Heralds CIS off Battle!!! Who Comes Out as The Winner?

Originally posted by Odekahn
I'm debating crazy because I said I think it would turn into a brawl? Lol ok.

And the second part of your first paragraph suggests that you think a brawl is fighting... without firepower?

Why are you acting like I said Surfer isn't capable of hurting anyone based solely on firepower?

Back on topic. Who do you think will win and why?

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
As said, you don't like it, it aint my problem. It's canon 100%. And you do the same with Hulk, someone saying asteroid?!

The reason I'm asking for fts during and after Annihilation is because Surfer received a power increased since his rebirth. Now again, when did Surfer get koed?

Originally posted by carver9
Again I ask, when has Surfer ever been defeated since annihilation in a fist cuff match. This is a simple question my friend.

Absolutely meaningless question.

I haven't been killed by gunfire, and I've been around guns. Am I suddenly incapable of being killed by guns?

Is it just me or does Carvers...Voice... Sound different?

Originally posted by -Pr-
Absolutely meaningless question.

I haven't been killed by gunfire, and I've been around guns. Am I suddenly incapable of being killed by guns?

The difference is, Surfer has faced Heralds and has been blasted, hit in the face with Mjlonir strikes, punched in the face by someone who was absorbing an entire planet into himself...he has faced beings within the caliber of the people in this thread, some above and he endured all of it, hell, he brushed it off. With that said, getting up close and personal with Surfer isn't the deciding factor for this fight because he can hang, hell, he would probably gain an advantage throughout some of the exchange but when you add in everything else he is capable of and what he can do, the thoughts of his abilities becomes limitless.

Batman Prime said Surfer has a glass Jaw so I'm asking him, during and after Surfer rebirth, when has he been koed by a punch. This is a simple question.

Also, Batman Prime...please read.

Originally posted by maxivitopowe
Is it just me or does Carvers...Voice... Sound different?

Sound like Barry White?

Originally posted by carver9
Back on topic. Who do you think will win and why?

Because I think this hinders everyone else in the field more than Superman. His weaknesses are what make him not... less, completely over the top.

Surfer Wins
Thor
Superman
G.L

Down to Surfer and Thor. Good thread. It's definitely down to these two.

Originally posted by carver9
The difference is, Surfer has faced Heralds and has been blasted, hit in the face with Mjlonir strikes, punched in the face by someone who was absorbing an entire planet into himself...he has faced beings within the caliber of the people in this thread, some above and he endured all of it, hell, he brushed it off. With that said, getting up close and personal with Surfer isn't the deciding factor for this fight because he can hang, hell, he would probably gain an advantage throughout some of the exchange but when you add in everything else he is capable of and what he can do, the thoughts of his abilities becomes limitless.

Batman Prime said Surfer has a glass Jaw so I'm asking him, during and after Surfer rebirth, when has he been koed by a punch. This is a simple question.

Also, Batman Prime...please read.

still means absolutely nothing. you're trying to apply a no-limits fallacy when you know it can't be done.

Originally posted by Odekahn
Because I think this hinders everyone else in the field more than Superman. His weaknesses are what make him not... less, completely over the top.

I thought you was a versatility guy? You tend to use that a lot when its involving a certain character. With that said, Surfer and Thor is by far the most versatile on the field. Not downing your judgement, trying to get an understanding of it since you play that card a lot during 99.9% of our debates.

Originally posted by carver9
The difference is, Surfer has faced Heralds and has been blasted, hit in the face with Mjlonir strikes, punched in the face by someone who was absorbing an entire planet into himself...he has faced beings within the caliber of the people in this thread, some above and he endured all of it, hell, he brushed it off. With that said, getting up close and personal with Surfer isn't the deciding factor for this fight because he can hang, hell, he would probably gain an advantage throughout some of the exchange but when you add in everything else he is capable of and what he can do, the thoughts of his abilities becomes limitless.

Batman Prime said Surfer has a glass Jaw so I'm asking him, during and after Surfer rebirth, when has he been koed by a punch. This is a simple question.

Also, Batman Prime...please read.

The Great one gets greater

Originally posted by -Pr-
still means absolutely nothing. you're trying to apply a no-limits fallacy when you know it can't be done.

I understand that but it proves that his opinion of Surfer is, how can I say it? False!!!!!

Originally posted by carver9
I understand that but it proves that his opinion of Surfer is, how can I say it? False!!!!!

You being wrong makes his opinion false?

Originally posted by carver9
I thought you was a versatility guy? You tend to use that a lot when its involving a certain character. With that said, Surfer and Thor is by far the most versatile on the field. Not downing your judgement, trying to get an understanding of it since you play that card a lot during 99.9% of our debates.

I said Superman had more tools in this situation, aka more versatility.

Originally posted by Odekahn
I said Superman had more tools in this situation, aka more versatility.

😂

Originally posted by -Pr-
You being wrong makes his opinion false?

Im not wrong though...I'm not seeing a post from him that counters my argument.

Are Carver and Pr brothers? I keep getting the bullying elder brother vibe from Pr's exchanges with Carver ... 😕

Originally posted by zopzop
There's a reason writers make Surfer fight like a moron "in character", because if he fought to the best of his abilities, it would take a skyfather level being to stop him.

Surfer wins.

Originally posted by h1a8
I agree. But Superman singing people out of existence just takes the cake.