bluewaterrider
Senior Member
Originally posted by MF DELPH
An assertion without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. I don't know how life began nor am I claiming to know. Simply asserting that a being which you can not provide any evidence to demonstrate it's existence as the cause doesn't make that position rational, particularly when you can simply assert the same claim for any other agent. What makes the Abrahamic God a more viable answer than Krishna or Amon-Ra, or simply that existence has always existed? It's essentially equivalent to asserting when my car malfunctions and I can't immediately determine what the actual cause is that Gremlins did it. That isn't a rational position.
The problem with a lot of this conversation is that:
1) You're using cliches and not actually thinking about what I'm saying or even what you yourself are saying.
2) You're preceding from the a priori assumption that the secular mainstream assertion HAS to be true, HAS to be the starting point, and nothing else can be.
3) You expand the definition of "natural" as suits you.
In regards to your car, that's not an equivalent example. You can simply go to a mechanic where they can examine your car and determine what's making it malfunction.
(As an aside, I've often found that, no matter what your problem is, if you voice your trouble in the hearing of the RIGHT person your problem is on its way to getting solved. The trick is to discover WHO that "right" person is, for scenario A often needs person A to solve while scenario B often needs person B and NOT person A to solve it.)
With your gremlins example, Midas can tell you very quickly what is wrong.
Note that they thoroughly examine the car. They have a guide as to what a car looks like. They have knowledge as to how a car should work and how the different pieces interact together. They are experts on investigating and solving car problems.
Do we have the equivalent for my life question?
Is there some expert I can go to and get the answer to my question?
Could I get an answer to my question even if I changed it to, "Show me someone who can make life from truly non-alive TODAY"?
What are you looking at that tells you the answer to THAT question can be found in science even 20 or 30 years from now?