to a fist/hammer to the face tactic, proved more then once, and both Superman and Thor are quite good at this.

Since his rebirth when has Surfer been koed by fist? You have a LOT of fights to choose from because he has consistently fought Heralds since his upcoming as Galactus top Herald during his rebirth in Annihilation.

Ill be waiting.

Originally posted by carver9
Since his rebirth when has Surfer been koed by fist? You have a LOT of fights to choose from because he has consistently fought Heralds since his upcoming as Galactus top Herald during his rebirth in Annihilation.

Ill be waiting.

You can wait as much as you want. A weakened Thor dented his little skull and did quite well. Surfer will be beaten, by hammer and fist, like always.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
You can wait as much as you want. A weakened Thor dented his little skull and did quite well. Surfer will be beaten, by hammer and fist, like always.

😂

So a pissed Thor denying his skull is him being koed? You have to do better than that. Everyone here has been dropped more than Surfer has within the past 4 to 5 yrs. So your point of Surfer having a glass jaw is moot.