Originally posted by Stoic
Did Superman defeat the real Darkseid? Huge unknown.HP Doomsday at his most powerful was well above Superman weight class.
Superboy Prime was intended to be above Superman. He even killed an elder version of the same character in that same scene that you are talking about while taking on Superman himself (weakened or not).
The things that you are bringing up can also be applied to other well known High Heralds as they too have defeated enemies well above their weight class. Should I place Thor in the Low-Mid Trans range, because of what he did during Blood & Thunder while not having the Power Gem? Of course not. We saw how a true Trans (Thanos) dealt with him.
Look at how Synnar took on Superman, Orion, J'onn, and a couple others during Hardcore Station. That's what power level a Trans tier character operates at. Unless you are saying that Superman was holding back against a universal menace that could take his best punches, and in turn flatten him out? All the same, Black Adam is not as powerful as Superman in any regard, but he can hang with him for a time at his base levels. He's 2x base in this thread, and there is no reason that he shouldn't win here IMO.
Yes, it was the real Darkseid. It led into the subsequent storylines that involved him getting free of the Source Wall, then him regaining the Omega Power, and eventually directly into the Death of the New Gods and Final Crisis.
Superman went toe to toe with Hunter Prey and eventually won via plot device, but Doomsday couldn't keep Superman down either. He also outlasted Darkseid in this story.
Synnar the architect of the universe? lol.
Superman beating these beings isn't him punching above his weight class. These aren't once in a lifetime events like Thor reaching outside of his.
What year did Superman beat Darkseid in Superman/Batman?
What year did Superman beat Darkseid over the soul of Steel?
When did Superman defeat Superboy Prime?
What year did Superman defeat Cythonna, the Kryptponian godess?
What year did Superman stop Imperiex?
What year did Superman stop Dominus?
What year did Superman beat Blaze, who eventually took over Hell?
What year did Superman wrestle Azmodel?
What year did Superman beat the god Apollo?
What year did Superman beat ---
You know, Thor's feats without being powered up just flat out don't measure up to Superman, let alone the laundry list of victories. It's just different brackets. He has to swing high against Superman's lows to even be near the same bracket.
Comparing Thor to Superman is like comparing Cyborg to Superman.
When was Blood and Thunder? 1993?
Thor or Surfer goes up against a god or high end cosmic, they're like ants.
Thanos goes against gods or high end cosmic, he get slapped down.
Superman goes up against gods or high end cosmic, he spins in a circle and wins.