Ben Kenobi vs Count Dooku

Started by Jmanghan13 pagesPoll

Who takes this?

Ben Kenobi vs Count Dooku

Setting takes place on the ship where they fought in ROTS, though remember that this is ANH Kenobi, Ben Kenobi, not Obi-Wan Kenobi.

Round 1 - Sabers
Round 2 - Force Abilities
Round 3 - All-Out

Who takes this?

Tyranus curbstomps all three. Mismatch.

He certainly doesn't curbstomp in sabers.. this much I know for sure

Yes he does Ben Kenobi isn't even ROTS Kenobi level at this point. He curbstomps all 3

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Yes he does Ben Kenobi isn't even ROTS Kenobi level at this point. He curbstomps all 3
The hell are you talking about? He's above ROTS Kenobi, just his simple comments can make you see that. "If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful then you can possibly imagine." AND "You can't win, Darth." Obi-Wan isn't one to over-exaggerate.

Ben is not more powerful then his ROTS self, where did you get that fanfiction from?

Originally posted by NTJack0
Ben is not more powerful then his ROTS self, where did you get that fanfiction from?
Oops, I guess Obi-Wan somehow grew weaker between the events of ROTS and ANH, even though it is heavily implied that its the opposite, I guess all that training with two of the most Jedi Master's in the Jedi Order was all for naught, right?

Originally posted by Intrepid37
What quote is that from?

Insider #62: Fightsaber.

^ Dooku>ROTS Kenobi>ANH Kenobi

That was out before ROTS was made, in 2002, and at the end of the ROTS movie, Obi-Wan was about to begin rigorous training with Yoda and Qui-Gon. It
makes absolutely no sense to include that in the movie if it has no relevance to Ben Kenobi's power. Everyone in this forum keeps arguing that "They just said it, to say it, therfore its just there to be there, in general" No, everything that is said in all the Star Wars movies is true, its not just said to be said, it actually means something and is relevant. Obi-Wan is told he is going to be trained by Qui-Gon again at the end of ROTS, and we know canonically that during the gap between ROTS and ANH, Kenobi had trained with Yoda as well. I doubt Yoda just went Mr. Miyagi style and just said "Paint my Dagobah house" No, he trained him, so you mean to tell me that despite all that training through about 19 years meant absolutely nothing?????

Kenobi was trained by Qui-Gon so he could learn how to be a Force ghost.

The source stands. It has never been retconned by anything.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Kenobi was trained by Qui-Gon so he could learn how to be a Force ghost.

The source stands. It has never been retconned by anything.

Then how come Anakin became a force ghost? If you have to be "Trained"

I'd say that Vader being a shadow of his former self has been conclusively retconned by The Force Unleashed and other sources, myself. Kenobi though....

Nah. Vader at the time lost to Maul. Also Vader was equal with only equal with Kenobi so there.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Then how come Anakin became a force ghost? If you have to be "Trained"

I believe he was taught to after Sidious got destroyed.

That may not have been really Maul. It was an ambiguous clone thing. Plus it was only in pure lightsabers. Most of Vaders strength comes from being stupidly good with the Force.

I know. But Vader might find it hard to employ TK against an opponent as aggressive as Maul, at least when he's behind in skill.

I'd say its more just PIS. Vader should have used TK more. Especially since iirc theres plenty of times when theres the opportunity to use it i.e. when Mauls gloating like an utter retard.

Plus reading it again, Vader does pretty well actually. He cuts his saber in half (again).

That's not the whole fight. And Vader used TK to have the blasters shoot at Maul.

IIRC Path of Destruction heavily explores that it depends on the situation. Likewise Maul is far more powerful than Obi-Wan but they fought for a minute without Maul using TK at all. Same goes for Starkiller. He is more powerful than any of his opponents but was still losing his duels because of inferior skill.