Itachi vs Dr Manhattan

Started by SSJGGogeta6 pages
Originally posted by Quincy
I'm not sure that Doctor Manhattan CAN die. He just atomizes Itachi. /thread

He can die, but not from any means that Itachi could even fathom. His Amaterasu is "as hot as the sun", but Manhattan literally WALKED on the sun before.

Itachi has literally NOTHING he can do here.

Originally posted by StealthRanger
People are seriously arguing for Itachi *looks at usernames*

Well I can't say I'm totally surprised

Right?

I'm with Gogeta ^

This thread is nonsense.

i think dr manhattan would win a majority of the times but i also think itachi can win a couple times.

I dont know, killer. The good doctor lives all of time at once, realistically speaking he's ALREADY stomped Itachi countless times.

Originally posted by SSJGGogeta
He can die, but not from any means that Itachi could even fathom. His Amaterasu is "as hot as the sun", but Manhattan literally WALKED on the sun before.

Itachi has literally NOTHING he can do here.

Yes. I can think of fictional characters that can handle Dr. Manhattan, but it is not a long list, and Itachi is not on it.

I can name lots of characters who would bully Dr. Manhattan.

No you can't.

just remember as powerful dr. manhattan is very melancholy and he very conflicted within. he blames himself for literally almost everything wrong is his life.

Originally posted by Q99
Yes. I can think of fictional characters that can handle Dr. Manhattan, but it is not a long list, and Itachi is not on it.

No question.

Although, how powerful is he, really? A lot of people play him up like he's trans tier, above Green Lanterns or someone like Silver Surfer, when his list of feats is actually pretty sparse..

More then Itachi could handle, either way.

Originally posted by chasedown
just remember as powerful dr. manhattan is very melancholy and he very conflicted within. he blames himself for literally almost everything wrong is his life.

And? All that means is that Itachi gets romped endlessly by an apathetic malcontent.

Originally posted by Sacred 117
And? All that means is that Itachi gets romped endlessly by an apathetic malcontent.

his confliction would be his main weakness when it comes to getting out of izanami.... just playing devils advocate

Originally posted by chasedown
his confliction would be his main weakness when it comes to getting out of izanami.... just playing devils advocate

You've been told already. He doesn't need to get out of it because he's already out, and that's assuming it would work OR that Itachi could even process the thought in time.

oh yea def izanami would only work if hes able to set dr. into a loop...... likelyhood of it occuring very small but possible

Originally posted by chasedown
oh yea def izanami would only work if hes able to set dr. into a loop...... likelyhood of it occuring very small but possible

Actually, no. Nothing he can do would put Manhattan in a loop given that he experiences time through a non-linear perspective, and simultaneously living in the present, future, AND past doesn't help Itachi's case even slightly. Not only would Itachi not know what to do, but the Doctor would know what he's going to do before he did and simply turn him to glass with a twitch of his eyebrow before he had a chance to think about it.

There's five pages of this. This is embarassing.

At the end of the series Manhattan isn't even really conflicted, he came out of things with a new outlook towards life.

Originally posted by cdtm
No question.

Although, how powerful is he, really? A lot of people play him up like he's trans tier, above Green Lanterns or someone like Silver Surfer, when his list of feats is actually pretty sparse..

Well, it's almost impossible to kill him (harder to kill than GLs), he can be in many places at once, erase people with a gesture, it was estimated he could stop, iirc, 70+% of Russia's nuclear arsenal (so, thousands of missiles), can create life, has the non linear time thing...

His power output may very well be smaller than a GL, but he's so versatile and, again, basically immortal, that his flexibility is greater and it's quite hard to score a win.

And one thing I want to mention, his power is still *growing*. As his understanding of physics increases, so do his abilities. He still learns new tricks. Being in multiple places at once was a newly developed technique of his. The 'stop 70+% of Russia's nukes' was, likely, conservative and based on old data. His limits are still unknown.

Originally posted by Quincy
There's five pages of this. This is embarassing.

I couldn't agree more. 👆

To be fair with the non linear time thing, it has no baring on a fight since he can't alter what he experiences in the future in the present. He always does what is supposed to happen.

So just not really something worth bringing up in arguments. Since he can't like change battle plans or anything, he has no free will.

That's fair

Seems that way.

Whether it's apathy, Genis-vell like madness, or a simple inability to change events like The Source entity (Or Sarda, for those familiar with 8 bit theater.)