Obi Wan Kenobi vs Darth Malgus

Started by Nephthys6 pages

No mistake was made. A comparison between them shows no advantage to Dooku. TK? No difference. Dueling? Dooku. Lightning? Malgus.

Originally posted by Nephthys
No mistake was made. A comparison between them shows no advantage to Dooku. TK? No difference. Dueling? Dooku. Lightning? Malgus.

Nah Dooku takes TK, dueling and lightning.

I'm sorry, I thought we were being serious. But I guess Malgus godstomps Dooku and puts Ventress in her place (on his dick) atop his corpse.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I'm sorry, I thought we were being serious. But I guess Malgus godstomps Dooku and puts Ventress in her place (on his dick) atop his corpse.

Dooku gets TK scaling from Savage via the orbalisk feat, and from Anakin considering he's blasted through his defenses several times. And Anakin's TK feats trump Malgus'. In lightning Dooku has lightning on par with Malgus' until he becomes Emperor, and he's a superior duelist.

Malgus tossing aside a mountain of rubble while wounded is every bit equal to Dooku lifting those obalisks. Eh, Dooku hasn't overpowered Anakin is straight TK often. Plus Malgus and Leneer > Anakin in TK too. God no does Anakin trump Malgus there, he doesn't even trump that nameless Zabrak Jedi. Dooku's lightning has absolutely nothing putting it on par with Malgus' and he's not superior by much in dueling.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Malgus tossing aside a mountain of rubble while wounded is every bit equal to Dooku lifting those obalisks. Eh, Dooku hasn't overpowered Anakin is straight TK often. Plus Malgus and Leneer > Anakin in TK too. God no does Anakin trump Malgus there, he doesn't even trump that nameless Zabrak Jedi. Dooku's lightning has absolutely nothing putting it on par with Malgus' and he's not superior by much in dueling.

Not really if 2 are roughly equal to a shuttle. Not to mention the feat I already posted from Anakin.

Nope they are not. Aside from killing like 6-7 force sensitives in a single blast? As of Decieved? He's pretty far above Malgus.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Not really if 2 are roughly equal to a shuttle. Not to mention the feat I already posted from Anakin.

Nope they are not. Aside from killing like 6-7 force sensitives in a single blast? As of Decieved? He's pretty far above Malgus.

Yeah really, since throwing something is far superior to just lifting it. Savage moved the shuttle after he'd figured out his power and could lift the obalisks (while being zapped by lightning). Even before then he was partially lifting 4 of them.

Yes they are. Yeah, aside from killing some weak as hell mooks with no defenses. No, he's not. Apprentice Malgus beat Kao who I put at about Kit Fisto level. By Deceived Malgus is at least on par with CW Anakin. At least.

Not at all. Malgus is roughly Maul level in Decieved. Dooku is superior to Maul.

👆

Malgus, as of Deceived, is equal to Maul?

Some people have lost their minds and evaluation abilities as well.

Malgus is in a different league then both Maul and Dooku. Book of Sith: Secrets of the Dark Side makes it clear that Bane, Malgus, Talzin, Syn and Plagueis are among the greatest of the dark lords in history. Malgus, in particular, have been noted to be unparalleled in combat prowess.

something I find funny is how people compare Malgus to both Dooku and Vader. that's like comparing someone to kit fisto and then mace windu.

Dooku is not to Vader as Fisto is to Windu. They're much closer than that.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Dooku is not to Vader as Fisto is to Windu. They're much closer than that.
Yes but the point remains, they are on different levels. Personally think Malgus is above Dooku but below Vader

Originally posted by WildBantha88
Yes but the point remains, they are on different levels. Personally think Malgus is above Dooku but below Vader

I agree with that assessment.

Originally posted by WildBantha88
Yes but the point remains, they are on different levels. Personally think Malgus is above Dooku but below Vader

Vader isn't better then Malgus and no where this have been implied.

In-fact, Book of Sith - Secrets of the Dark Side implies that Malgus is superior to Vader as well; through the perceptions of Sidious, this had been implied.

Malgus was so strong that he single-handedly won many battles. His battlefield feats have never been duplicated as per Sidious. He also have history of destroying powerful opponents, something that Vader found to be extremely difficult regardless of the hype surrounding him.

Vader was extremely good but he was handicapped in his abilities after his injuries and Malgus have no such restrictions. Malgus continued to grow in power with passage of time.

I put Malgus above Vader, though only during his tenure as Emperor, where his strength in the force was rather monstrous.

The way I see it, pre-Aleema Malgus is slightly inferior to Maul, while post-Aleema Malgus is slightly superior to him.

Emperor Malgus is probably just a cut under Dooku.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
The way I see it, pre-Aleema Malgus is slightly inferior to Maul, while post-Aleema Malgus is slightly superior to him.

Emperor Malgus is probably just a cut under Dooku.


You don't pay attention or do you?

Why would someone as great as Sidious would be inspired by Malgus if his own apprentices were better then the latter? I mean common sense is really lacking, right?

Malgus is in a different league in comparison to Maul, Dooku and Vader. Deal with it.

Malgus is too much for Kenobi.

LOL at people comparing Maul to Malgus. He destroyed Darach(far superior to Qui Gon, or Kenobi for that matter) in an enraged state well BEFORE his prime.

Kenobi would fare better than Zallow but I can't give him more than that.

Bump

Malgus in a close fight.