Obi Wan Kenobi vs Darth Malgus

Started by Deronn_solo6 pages
Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I put Malgus above Vader

Heh.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Kenobi would fare better than Zallow but I can't give him more than that.

You act like faring better than Zallow isn't in the ballpark of winning.

Malgus in a brutal as **** fight

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I put Malgus above Vader

RotS Obi-Wan should win, tbh.

Kenobi has more skill but Malgus would still beat the shit out of him. He's had trouble with Savage's strength before and Gus is probably stronger than him

Originally posted by SunRazer
RotS Obi-Wan should win, tbh.

Seriously? Malgus one-shot Aryn Leneer, one-shot a Jedi who collapsed two buildings with the Force and choked out 3 members of the Strike Team while fighting the fourth. After he'd TK slapped them and zapped them to their knees. He destroyed a squad of starfighters with a Force Scream, his lightning can burn holes through Jedi at the least and Sidious claims that his battlefield feats have never been equaled.

Meanwhile Kenobi is routinely made a fool of by Dooku and thrown around by Maul. He simply cannot compete with Malgus' Force powers.

Also choked by Ventress and placed in stasis, but he can blow up Durge so that means no one other than Maul can ragdoll him cuz reasons

God I enjoy just how much ignorance of context people like to spew out; when Asajj did what she did to Kenobi, he was breathing a toxin that would damn near melted the lungs of a Jedi Master(it took all of said Master's strength to keep it from eating him from the inside out).

And Dooku and Maul making fools out of him, would be more of a good feat for them. I can just as easily say Aryn isn't impressive, because she got TKed by Malgus.

Obi wins.

Kenobi twerks.

Originally posted by MythLord
God I enjoy just how much ignorance of context people like to spew out; when Asajj did what she did to Kenobi, he was breathing a toxin that would damn near melted the lungs of a Jedi Master(it took all of said Master's strength to keep it from eating him from the inside out).

And Dooku and Maul making fools out of him, would be more of a good feat for them. I can just as easily say Aryn isn't impressive, because she got TKed by Malgus.

Obi wins.

She also choked them him out again while he was unharmed/with Anakin, but ok he obviously can't do it when that's not the only example. Kenobi's track record doesn't really support your statement, but ok.

Malgus obviously can't tool him where every other darksider can.

Gonna go with Malgus.

Malgus. The Force gap is noticeably bigger than the one in sabers.

Actually, I'm on the fence now regarding how Malgus can take him down with the Force.

Malgus is a very clear superior to Kenobi in the Force, search your feelings Nova, you know it to be true.

I know Malgus is stronger. I'm just not sure if he can ragdoll RotS Obi-Wan. Are there any quotes for how much Obi-Wan's improved since TCW?

According to Dooku he improved as a swordsman, his most impressive feat by far is deflecting Vader's TK blasts in the novel though. But Malgus was ragdolling the strike team that killed Revan two chapters earlier, like seriously Nova.

I don't count Malgus' Strike Team Choking. And that isn't necessary to make a case for him ragdolling Obi-Wan, tbh.

But you take unsubstantiated cut content seriously mmm

Makes total sense an enraged Ventress can choke him out, versus an enraged. Malgus before his prime who can blow up Ships/shake entire buildings with force screams who can't

Is there any quote that says he became more powerful as of ROTS?