Mjolnir vs. Enchantment

Started by h1a810 pages
Originally posted by burrrrrr
No, magic is not science or even logical...not in a comic book where the rules and logic within the story are always controlled and changed by the whim of forces (writers) outside of the story
It seems that, for the unworthy, the hammer ignores strength altogether for the purpose of lifting. Sufficiently powerful cosmic or magical beings like Odin or Molecule Man can certainly override the enchantment. A physically strong enough being could just crush the hammer as well. You're not going to get a perfectly logical explanation until one is created in story.

Irrelevant!

To claim that Mjolnir can not be lifted due to a magical spell is valid. But to claim Mjolnir can't be broken with physical force is wrong. Mjolnir has been broken with pure physical force before. So either the character lifts it or just breaks Mjolnir without lifting it.

Originally posted by h1a8
Irrelevant!

To claim that Mjolnir can not be lifted due to a magical spell is valid. But to claim Mjolnir can't be broken with physical force is wrong. Mjolnir has been broken with pure physical force before. So either the character lifts it or just breaks Mjolnir without lifting it.

Scans?

Originally posted by riv6672
Yeah this keeps going into areas that dont matter here. On pure strength, the hammer isnt moving.
Then the hammer breaks. Isn't this common sense?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Scans?
Scans of what?

Originally posted by h1a8
Scans of what?

Your imaginary character doing anything.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Your imaginary character doing anything.
All characters are imaginary. Why troll?

Originally posted by h1a8
All characters are imaginary. Why troll?

Soooo lemme get this straight. Your character has no limits to srrength..durability..he's immortal..has an indestructible platform..indestructible leverage etc. And u want him to attempt to lift mjolnir but only within your two preordained parameters? Which as it is goes against everything weve already witnessed because as u well know mjolnir has never been lifted by strength alone. Yet IM trolling?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Soooo lemme get this straight. Your character has no limits to srrength..durability..he's immortal..has an indestructible platform..indestructible leverage etc. And u want him to attempt to lift mjolnir but only within your two preordained parameters? Which as it is goes against everything weve already witnessed because as u well know mjolnir has never been lifted by strength alone. Yet IM trolling?
You are trolling.

Mjolnir not being lifted by this personification of a no limits fallacy is a no limits fallacy.

Originally posted by Mindset
You are trolling.

Mjolnir not being lifted by this personification of a no limits fallacy is a no limits fallacy.

😂

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Soooo lemme get this straight. Your character has no limits to srrength..durability..he's immortal..has an indestructible platform..indestructible leverage etc. And u want him to attempt to lift mjolnir but only within your two preordained parameters? Which as it is goes against everything weve already witnessed because as u well know mjolnir has never been lifted by strength alone. Yet IM trolling?
If Mjolnir can't be lifted then it breaks. Just vote that it breaks. It's not hard.

Do you believe Mjolnir breaks?

Originally posted by Mindset
You are trolling.

Mjolnir not being lifted by this personification of a no limits fallacy is a no limits fallacy.

Then you agree that Mjolnir breaks?

Originally posted by h1a8
Then you agree that Mjolnir breaks?
I agree with everything you've ever said regarding comics.

Originally posted by Mindset
I agree with everything you've ever said regarding comics.
Thank you. I appreciate it.

Originally posted by h1a8
Thank you. I appreciate it.
No problem, man.

Originally posted by Mindset
I agree with everything you've ever said regarding comics.

Brown noser

Originally posted by Time-Immemorial
Brown noser
h1a8 doesn't poop.

He is an angel sent down from heaven to teach us about comics.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
If he is trying to lift it with STRENGTH alone then no he cannot. y are u going off topic

Haha, what? So you are saying Odin is more powerful than Beyonder?

Originally posted by h1a8
If Mjolnir can't be lifted then it breaks. Just vote that it breaks. It's not hard.

Do you believe Mjolnir breaks?

I agree that you're a dumbass

Originally posted by abhilegend
Haha, what? So you are saying Odin is more powerful than Beyonder?

When did i say that? I said if beyonder tried lifting mjolnir with strength alone hed fail. Has mjolnir been lifted by strength alone? Stop being so coy abhi..if u wanna dance just ask stop beating around the bush

Originally posted by Sin I AM
I agree that you're a dumbass

When did i say that? I said if beyonder tried lifting mjolnir with strength alone hed fail. Has mjolnir been lifted by strength alone? Stop being so coy abhi..if u wanna dance just ask stop beating around the bush


Why not? If Beyonder fails against Odin's power, that means Odin is more powerful than him.

You are simply not understanding how comics work.

Originally posted by Mindset
h1a8 doesn't poop.

He is an angel sent down from heaven to teach us about comics.

He must not eat then. H1 recieves nourishment from sunlight.